Preview Rnd 12 Pies vs Dees (Queen's Birthday) - Changes and Prematch Discussion

[Yidaki]

Thoughts?

Ins: Reid, Ball, Swan
Outs: Maxy, Thomas (possibly), Sidebottoms

Should be another good win, but who knows what the Dees will throw up.

 

[SuperSub17]

If Josh Thomas gets dropped after that I will seriously spew up.

 

[SuperSub17]

Reid certainly needs a run in the VFL so for mine:
Out Maxwell Sidebottom
In Swan Ball

Edit: in fact forgot Grundy so maybe he comes in for Adams too, can't really have Thomas Ball and Adams in at once.

 

[Yidaki]

If Josh Thomas gets dropped after that I will seriously spew up.

He shouldn't, but who knows with the MRP. I expect that he won't. At the most it will be one week.

 

[Yidaki]

Reid certainly needs a run in the VFL so for mine:
Out Maxwell Sidebottom
In Swan Ball

Is Reid having a run in the VFL this weekend?

 

[SuperSub17]

Is Reid having a run in the VFL this weekend?

No VFL game unfortunately

 

[TheFreshBanana]

In: Swan, Broomhead, Kennedy
Out: Adams, Sidebottom, Maxwell

 

[SuperSub17]

He shouldn't, but who knows with the MRP. I expect that he won't. At the most it will be one week.

Ah sorry, shouldn't go for that though. Jones pretty much ducked into it and he pulled out of the bump.

 

[blaze036]

Edit* Thread already made, delete please mods.

 

[POKsPies252]

Out: Maxwell Sidebottom Adams
In: Grundy Swan Ball

For me the game is a ruck-off between Grundy and Witts because once Reid is back we should go with White as the 2nd ruck, showed tonight he can do well in that role.

 

[Shaneprice97]

Thomas no chance of getting dropped, hes a chance to poll brownlow votes, Adams could get dropped. Hopefully Seedsman stays in, gave great outside pace and used his kick well.

 

[Yidaki]

No VFL game unfortunately

Damn.

 

[SuperSub17]

Cloke was excellent. Back to his roaming best - 23 touches, 12 marks, 4 tackles and 5 goals 2.

Credit to him.

 

[Rustin Cohle]

I don't think Ball is an automatic inclusion.

 

[blaze036]

Thoughts?

Ins: Reid, Ball, Swan
Outs: Maxy, Thomas (possibly), Sidebottoms

Should be another good win, but who knows what the Dees will throw up.

Club has confirmed Reid will play 1-2 VFL games to comeback

In: Grundy Swan Dywer

Out: Adams Maxwell(inj) Sidebottom(sus)

No way Thomas gets dropped

 

[Da Main Man]

who comes in to cover maxy?

send goldy back?

 

[SApies]

OUTS: Sidebottom, Maxwell
INS: Swan, Karnezis

Goldsack to head into defence and PK up forward.
Think the more Adams gets a crack at it the better he'll get.
But if he were to get dropped I'd like to see Ben Kennedy or Broomhead in.

 

[Yidaki]

Club has confirmed Reid will play 1-2 VFL games to comeback

In: Grundy Swan Dywer

Out: Adams Maxwell(inj) Sidebottom(sus)

No way Thomas gets dropped

I forgot about Grundy.

 

[vjknight]

bloody dave

 

[piedpiper32]

I predict we won't be hearing any calls to drop Cloke this week
Or send him to full back
Or put him in for surgery

 

[dubber]

I actually think we need to persist with Adams.. If he is the heir apparent to Ball then he needs game time.

Out : Maxy, Sidebottom, Witts
In : Swan, Grundy, Dwyer

 

[blaze036]

OUTS: Sidebottom, Maxwell
INS: Swan, Karnezis

Goldsack to head into defence and PK up forward.
Think the more Adams gets a crack at it the better he'll get.
But if he were to get dropped I'd like to see Ben Kennedy or Broomhead in.

Karnezis has done his hammy... won't be playing AFL any time soon

 

[Da Main Man]

PK done a hammy?

 

[dubber]

Karnezis has done his hammy... won't be playing AFL any time soon

When did he do that?

 

[blaze036]

When did he do that?

Today apparently