Rnd 17 Trades

[vjknight]

The only way he'll get that low is if he spuds it up on his return, and if he does that you probably wouldn't want him. The last game he played he scored 98.

i understand that, BUT last time he resumed from injury he started as sub, and with the long layoff, i expect this time around will be same. has a huge BE at present, and so with first game say 60, 2nd game 100, he is likely to plummet to around 400k before resurging - hence my great interest in him.......in round 20.

 

[TheNextBigThing]

Stuff it, Smedts to Couch and Broughton to Shaw it is, leaves me with 1 trade and 139k in the bank, now to sit back and pray, good luck to all in a similar position

 

[Ed D]

i understand that, BUT last time he resumed from injury he started as sub, and with the long layoff, i expect this time around will be same. has a huge BE at present, and so with first game say 60, 2nd game 100, he is likely to plummet to around 400k before resurging - hence my great interest in him.......in round 20.

If you punch those numbers into tooserious he drops to $434k. I suppose it's not too far off $400k but is he going to start as the sub when he's been training well for a few weeks already and they're just waiting for his shoulder to be strong enough? I wouldn't be counting on him being $400k is all I'm saying.

 

[NSWCROW]

Well i've finally reached my supercoach Alamo..
2 trades left

OPTION 1 Jaensch>scotland ( Leaving 1 trade ( Jacob Brennan ) but upgrade optios are shite ...

OPTION 2 Jaensch>M Johnson + $$$$ and B Martin>Firrito and Bench Jacob Brennan........

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Couch or Sam Day?

Day will play every match...Couch may not

Dekisions

 

[laxation]

With Mohr, Clarke and now S Shaw out I'm left with a donut in defense.
With 6 trades left should I hold on or trade say Mohr and be left with 5 trades?

Trade definitely. Either upgrade if you have the $ or get Baguely.

If youre desperate for a win this week but dont have a lot of cash, get Yarran.
Goddard is cheap as chips too if you dont have him yet.

 

[The Made Guy]

i understand that, BUT last time he resumed from injury he started as sub, and with the long layoff, i expect this time around will be same. has a huge BE at present, and so with first game say 60, 2nd game 100, he is likely to plummet to around 400k before resurging - hence my great interest in him.......in round 20.

He didn't start as sub, he was subbed out.

 

[JustMe53]

I've got 4 trades left, thinking out marley Williams for couch and pfiffier to pendals leave me with 2 trades left 28grand. Full side but broughton and kruezz what people think?
My mids would be Watson swan body Mitchell ablett and pendals

 

[rocker_oz33]

broughton out baguley in.Either darley to lids or gilies to macvoy?

 

[rocker_oz33]

I've got 4 trades left, thinking out marley Williams for couch and pfiffier to pendals leave me with 2 trades left 28grand. Full side but broughton and kruezz what people think?
My mids would be Watson swan body Mitchell ablett and pendals

Whos body?

 

[JustMe53]

sorry boyd

 

[Propagandhi]

Wow, I got owned at the selection table this week. I've been quite smug recently thinking that my team had depth... now my bench with a full strength team includes:

Mohr, Shaw, D. Smith, Gibson, Redden, Stephenson, Adams, Dickson.

Most weeks I'd expect at least 6 of these to be playing. This week I only have the services of one of them! (Gibson)

I currently have Kreuzer, Judd and Franklin in my team. Should I:

1) Trade Judd to Goodes and use Goodes' MPP to avoid a 0 this week
2) Trade Judd to Murphy and cop the extra 0 for this week

I think I'd rather have Marc Murphy as M6 than Goodes, but is it worth the donut that would give me this week?

TLDR; Marc Murphy + donut this week vs Goodes

 

[rocker_oz33]

What about the heavy tag on murph with no judd.both players great value

 

[Propagandhi]

What about the heavy tag on murph with no judd.both players great value

Myeah, but wasn't Murph copping the tags earlier in the year and coping ok? I reckon I'll go Goodes but he just scares me as he can go missing in the forward line...

 

[Burzum]

Out: Kreuzer, Mohr
In: Roughead, Baguley

 

[Propagandhi]

broughton out baguley in.Either darley to lids or gilies to macvoy?

Does Darley to Lids save a donut this week? Either way I think I like Darley to Lids better. Lids really is a must have.

 

[G-Mo77]

Went like this

D. Smith > Couch
Judd > Pendles

I still an egg in the ruck and have genuine concerns about Kruezer. 2 Trades and plenty of cash but still 6 weeks to go.

 

[Crimson Azure]

Mitch Robinson? Y/N

 

[rocker_oz33]

Does Darley to Lids save a donut this week? Either way I think I like Darley to Lids better. Lids really is a must have.

Not now i have got sick of broughtons scores more shitty at rossy.baguey for broughton and went giles for macvoy for POD never had 2 guns rucks before jacobs/macca might get waters next week.

 

[Seppo]

Downgrading D.Shiel on the bench in midfield to free up some cash.
I can go to Baguley and get a MID/DEF link with Goddard and Carrots to swap with.
OR
Bring in Couch for the MID/FWD link with Pavlich, Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Zorko, Martin and Adams.

Does everyone agree that Couch has the better job security based on a team that is out of finals contention over Baugely who may be out of the side as others come back for Essendon?

 

[CrashTestDummy]

I have a donut this week due to Broughton, S.Shaw and Darley all being out.

Should I trade this week to avoid a donut and if so who do I trade out?

I have one trade and $196,300 in the kitty.

Thoughts?

Keep Broughton (easy run home)
Keep Shaw (BE of -11)
Darley (will get more games)

Hold the trade for a premo injury and/or upgrade an injured rookie later
Just my advice

 

[CrashTestDummy]

Saad out or Treloar out for Goodes?

 

[Super Hans]

should I bring in Crameri or Cloke as my forward bench cover for the rest of season? or any forward 371k or under

 

[Seppo]

Upgrade Bugg to Deledio or H.Shaw?

I feel Deledio is more consistent and capable of bigger scores that Shaw.

 

[JustMe53]

1.)williams out cocuh in 2.) pfiffier out pendelbury in
2 trades left and full team but have broughton and kruezzz