Rolling All Australian Team 2020

[Giant Pete]

FB: Hurn - Andrews - Howe
HB: Saad - Weitering - Docherty
C: Gaff - Cripps - Adams
HF: Heeney - Taberner - Papley
FF: C.Cameron - Dixon - Perryman
RR: Goldstein - Fyfe - Neale
INT: Pendlebury - Simpkin - Boak - Sicily

Nick Haynes.

 

[Scotland]

Four games in I'm pretty confident we have 0 representatives.

Maybe Liam Ryan at a stretch but Papley and Cameron have been better as small forwards.

 

[HairyO]

Four games in I'm pretty confident we have 0 representatives.

Maybe Liam Ryan at a stretch but Papley and Cameron have been better as small forwards.

Wingard 9 goals in 4 games. Also ahead of Ryan.

 

[eth-dog]

From my perspective so far:

FB: Nick Haynes - Harris Andrews - Adam Saad
HB: Sam Docherty - Jacob Weitering - James Sicily
MF: Jy Simpkin - Lachie Neale - Harry Perryman
HF: Tom Papley - Levi Casboult - Chad Wingard
FF: Daniel Butler - Charlie Dixon - Charlie Cameron
OB: Todd Goldstein - Patrick Cripps - Scott Pendlebury
IC: Matthew Rowell - Taylor Adams - Travis Boak - Luke Parker

Robbie Tarrant, DBJ to miss out in defence in particular.

 

[Scotland]

Wingard 9 goals in 4 games. Also ahead of Ryan.

Not competing.

Wingard would be in line for one of those HF spots they give to half forwards, mids who play forward a mid and forwards who play mid a bit depending on which year it is.

They tend to just pick one forward pocket now in the AA side. Right now that would be Cameron.

 

[WWSD]

It's really hard to get a gauge with the shortened quarters.


B: Adam Saad, Harris Andrews, Nick Haynes

HB: Daniel Houston, Jacob Weitering, Sam Docherty

C: Hugh McCluggage, Matthew Rowell, Steele Sidebottom

HF: Chad Wingard, Levi Casboult, Patrick Dangerfield

F: Tom Papley, Charlie Dixon, Charlie Cameron

R: Todd Goldstein, Scott Pendlebury, Lachie Neale

INT: Jy Simpkin, Brodie Grundy, Travis Boak, Touk Miller

 

[Juddernaut08]

From my perspective so far:

FB: Nick Haynes - Harris Andrews - Adam Saad
HB: Sam Docherty - Jacob Weitering - James Sicily
MF: Jy Simpkin - Lachie Neale - Harry Perryman
HF: Tom Papley - Levi Casboult - Chad Wingard
FF: Daniel Butler - Charlie Dixon - Charlie Cameron
OB: Todd Goldstein - Patrick Cripps - Scott Pendlebury
IC: Matthew Rowell - Taylor Adams - Travis Boak - Luke Parker

Robbie Tarrant, DBJ to miss out in defence in particular.

Good team. Seriously be shocking if a first year player makes AA but bloody hell Rowell deserves it at this point.

Would love if he won the Brownlow.

 

[Juddernaut08]

Billings a chance? Saints are doing so well, who has been starring?

Havent watched any of their games but will this Saturday.

 

[curnow inferno]

FB: Maynard - Andrews - Howe
HB: Saad - Weitering - Docherty
C: Gaff - Rowell - McCluggage
HF: Butler - Casboult - Papley
FF: C.Cameron - Dixon - Wingard
RR: Goldstein - Boak - Neale
INT: Pendlebury - Simpkin - Adams - Rampe

Round 4 changes:
In- Rowell, Maynard, Butler, McCluggage, Rampe, Wingard, Casboult
Out- Cripps, Hurn, Heeney, Fyfe, Sicily, Perryman, Taberner

 

[It Just Is]

My early smokey from Port would be Justin Westhoff for a tall forward and 2nd ruck spot. I’d have him ahead of Casboult at this stage.

 

[hilly]

I will go through the roof if/when Tarrant misses again.

 

[The 747]

My early smokey from Port would be Justin Westhoff for a tall forward and 2nd ruck spot. I’d have him ahead of Casboult at this stage.

He's been outstanding in the games I have watched (all except round 10), very high hurt factor.

 

[KissKiss]

I will go through the roof if/when Tarrant misses again.

Interesting year so far for tall backs. They have been dominating the key forwards so far with almost no bags being kicked. I can see at least 4 or more key defenders that all have llegitimate claims so far.
Tarrant, Weitering, Andrews, Jonas and Haynes all been very good
No-one has got on top of McEvoy I think yet either

 

[kreglze]

From the Suns:

Rowell on form needs to be in there with potentially 3 B.O.G performances.

Outside of him, I don't think we have too many massive standouts.

If you are looking at specialist wingman, Ellis in the 2 games he has played since coming back from injury he has been great for us.

Collins has been big for us down back marking anything in his general vicinity.

Would have had Weller up there, but he had a pretty poor game against Freo.

Witts has been massive for us, but I haven't seen enough of the other teams ruckmen.

I think for the Suns it has been a more even performance as opposed to a couple of massive stand outs.

 

[Pykie]

Simpkin has to just about be in, more than likely in a starting position on the ground.

CD have him on par with Rowell and only Neale ahead of both of them as far as midfielders go this year.

He's pretty much top 6 or 7 in every major statistic - Disposals, Clearances, Score Involvements, effective disposals etc.

 

[Nater]

Port are only averaging 36.5 points against and none of our defenders are getting any love. Tommy Jonas should be captain of that side and how DBJ isn't getting a run is blasphemous.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[KissKiss]

Port are only averaging 36.5 points against and none of our defenders are getting any love. Tommy Jonas should be captain of that side and how DBJ isn't getting a run is blasphemous.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

In my post about 3 or 4 up the Port defenders were the others I was wondering about. But I havent really watched Port much this year to be clear on who has played well. Which is basically the problem. They are so unknown and under-rated

 

[nahnah]

Port should have like 6-7 players in the team

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Port should have like 6-7 players in the team

Realistically If it were done today we would probably have Boak, DBJ, McKenzie and Dixon in the team and Hartlett and Westhoff in the 40

 

[Veer Right]

Billings a chance? Saints are doing so well, who has been starring?

Havent watched any of their games but will this Saturday.

Nah, he's been good but not AA. Jack Steele would be close but he's fighting a lot of other gun players in the same position.

 

[SSSSSS]

My early smokey from Port would be Justin Westhoff for a tall forward and 2nd ruck spot. I’d have him ahead of Casboult at this stage.

You know it's a crazy year when we are debating Westhoff ahead of Casboult for an AA spot, no disrespect to either player.
Both very valid choices as well.

 

[PAFC_1870]

Realistically If it were done today we would probably have Boak, DBJ, McKenzie and Dixon in the team and Hartlett and Westhoff in the 40

Can't argue that.

 

[PAFC_1870]

Port are only averaging 36.5 points against and none of our defenders are getting any love. Tommy Jonas should be captain of that side and how DBJ isn't getting a run is blasphemous.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

This. Classic clueless Bigfooty.

League's best defence

 

[FRUMPY]

You know it's a crazy year when we are debating Westhoff ahead of Casboult for an AA spot, no disrespect to either player.
Both very valid choices as well.

haha spot on

 

[philthy05]

My early smokey from Port would be Justin Westhoff for a tall forward and 2nd ruck spot. I’d have him ahead of Casboult at this stage.

the amount of teams in here that have ****ing Carlton or some other middle of the road Victorian team with more aa players than the unbeaten team with record percentage is laughable.

any other year we get told nah, no room for boak cause x team has won more games or some other bullshit.