NFL Rookies of the Year

[Blacky]

OROY is no slam dunk.
A number of players have a case.

That's true

QBs have a bias though for sure

 

[aussiedude]

QB's are compared against eachother.
Worst Passer rating and completion % of the 12 players who threw for over 4000yds. including players like Tannerhill, Stafford Elisha Manning and Cousins

21st on QBR

 

[Blacky]

QBR? Lol

You're saying he doesn't deserve it because although he is similar to seasoned veterans, he is slightly worse?

 

[royals1922]

QBR? Lol

You're saying he doesn't deserve it because although he is similar to seasoned veterans, he is slightly worse?

Sample his numbers againstplayers with 3 or less years....

 

[Blacky]

He walked into the worst team in the league though

 

[aussiedude]

He walked into the worst team in the league though

I think his passing yds are inflated and that he didnt have the best season as a Rookie.

They played a heap of teams with bad a D.

I would vote Cooper, Winston, Gurley as my top 3

 

[Bucking Beads]

didnt he get done for PEDs?

Yeah so he's out.

 

[Blacky]

Yeah so he's out.

Sorry I thought that was a recent post haha

 

[aussiedude]

Todd Gurley beat Winston for OROY. But Winston got the Pepsi Rookie of the Year