Kane McGoodwin
Make me an Admin!
- May 21, 2001
- 86,012
- 91,377
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Crows
Lol, he sure is.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Prediction ROUND 1 2023 - Pick your best team
- Thread starter JPetro83
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Sep 13, 2019
- 4,763
- 5,322
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
As long as keays is in our side we arent wining a flag.
Kane McGoodwin
Make me an Admin!
- May 21, 2001
- 86,012
- 91,377
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Crows
Lol, Keays is the least of our problems... but he clearly has you triggered!
- Sep 13, 2019
- 4,763
- 5,322
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
He has most crows fans triggered with his constant clangers.
He takes no care with his kicking disposal. He also is a panic merchant around goals at times.
Ramify
Cancelled
- Oct 15, 2012
- 5,384
- 7,472
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
IDK. Hes kinda the epitome of two of our biggest problems. Poor disposal + poor decision maker.
The sooner he's pushed out, the closer we are to competing.
Don't get me wrong. I don't think he gets pushed out for a while yet.
I am updating my round 1 team. Very few changes. Just a slight tweak or two:
B: Parnell - Butts - Worrell
HB: Smith - Murray - Hamill
C: Pedlar - Berry - Dawson
HF: Rankine - Walker - Rachele
F: McAdam - Fogarty - Thilthorpe
R: ROB - Laird - Soligo
I/C: Doedee - Jones - Keays - Milera - Schoenberg.
Emergencies: Himmelberg; Hinge; Nankervis; Strachan; Taylor; (McHenry; Sloane if recovered)
closet crows supporter
this is probably round 1 best 22 less hately
What I want:
B: Jones Butts Worrell
HB: Smith Doedee Milera
C: Dawson Berry Keays
HF: Rankine Walker Thilthorpe
FF: McAdam Fog Rachele
1R: ROB Soligo Laird
INT: Schoenberg Hinge Parnell Taylor
Sub: McHenry
What I think we will do (only half joking):
B: Jones Butts Doedee
HB: Smith Murray Dawson
C: Soligo Keays McHenry
HF: Rankine Walker Thilthorpe
FF: McAdam Fog Rachele
1R: ROB Sloane Laird
Int: Berry Hinge Murphy Milera
SUB: Mackay
B: Jones Butts Worrell
HB: Smith Doedee Milera
C: Dawson Berry Keays
HF: Rankine Walker Thilthorpe
FF: McAdam Fog Rachele
1R: ROB Soligo Laird
INT: Schoenberg Hinge Parnell Taylor
Sub: McHenry
What I think we will do (only half joking):
B: Jones Butts Doedee
HB: Smith Murray Dawson
C: Soligo Keays McHenry
HF: Rankine Walker Thilthorpe
FF: McAdam Fog Rachele
1R: ROB Sloane Laird
Int: Berry Hinge Murphy Milera
SUB: Mackay
Mackay lol. I don't think Murphy, McHenry will be suiting up round 1.
You underestimate how much our coaches love them both.
Rankine and Rachele need players to come out for them. McHenry and Murphy are the logical choices. You have to remember Murphy was dropped towards the end of 2022. I feel Nick's will try and get one of Taylor or Nank some game time as well so Ned, Murphy and Jones will be under pressure.
Scorpus
Moderator
- Apr 16, 2014
- 61,720
- 165,043
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Moderator
- #314
This was the lineup from R23 in 2022
B Worrell - Butts - Doedee
HB Smith - Murray - Dawson
C Hinge - Laird - Jones
HF Thilthorpe - Fogarty - Schoenberg
F McHenry - Walker - Murphy
R O'Brien - Berry - Keays
I Soligo - Milera - Rowe - Parnell
This was a pretty stable line-up from the previous few weeks, we had McAdam, Milera and Rowe all rotating in and out due to various injuries but otherwise not a heap of change
We also know that of our smalls we had
McHenry - 20 games (0 SANFL)
Murphy - 17 games (1 SANFL)
Rowe - 17 games (4 SANFL)
McAdam - 15 games (2 SANFL)
Rachele - 13 games (1 SANFL)
Milera - 12 games (7 SANFL)
So on average we basically played 4 small forwards each week, with the preference being McHenry, Murphy, Rachele and McAdam
Based on that you'd think McHenry and Murphy are locks in the team having played the most AFL and least SANFL. The replacements for Rachele and Rankine will likely come from McAdam, Milera, Schoenberg, those types that played fewer games
Scorpus
Moderator
- Apr 16, 2014
- 61,720
- 165,043
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Moderator
- #315
I don't think that's much joking in there, aside from the sub. I reckon that's pretty close to how we'll roll out. We'll try shuffle one of the smalls up the ground to fit them all in, and it'll cost someone like Schoenberg their spot
Sadly, I agree.
v v funny well done
We don't see much change over a preseason, in fact, historically poor form from seniors tends to be forgotten throughout the warmer months. So the continuity driven 22 from the last few games is a very good basis for predicting the round 1 side. This is why we could reliably predict the starting mids at the opening bounce of this season. Injury notwithstanding, the definite ins are Rachele, Rankine and Sloane with Davis and Rowe out.
Given the certain ins being mid or forwards, I originally figured that would put Ned and Murph at risk. But looking at the back 6 above, I wouldn't be surprised if Worrell was to be one of the outs. My new prediction if everyone is available is Worrell out, Milera back half and Murphy to sub. I can't see McAdam squeezing back in despite a pretty good year and offering a point of difference in our forward line.
Schoey and Parnell are potentially at some risk to be sub instead of Murphy. But I reckon the 23 are all but locked in.
Didn’t we bring McAdam straight back into the side after every injury absence last year (from when he got brought into the side)
No way this will happen haha
It's not that he doesn't deserve a spot, he'd be in my side for sure. But according to scorpus post he did play 2 SANFL games, so wasn't always brought straight back. The issue is someone has to miss to fit 3 certainties in with only 2 current outs. The forward line has 5 absolute locks in Tex, TT, Fog, Rankine and Rachele. Add Murphy, Ned and possibly Sloane plus a rotating mid and there's not much room. But happy to put McAdam in as he's a favourite of mine, but who from my predicted 23 is now missing out?
I cannot see Murphy playing over McAdam when both are fit. Murphy got dropped two or three times in the second half of the year, whilst McAdam’s SANFL games I’m pretty sure were at the start of the year before he pretty much permanently came back into the AFL side
Ned is hard to say, as he has history of being more of a permanent fixture, but if I had to guess (fully fit), our R1 forwards will be the five locks, plus Ned and Shane
I have no idea what we’ll do with Sloane
- Aug 30, 2021
- 18,783
- 36,992
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
McAdams B&F finish off reduced games shows how he’s rated by the coaches, he adds a lot to our forward line so he isn’t going anywhere.
We’ve got the makings of a very exciting forward line, hopefully that doesn’t include Sloane, Murphy and McHenry much.
I think a fit Sloane is a walk up start, won't be left out with his hand up. According to scorpus, Murph played only 1 SANFL game, so surely only 1 dropping. Murph is a good choice for sub if 4 points are the priority, he can be deployed pretty much anywhere other than KPD and ruck, that's why he's my predicted sub. I don't see McAdam being sub though, which moves someone else out of the 22, which would surprise me. Maybe Parnell.
Not bad , probably like to see Milera for max .
Similar threads
