Round 11 trades

[Faz 2000]

Ben Ken will lose money this week, so he's the obvious cull.

Kerridge is highly likely to stay steady or sneak up a little more, so he can get Cutty McSnipsnip next week for Dahl or Jelwood or someone else better than him.

 

[Mex13]

What are the thoughts in these trades?
This week
BenKen-> Hanners
Kerridge -> Paine
Next week
Hewett-> Ward
Hartley -> Collins

 

[Blueboys11]

Rocky is playing this weekend
Mathieson coming out for him would definitely mean a lot of reversed trades and cause a lot of uncertainty

Mathieson to miss a couple of weeks to give time for Davis to ripen up to 300k would be nice

 

[rocker_oz33]

Mathieson to miss a couple of weeks to give time for Davis to ripen up to 300k would be nice

Forgotten man jack Trengove might get some games with Viney out with a broken cheek bone.

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Is anyone considering Dunkley over Mathieson this week?

I know Dunkley is $50k more, but at their current averages (61 for Dunkley & 56 for Mathieson), they're forecast to make approximately the same amount over the next 3 weeks! When you consider that Dunkley has the higher ceiling & is more likely to score above his average, it probably means that he will make more money in 3 weeks time! And their job security would be about the same.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

shut up with all this matho not playing talk. His ability to draw the high free kick is Selwood like and the juicy points are great for us. Forget about rocky hes dead to me, and should be to the rest of you campaigners too. Its all about the Mooooo

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Is anyone considering Dunkley over Mathieson this week?

I know Dunkley is $50k more, but at their current averages (61 for Dunkley & 56 for Mathieson), they're forecast to make approximately the same amount over the next 3 weeks! When you consider that Dunkley has the higher ceiling & is more likely to score above his average, it probably means that he will make more money in 3 weeks time! And their job security would be about the same.

No.. I have to wait, 8 weeks for Dunks to play his 3rd game. Even a good game doesn't guarantee he plays this week. I don't think he has the best JS

 

[DaveyBoy123]

No.. I have to wait, 8 weeks for Dunks to play his 3rd game. Even a good game doesn't guarantee he plays this week. I don't think he has the best JS

I can understand why those that had him from the start would be frustrated.

Would be keen to hear from Dogs supporters on Dunkley's JS.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Matho a decent option for a rookie should get a good run of games looks a goer too.
I'm passing only because I took hopper and smith,Davis and dunks are mooing.

Early on but I will prob do these trades.
Hartley to phil Collins.
Menaspud-menaspew-menachop-menazero-menahack- to dollhouse.

 

[jellyfish]

Kerridge > Dahl
Hartley > Collins
Going to wait one more on Robbie hopefully nab him next week
Is DPP fwd/mid link crucial in byes?

Sorry last question what is relatively a good bye structure? what should you be aiming for

 

[j0rdy1]

Also fwiw I'm probably going to ditch Kerridge slightly early this week to get matho.
Footywire says Kerridge only has 10-15k left in him before he starts losing money

Why not upgrade Kerridge next week instead and downgrade someone else this week, Kerridge has Brisbane this week so I have a feeling he will score almost the best out of the 'rookies'.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Is anyone considering Dunkley over Mathieson this week?

I know Dunkley is $50k more, but at their current averages (61 for Dunkley & 56 for Mathieson), they're forecast to make approximately the same amount over the next 3 weeks! When you consider that Dunkley has the higher ceiling & is more likely to score above his average, it probably means that he will make more money in 3 weeks time! And their job security would be about the same.

Go with matho should get games and cheaper.matho better breakeven too.
Dunks js is a worrie so many gun mids at the western puppies.

 

[Sebsal2313]

Hartley is going for me this week, Collins is leading the race but have to wait until the teams come out.
Stringer is a must go as well, His breakeven is 149 and has been shocking, lazy, not committed and seems like he cant even be bothered. The good thing is Dayne Zorko is coming in this week and next week I can bring Robbie in for De Goey or someone thereabouts.

 

[Chaisa]

What is Collins JS like? Usually I'd wait a week but need to trade out Hartley and Kennedy and don't have enough cash for 2 upgrades....

 

[DrummoSolo]

What is Collins JS like? Usually I'd wait a week but need to trade out Hartley and Kennedy and don't have enough cash for 2 upgrades....

I'm pretty sure all of Freo's KPD are suffering long-term injuries. Should be safe as houses.

 

[PAFC1996]

Davis and Gresham scoring half decently has ruined my planned trades. Will be bringing Gray in this week. Not sure how, can afford going Hewett and Gresham/Davis > Gray and Mathieson, provided he is named. Also considered Libba and Hewett out, could afford Gray and Sam Mitchell or cheaper, but would like to keep Libba for M8/9. Suggestions?

 

[jellyfish]

would you Zorko at 585 or Dahlhause at 545 this week and with their byes?
this is the problem i face

 

[rocker_oz33]

Davis and Gresham scoring half decently has ruined my planned trades. Will be bringing Gray in this week. Not sure how, can afford going Hewett and Gresham/Davis > Gray and Mathieson, provided he is named. Also considered Libba and Hewett out, could afford Gray and Sam Mitchell or cheaper, but would like to keep Libba for M8/9. Suggestions?

Much easier if you post your team with money in bank people get to see the big picture.

 

[The_Steadier]

Why not upgrade Kerridge next week instead and downgrade someone else this week, Kerridge has Brisbane this week so I have a feeling he will score almost the best out of the 'rookies'.

I'd like to hold onto kerridge but I'm kinda already +1 premo/starter in the fwd line with barlow back now.

Which in itself wouldn't be enough reason to chop kerridge- but my other cows of keayes, hopper, davis, smith, petracca need more time.

You're right though- I'd expect kerridge to score well this week, but I'm equally happy enough fielding smith (with adams out) and hopper this week.

 

[felsty]

Am I missing something with the Kerridge talk?

Probably one of the only decent rookies who has the ability to go large. I'll be keeping him to use through the bye rounds, hopefully he pops out some half decent scores and I can catch further up the rankings.

For me,

Kennedy > Mathieson
Hartley > McVeigh

Means I have to play Hopper and Smith on field but think my premos will make up for it.

B: Shaw, Simpson, Bartel, McVeigh, Rich, Adams (Tippa, Brown)
M: Dangerfield, Ablett, Parker, Gray, Priddis, Liberatore, Hopper, Smith (Mathieson, Davis, Macpherson)
R: Goldstein, Gawn (Grimley)
F: Montagna, Zorko, Martin, Wingard, Wells, Hall (Kerridge, Petracca)

$139k remaining, 15 trades left.

Would love to get Kerridge on the ground somehow but don't think its possible ($1k short of going Macpherson > Mathieson, Kennedy > McVeigh!)

 

[PAFC1996]

Much easier if you post your team with money in bank people get to see the big picture.

The current lack of a mid/fwd DPP link is annoying, but I'm hoping to have that back after next weeks trades.

 

[rocker_oz33]

View attachment 252306
The current lack of a mid/fwd DPP link is annoying, but I'm hoping to have that back after next weeks trades.

Imho you need another gun mid.
Maybe Hewitt to gray.
If you need more cash Hartley to Collins.
Hewitt bit of moo left but what hewitt gains gray will gain and score more if you want gray that is.
I would let the others moo and hopefully a rookie DPP mid fwd comes along.

 

[CGPIES25]

Two Trading options
1st. Macpherson -> Mathieson
Or
2nd. Hartley -> S.Collins
Ben Ken -> Dahlhaus

Can wait a week on 2nd option so thinking maybe do the 1st and then 2nd next week but not sure if I actually want Mathieson can just hold Dmac until better rookie comes along.
Thoughts?

 

[nameless]

People's thoughts on McVeigh?
Looked good on Friday, built his fitness back up and is cheap as chips at the minute.

 

[karaoke]

Is anyone considering Dunkley over Mathieson this week?

I know Dunkley is $50k more, but at their current averages (61 for Dunkley & 56 for Mathieson), they're forecast to make approximately the same amount over the next 3 weeks! When you consider that Dunkley has the higher ceiling & is more likely to score above his average, it probably means that he will make more money in 3 weeks time! And their job security would be about the same.

A 2 & 3 game history isn't much to go by.