Round 11 trades

[Double the Fist]

Footy trips are a bit too masculine for my liking.

Ok ok. Calm down.






Have a glass of white wine son!

 

[Longbombswans]

Want to upgrade Parish to R Gray, but would have to bring in Collins a week early... worth the risk or wait a week?

 

[Keg on legs]

I would love him at D6 at his price.
Whats his BE this week?

BE is 80, so even if he scores another 120 odd he shouldn't go up all that much (don't have those figures with me)

 

[Gerald Preston]

Want to upgrade Parish to R Gray, but would have to bring in Collins a week early... worth the risk or wait a week?

Chase that instant gratification son

 

[Hairy Lager]

BE is 80, so even if he scores another 120 odd he shouldn't go up all that much (don't have those figures with me)

Thanks.
I'm playing with 2 mid rookies so he's out of reach.
I really need 1 of Pendles or Hanners to spud up.
Can't see it happening.

 

[markm106]

Dea to Tucker
BenKen to Wingard.

Leaves me 441k for upgrades next week. However I'll be watching the potential late out of Goldy. Then Reversal and BenKen to maybe Lycett to allow for ruck cover.
Just wish I had of gone big Mason Cox over Grimley at start of the year.

 

[Double the Fist]

GAJ

GAJ +2

+3 easy choice

He had a good score in a losing side, did he look over his ailments? Did he look like he gave a damn, I didn't see the game, and really wanted too, because GAJ is extra cheap, 90 k cheaper. Really want to make sure he looks right though. What did you see of him?

Thanks for the replies and help.

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Hartley has a BE of 95....

trade in Tucker, Collins 1 week early, Trengove 2 weeks early or wait?

 

[toxic]

Hartley has a BE of 95....

trade in Tucker, Collins 1 week early, Trengove 2 weeks early or wait?

He wont be playing so his b/e is irrelevant this week and probably next

 

[Obese Arachnid]

A Triple Brie with a pack of water crackers and half a slab is perfect for that,
I need some light refreshment and a light snack moment, I find.

Substitute Brie with duck liver pate (especially my sis's homemade) & I'm with ya, oh & another 6 pack or two.

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Dea to Tucker
BenKen to Wingard.

Leaves me 441k for upgrades next week. However I'll be watching the potential late out of Goldy. Then Reversal and BenKen to maybe Lycett to allow for ruck cover.
Just wish I had of gone big Mason Cox over Grimley at start of the year.

I have Goldy and no cover too. Not sure it is worth buggering up your trade plans for a (potential) 1 week injury unless you're bringing a true premium who will play forward (obviously not Lycett). 'Tis a shame we missed the Mason Cox boat!

 

[Kadog]

Oh fukkit...

MMurphy > Gibbs. YOLO

 

[Guardian Hawk]

He wont be playing so his b/e is irrelevant this week and probably next

Thanks Toxic - not sure how I missed that!

I'm not saying this just coz you replied to me but though I'm not a very regular poster like some, I have been reading the Supercoach board weekly for years and you are a Supercoach champion whether you win it or not.

You are always giving advice and answering questions, even if its a question that has been asked 65 times in the thread already or is the old newbie questions every week regarding DPP trades and E loopholes.

Thanks heaps mate from all of us on the BF Supercoach board!

 

[dudemcguy]

He had a good score in a losing side, did he look over his ailments? Did he look like he gave a damn, I didn't see the game, and really wanted too, because GAJ is extra cheap, 90 k cheaper. Really want to make sure he looks right though. What did you see of him?

Thanks for the replies and help.

I watched until about 3 qtr time and tbh I didn't think he had as much of an impact on the game as his score suggested. Played well but it wasn't like when you used to be able to watch a Gold Coast game and see nobody except for Ablett getting the ball, granted he did have 30 odd disposals so maybe i'm just blind.

 

[King_Steele]

Oh fukkit...

MMurphy > Gibbs. YOLO

No luv 4 Cropps?

 

[Double the Fist]

Thanks Toxic - not sure how I missed that!

I'm not saying this just coz you replied to me but though I'm not a very regular poster like some, I have been reading the Supercoach board weekly for years and you are a Supercoach champion whether you win it or not.

You are always giving advice and answering questions, even if its a question that has been asked 65 times in the thread already or is the old newbie questions every week regarding DPP trades and E loopholes.

Thanks heaps mate from all of us on the BF Supercoach board!

Yeah, he's great value.

I watched until about 3 qtr time and tbh I didn't think he had as much of an impact on the game as his score suggested. Played well but it wasn't like when you used to be able to watch a Gold Coast game and see nobody except for Ablett getting the ball, granted he did have 30 odd disposals so maybe i'm just blind.

Did he look pretty fit? Or was he proppy but still managed to get around under duress?

 

[Metapod]

Compare his T.O.G to nutnut

Makes for interesting reading

Interesting...


However doesn't look like TOG has a direct correlation to SC score. Interesting read nonetheless. Nic Nat's scores are incredible given his consistent 65-70% TOG! Imagine what he could do with a little bit more fitness, playing 80% of the game (at the same intensity he plays at 65-70%).

 

[MVallence90]

I think I'm one of the few with Lincon McCarthy is my side, back this week B/E of 105. Will drop from $269k, is it time to let him go. Can swap Brown/Adams/Tippa to my FWDS

Can just do one trade, BenKen to Grey in my mids, will lose MID/FWD dpp, 8k in the bank. If I make a second trade of McCarthy to Collins or Tucker, would leave 159k in the bank.

 

[stevebbb]

lack of replies is because nobody likes the single player specific threads, I'm sure Jiska will come through and delete it

just post in the round trade or discussion thread


on topic, didn't start with him

 

[toxic]

Interesting...
View attachment 253032

However doesn't look like TOG has a direct correlation to SC score. Interesting read nonetheless. Nic Nat's scores are incredible given his consistent 65-70% TOG! Imagine what he could do with a little bit more fitness, playing 80% of the game (at the same intensity he plays at 65-70%).

Agreed

My query is what happens if nutnut and his time on ground increase to consistent high 70s..
Does that impact lycett who i rate a lot

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Umm.. we have a trades thread just for this kinda stuff man.. no need to feel special and start your own for some Essendon dude..

 

[Double the Fist]

lack of replies is because nobody likes the single player specific threads, I'm sure Jiska will come through and delete it

just post in the round trade or discussion thread


on topic, didn't start with him

Just post tennis ladies and it will be gone, licketty split!

EDIT : Or hardcore MILF pawn. Yeah, post that.

 

[Metapod]

I have Goldy and no cover too. Not sure it is worth buggering up your trade plans for a (potential) 1 week injury unless you're bringing a true premium who will play forward (obviously not Lycett). 'Tis a shame we missed the Mason Cox boat!

I tend to disagree with this statement. Having a good R/F as your F7/R3 can be huge value - especially towards the end of the year if you are short of trades and one of your rucks is rested for the one week!

 

[Metapod]

Agreed

My query is what happens if nutnut and his time on ground increase to consistent high 70s..
Does that impact lycett who i rate a lot

Nic Nat has had 3 games with TOG > 70%. Of those 3 games, Lycett scored 107 & 113 (DNP 1). Probably not much data to make a call, but certainly doesn't suggest Lycett scores poorly when NN plays.

 

[Guardian Hawk]

I think I'm one of the few with Lincon McCarthy is my side, back this week B/E of 105. Will drop from $269k, is it time to let him go. Can swap Brown/Adams/Tippa to my FWDS

Can just do one trade, BenKen to Grey in my mids, will lose MID/FWD dpp, 8k in the bank. If I make a second trade of McCarthy to Collins or Tucker, would leave 159k in the bank.

Depends on your side (trade needs, bye structure, etc) but I would hold McCarthy. His BE is high because of his injury affected 15. Once that is out of his scores (after 2 weeks) he will start making money again. His JS seems pretty good too (I'm no expert on Geelong) given he has come back into the side after recovering. You have held him this long so may as well use him through the byes. His non injury average is 66 and if he maintains that he will be worth 281K at his bye and 300K a couple of weeks later.