Trades Round 11 trades.

Remove this Banner Ad

Would appreciate some guidance as I'm finding it tough to decide. It's probably a bit of FOMO clouding my thoughts.

I can downgrade Lockhart to Hinge (placeholder rookie) and upgrade Rockliff to Whitfield. I'll have 4 rookies in Hore, Stack, Miers and Balta on field.

OR downgrade Miers to Hinge (placeholder) and upgrade Lockhart to Laird. Only 3 rookies in Hore, Stack and Balta would be on field.

I'm pretty sure Whitfield is going 150+ this week.

So its...Rocky, Laird, Hore, Stack, Balta vs Whitfield, Hore, Stack, Miers, Balta
So basically it's Rocky and Laird vs Miers and Whitfield

Say Rocky 120 and Laird 100 vs Miers 60 and Whitfield 150

Your 10 points up with the 2 premiums, I also think Laird could go big against Melbourne and getting rid of Miers is ideal because he is losing cash. However if you were wanting to captain Whitfield for his score it could change things. I think Rocky and Laird is the way to go, but I wouldn't be against going for Whitfield as he could go 150+. I am in a similar situation myself except thinking of getting in Dusty instead of Laird and can't make up my mind (Whitfield looks good in the team).
 
What do we think about the GWS mids and their scoring? Can Whitfield, Kelly, Taranto and cogs all average 110+? I think they could given their fixtures but having 3 or 4 players from one team is always risky.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Who to bring in for Brayshaw? Was thinking Taranto although could do to Laird via dpp.

Your guys thoughts Taranto or Laird already have B Smith?
 
So it seems that Matt Crouch won’t play this week either.

Next year I won’t be holding an injured premo under any circumstance.

Whitfield?
 
So it seems that Matt Crouch won’t play this week either.

Next year I won’t be holding an injured premo under any circumstance.

Annoying if that's the case because holding premos for 1 week is 100% the correct decision. It only falls apart when teams put up this smoke screen naming them in the Sunday team then being a late withdrawl.... followed by 2 more weeks off? Wth? How about some transparency in the injury analysis?
 
Trading Hayes and will have around 200k to upgrade one of Newnes or Mills..

Newnes has had a role change in recent weeks however I wouldn’t be surprised if Phillips was dropped allowing Jack to spend more time on the wing.

Mills has been rubbish for me, expected more midfield time and have held due to injuries and hope that he would improve.

Thinking my options are Mills > Laird/Lloyd or Newnes > Dunkley/Dusty. Thoughts?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Just some of the journos on twitter were giving off the vibe that he’s more unlikely than likely. And I like to jump to conclusions.
I'll contradict you in saying I am far too positive a person to read into it that way.

Genuine 50/50 it seems, he's playing!! 🤣 But seriously, it genuinely seems like it will be something we find out Thursday/Friday
 
I'll contradict you in saying I am far too positive a person to read into it that way.

Genuine 50/50 it seems, he's playing!! 🤣 But seriously, it genuinely seems like it will be something we find out Thursday/Friday

I’m preparing for the worst, if Crouch and Rocky are both out I give up.
 
Would appreciate some guidance as I'm finding it tough to decide. It's probably a bit of FOMO clouding my thoughts.

I can downgrade Lockhart to Hinge (placeholder rookie) and upgrade Rockliff to Whitfield. I'll have 4 rookies in Hore, Stack, Miers and Balta on field.

OR downgrade Miers to Hinge (placeholder) and upgrade Lockhart to Laird. Only 3 rookies in Hore, Stack and Balta would be on field.

I'm pretty sure Whitfield is going 150+ this week.

So its...Rocky, Laird, Hore, Stack, Balta vs Whitfield, Hore, Stack, Miers, Balta
Surely Lachie Weller is as good a matchup as any in the league. Wouldn’t be certain he is going huge.

Having said that I will be chucking the C on him.
 
At this point in time I’m think I’m going to stick with Scrimshaw and Hayes to Hinge and Baker.

Depending if Rocky plays or not I should be able to trade using DPP to get all of Miers, Rozee, Stack and Hore as my only playing rookies.

Injuries aside, and especially with that third trade next week, that will give me enough money to go Miers up to a premo mid and Rozee to a premo defender leaving only two rookies on field in Hore and Stack.

Might sound ok, but I don’t own Grundy yet (waiting to trade Witts to Grundy after his bye) and I also have Ziebell at F6 and Liam Shiels at M8 with Boak still sitting in my mids.
 
I held him the first week and then traded him out the second :mad:
Why..? It was a cork so wasn't going to be any longer than two. After holding for one what's the point?
 
Why..? It was a cork so wasn't going to be any longer than two. After holding for one what's the point?
I looked at the177 BE and played the cash making game, plus points that round bringing in Stewart....for 80 and 77.
Meanwhile over in 'he'll lose $ with a BE of 177 land"...
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Trades Round 11 trades.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top