IMO he will play out the season unless he gets injured. His JS is very good since Brogan is retiring and we need to get some games into him but his average will probably drop - perhaps significantly - when Dean returns (maybe next week... Maybe R19)
-
Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2025 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
Round 16 Trades
- Thread starter lmach
- Start date
- Tagged users None
IMO he will play out the season unless he gets injured. His JS is very good since Brogan is retiring and we need to get some games into him but his average will probably drop - perhaps significantly - when Dean returns (maybe next week... Maybe R19)
WCE9
Rookie
- Apr 22, 2010
- 23
- 0
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Manchester United
Im planning on doing bartel > ablett this week and was wondering which move was better to free up cash:
1) Otten > Talia (my other 2 benchmen are lower and jacobs so i should have decent cover if talia was eventually dropped)
2) Smith > Lobbe (my other rucks are vardy, cox and mcoughly, so it would mean that lobbe would be starting every week with cox)
I'm leaning towards option 1 as although lobbe is better than talia, smith is safer as a second ruck.
Any thoughts???
1) Otten > Talia (my other 2 benchmen are lower and jacobs so i should have decent cover if talia was eventually dropped)
2) Smith > Lobbe (my other rucks are vardy, cox and mcoughly, so it would mean that lobbe would be starting every week with cox)
I'm leaning towards option 1 as although lobbe is better than talia, smith is safer as a second ruck.
Any thoughts???
- May 22, 2006
- 2,742
- 3,132
- AFL Club
- West Coast
What about Otten > Wilkinson who has been named on a HBF for the Suns this week.
St Oxley
Debutant
Does anyone think that clokes scores will be lower than what they have been due to dawes out of the side.
I’m tossing up between him and pav but obviously cloke has an extra week and freo doesnt have the best draw
Does anyone get concerned at the fact that coll v geel is in the grand final round
I’m tossing up between him and pav but obviously cloke has an extra week and freo doesnt have the best draw
Does anyone get concerned at the fact that coll v geel is in the grand final round
This question is killing me to. I want the league win and not the overall, But after this trade I will only have 3 left. Thoughts? I could even get Stevie J but im not to sure if he's worth the extra cash.
Parquet Court
Club Legend
- Jun 10, 2010
- 1,642
- 716
- AFL Club
- Richmond
just the one trade this week. sick of cotchin and his mid 70s scores...
cotchin to swan. leaves me with 100k in the bank and 6 trades
gibbs, suckling, deledio, enright, shaw, adcock, goddard, stanley, guthrie, duigan
gablett, thompson, boyd, swan, fyfe, hibberd, bewick, i smith, jacobs
cox, petri, bailey, mccauley
chapman, nahas, franklin, pavlich, sylvia, riewoldt, higgins, richardson, lobbe, mzungu
guthrie and mccauley have killed me this season, cant get rid of them. hopefully i smith to callinan next week and upgrade a mid
cotchin to swan. leaves me with 100k in the bank and 6 trades
gibbs, suckling, deledio, enright, shaw, adcock, goddard, stanley, guthrie, duigan
gablett, thompson, boyd, swan, fyfe, hibberd, bewick, i smith, jacobs
cox, petri, bailey, mccauley
chapman, nahas, franklin, pavlich, sylvia, riewoldt, higgins, richardson, lobbe, mzungu
guthrie and mccauley have killed me this season, cant get rid of them. hopefully i smith to callinan next week and upgrade a mid
ROK in your case as Chappy has bye in finals.
Anyone know ROK's be?
92.
Hearing rumours of Nick Riewoldt in doubt is making trading Didak to Lobbe VERY tempting indeed... Would probably then upgrade Smith to Petrie eventually.
Didak is such a pain, what's the general consensus - is he worth holding onto, or not? Is there any chance of him coming back to his former self, the one that played last year.
Option One:
Didak OUT
Lobbe IN
Option Two:
Smith OUT
Lobbe IN
Option Three:
Leuenberger, Bartel OUT
Lobbe, Ablett In
Rather risky, with six trades left. But sooooo... tempting **Homer Simpson Drool**
Option Four:
No trades.
6 trades left, 3K in the bank. All lines finished if Heppell counts as a B7, Didak as a F7 and Bartel as a M7.
Done!
Z. Smith > Lobbe
Knights > giansiracusa
Z. Smith > Lobbe
Knights > giansiracusa
clogwearer
Idiot Savant
Turned Bartel into Ablett already. Tempted to turn Gibbs into Fisher while prices and BEs are still favorable (only interested in league results).
Would leave me with 2 trades and still one backline upgrade preferable - but could leave until league GF if I make it that far.
Should I do it?
Would leave me with 2 trades and still one backline upgrade preferable - but could leave until league GF if I make it that far.
Should I do it?
- Jun 14, 2011
- 578
- 374
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
I am struggling to chose between trading Hibberd to Suckling or Fisher. I really want to bring in Suckling but next weeks bye is holding me back. Fisher is Bye free but do you think he can lift his game and pull out consistent 100's?
I also am trading out rioli and i want to bring in Pav next week with him but i will cop a donut if i dont trade Rioli to Cloke, Gia or Lecras this week.
Thoughts???
Possible trades
Hibberd to Suckling or Fisher
Rioli to Gia, Lecras or Cloke OR Next week Rioli to Pav or Sylvia
I also am trading out rioli and i want to bring in Pav next week with him but i will cop a donut if i dont trade Rioli to Cloke, Gia or Lecras this week.
Thoughts???
Possible trades
Hibberd to Suckling or Fisher
Rioli to Gia, Lecras or Cloke OR Next week Rioli to Pav or Sylvia
clogwearer
Idiot Savant
I did Hibberd>Suckling last week knowing the risks for rd 17 and there's a fair chance I'll pay for that next week. Looking for the long term return to outweigh the short term pain.
For Rioli...if you're going to trade him this week it's hard to look past Cloke. Fluctuating scores but averaging very well for a forward. I haven't really looked into Gia or Lecras but at first sight Cloke is the trade I'd do. Might be wise to wait a week if you have the patience and then see where you want to go.
Then again, I'm 10k+ and struggling so maybe better to wait for someone better versed in DT than I am.
Just the one this week:
OUT: Gram
IN: Fisher
Just leaves me to downgrade Curnow to Callinan next week and then upgrade Howard or Tape to Broughton.
My team will then be finished in a disappointing year.
Would have liked 2 or 3 more premiums but oh well.
OUT: Gram
IN: Fisher
Just leaves me to downgrade Curnow to Callinan next week and then upgrade Howard or Tape to Broughton.
My team will then be finished in a disappointing year.
Would have liked 2 or 3 more premiums but oh well.
So you have 3 trades left and are considering using one to go gibbs -> fisher?
Thats crazy, you WILL get more than 2 injuries to your team before the end of the year so i'd suggest holding onto your trades so you can trade out some of your injured players come finals time.
lmach
Naitanui2Yeo
- Thread starter
- #93
I want to get Cloke. But heres the problem:
I can trade either Mzungu or Knights for him, though I planned to trade him in for Darling but I am 4k short of that
Should I trade Knights or Mzungu? if so which one?
OR should i trade Darling for Chapman/Fyfe/LeCras/Gia
Someone please give me some advice before lockout
Someone please give me some advice before lockout
Trade Knights. Darling will play out the year and provide good cover, Knights was dropped last week and his scores have been shocking of late.
- Jun 5, 2004
- 9,229
- 6,932
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Going back to my original plan of no trades this week. Can wait out and see how prices move on Suckling/Birchall and Ablett, who are the main 3 I want now. Could get Fisher in now, but will hold.
For all I know, Ablett could get a niggle and be off for surgery a few weeks before the end of the season.
For all I know, Ablett could get a niggle and be off for surgery a few weeks before the end of the season.
Anyone?
Get Bartel out and GAblett in.
Is Leuenberger your R2? If so, very risky. But maybe worth the pay off.
