i dont have jimmy so im gonna go with swan.
-
LIVE: Sydney v Port Adelaide - 7:40 / 7:10 Fri
Squiggle tips Swans at 57% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Prelim Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round SF Winner: And_ROOS
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Round 19 Captain Selection
- Thread starter Hirdy_5
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Thread starter
- #28
Yeah no problems, With ROK if your one of the coaches that has him, You realy can't go past him, His form over the past 3 weeks has been outstanding, The Swans are playing Fremantle and if you run through Fremantles list i can't see anyone that can realy match up on him. But every time you hype someone up for a big game against a lower ranked side it always seems to fail, IIRC Johnothan Brown was ment to turn his slow start to the season around when the Lions played the Demons earlyer on, yet didn't live up to the hype and scored somewere in the 50's or 60's.
justthedukes
Club Legend
Luke Hodge anyone?
I had him captain last time they played Brisbane and Troy Selwood kept him to 69. Selwood isn't in the side at the moment so wait and see if he comes back in. If he isn't in the side, Hodgey will most likely rip us a new one.
matt73
Senior List
Buddy could be an excellent selection this week up against the tiring Lions. From memory i remember Buddy kicking something like 9 goals 6 earlier this year against Brisbane in a shoot out with Bradshaw!!
OO74812
Debutant
Hodge or Buddy?
Been killing it alternating between Riewoldt and Bartel for the last 6 weeks or so based simply on past performances.
Will keep it going and stay with Bartel for this week.
Will keep it going and stay with Bartel for this week.
Who cares if whatshisname "runs with Bartel"
Same deal just about every game...all the big names get tagged so why worry about it unless there is previous form to suggest staying away.
Not as though its Baker on Judd...or Rawlings on someone.
Stay with logic based on past performances mixed with current form...dont talk yaself out of your decision based on nothing but guesswork.
Same deal just about every game...all the big names get tagged so why worry about it unless there is previous form to suggest staying away.
Not as though its Baker on Judd...or Rawlings on someone.
Stay with logic based on past performances mixed with current form...dont talk yaself out of your decision based on nothing but guesswork.
- Aug 2, 2006
- 5,585
- 3,094
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens, Arsenal
Kane gets another shot as his form is incredible
kornes or buddy or bartel or corey. Tough...real tough
i think james mcdonald will run with ablett and dunn with bartel. mind you i'm still going bartel captain and i really need him to pull out a 120+ because in my final this week i've got 20 players and my opponent has 22. i've worked out i need my players to average about 8.5 more than his altogether to win.
Does it matter who tags Jimmy, in good form he's unstoppable. Being tagged may reduce his marks, but then he'll just get more tackles.
Let's face it, Bartel can beat a tag in DT terms without many dramas. Ablett is back in and will still cop the number on tag as he is far more devastating to the outcome of a game, and not to mention that Bartel is red hot at the moment.
I can't see him having any trouble hitting big numbers against Melbourne, who probably won't worry the scorers too much this week, and we'll probably see half the Geelong team score 80+ in DT.
I can't see him having any trouble hitting big numbers against Melbourne, who probably won't worry the scorers too much this week, and we'll probably see half the Geelong team score 80+ in DT.
bigman100kg
Debutant
Kane or ROK or Buddy
Mackie as a roughie, (Id be happy with a gauranteed 85+) I have almost lost my mind bc of DT this week.
Mackie as a roughie, (Id be happy with a gauranteed 85+) I have almost lost my mind bc of DT this week.
Juddy88
Brownlow Medallist
Well i don't think i'll be making comments on captains this round, not after my performance last week, i don't think anyone would pay any attention(even though in theory, both Swan and Riewoldt were perfect captain choices).
I paid attention!! Lol went with Swan. Damn you!
Haha nah not your fault, silly decision!
It wasn't a silly decision mate, everything pointed his way at the time, it was just Malthouse had other ideas.
Now we know he's almost definitely playing, is anyone considering Ablett?
The guy i'm up against in finals also has Bartel but not Ablett, so I'm considering picking Ablett to try and get the jump on him hoping Ablett hops straight back to his earlier form.
Is this just wishful thinking?
The guy i'm up against in finals also has Bartel but not Ablett, so I'm considering picking Ablett to try and get the jump on him hoping Ablett hops straight back to his earlier form.
Is this just wishful thinking?
Juddy88
Brownlow Medallist
everything seems to be pointing to Swan again for me.
but on the back of this poll (60% Bartel
(cue the 150+ from Dane)
You said the exact same thing last week.
Similar threads
