Trades Round 8 trades

[samFFC]

Think Zorko carries the same risk, in a different way. A role change could mean Redden is crap and the same goes for Zorko if he's tagged.

JPK is a great shout, even if he is 40k more expensive.

Hutchings whilst Shuey is out? Or too mid pricer?

 

[TedDougChris]

1. Parker + Crowden -> MacRae + Mutch
2. English + Findlayson -> MacRae + 170k ruck
3. Florent + English -> R Gray + Crossley

Thoughts? I'm leaving towards 1 ATM

Option 1 out of that lot.

 

[WCEbrody]

Hutchings whilst Shuey is out? Or too mid pricer?

Will likely get tagging jobs every now and then, plus is in and out of the side a lot.

I like you're thinking though. Has scored very nicely this year.

 

[guero]

Thinking English to Keeffe or Crossley and maybe Doedee to Lids (if listed) via Sicily. Lids a big risk, but **** it...if fit I expect him to score well against the Eagles.

I'll hold Bont even if he doesn't get up. I'm over injury trades.

 

[DockerLoz]

I’ve gone Wilson to Sicily, English to Mason Wood

Probably will change up the English trade before lockout


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[samFFC]

Will likely get tagging jobs every now and then, plus is in and out of the side a lot.

I like you're thinking though. Has scored very nicely this year.

Even if he plays the next month with Shuey out for next 2 and he keeps his form until the byes, he could gain another 100k and score like an underpriced premo. Do you think he will be dropped soon?

bl4ke

 

[samFFC]

Zorko + Ronke or Mutch = 812k

Depending on Milera injury I've got:
Finlayson 414k
Coffield 365k
Milera 449k
English 425k

+ 9k in the bank.

 

[PAFC27]

Gonna back in Luke Parker another week.

Billings > Keeffe and swap a fresh Guelfi onto field.
Andrew Brayshaw > Macrae

 

[Shadow89]

No luxury trades for me this week now with news of Nic Nat's suspension. If he gets off will reverse it, but for now:

Savage > Mutch via Seeds DPP
Nic Nat > Stef Martin with 106K remaining

 

[Iskender Time]

They're only losing coin if you move them on.

Which you are going to want to do some time as part of team completion. On current form, Parker is not going to be among the best mids nor probably Billings among the top forwards. Losing value on falling stocks makes it harder to turn failed experiments into stepping stones to true premiums who will bank the scores that win your league games and push up overall rankings.

 

[Carey84]

I think I'll jump on Redden this week. 30 BE and no Shuey for at least this week, he's found some form and I think he'll go OK at least until the byes, maybe even make $100K while doing it. I don't trust Zorko just yet so will avoid for now.

English -> Keeffe
Finlayson -> Redden

Other option is whitfield - WCE don't really play the tagging half backer, as can be seen with Simpson and Lloyd earlier this year, so whits could go big at home. Although the amount of outs at GWS and WCE's pressure on the ball carrier may mean he gets less uncontested ball this game.

If Nic Nat doesn't get off, I can go NN -> Stef, but that leaves me with $0 in the bank and 0 ruckmen in the R13 bye

 

[bl4ke]

Even if he plays the next month with Shuey out for next 2 and he keeps his form until the byes, he could gain another 100k and score like an underpriced premo. Do you think he will be dropped soon?

bl4ke

Often a scapegoat at the selection table, however news is Sheed may need another week and Shuey is 3-4 away (I hope we don't risk him until after the bye tbh) so you would assume his JS is solid until then. As seen on the weekend, his tagging on Robbie Gray wasn't close and he definetely has more of a license to win his own ball than he used to. I think you could comfortably say that he will average ~80 for the next month, and his BE is only 16 so a 100k increase isn't out of the question. You just have to weigh up if it's worth the extra cash over a rookie and an extra trade over a keeper.

 

[dales.girl38]

I really am struggling with my team constantly having pure midfielders in my midfield, no DPPs to play with at all (4 mid/fwd in fwd, 2 def/mid in def). Amateur hour.

I've been close to trading Banfield, Fritsch, Dow and Brayshaw, but after a good week for all 4 their BE's are too low to trade this week. So far I've done English to Spargo. Leaves me with $207k and an upgrade to do, these are my current options:

Bont > move McLean to MID > Hogan
Bont > move Seedsman to MID > Sicily
Doedee/Finlayson > Sicily
Billings > Hogan
Billings > inanimate object

Could go anyway right now.

 

[TedDougChris]

I really am struggling with my team constantly having pure midfielders in my midfield, no DPPs to play with at all (4 mid/fwd in fwd, 2 def/mid in def). Amateur hour.

I've been close to trading Banfield, Fritsch, Dow and Brayshaw, but after a good week for all 4 their BE's are too low to trade this week. So far I've done English to Spargo. Leaves me with $207k and an upgrade to do, these are my current options:

Bont > move McLean to MID > Hogan
Bont > move Seedsman to MID > Sicily
Doedee/Finlayson > Sicily
Billings > Hogan
Billings > inanimate object

Could go anyway right now.

Last option. Inanimate objects are clearly an upgrade on Billings....

 

[SM]

Which you are going to want to do some time as part of team completion. On current form, Parker is not going to be among the best mids nor probably Billings among the top forwards. Losing value on falling stocks makes it harder to turn failed experiments into stepping stones to true premiums who will bank the scores that win your league games and push up overall rankings.

Why would you move premiums on for team completion?

 

[dales.girl38]

Last option. Inanimate objects are clearly an upgrade on Billings....

Yep! They should at least maintain their value, which is more than we can say for Jack.

 

[VSTone]

DON'T DO IT!!!!!!!! I started with him and traded out 2 weeks ago. Even Zerrett is a better option.
Zork may not get another 70 points all year

I hear ya, I've been proper ****ed by Zerrett too... I'm so far back I've got to tack into the wind.

 

[TheRednWhite]

So from this point onwards last year, Parker apparently went 108. Is this true? I don’t know what to do anymore.

 

[samFFC]

Often a scapegoat at the selection table, however news is Sheed may need another week and Shuey is 3-4 away (I hope we don't risk him until after the bye tbh) so you would assume his JS is solid until then. As seen on the weekend, his tagging on Robbie Gray wasn't close and he definetely has more of a license to win his own ball than he used to. I think you could comfortably say that he will average ~80 for the next month, and his BE is only 16 so a 100k increase isn't out of the question. You just have to weigh up if it's worth the extra cash over a rookie and an extra trade over a keeper.

Thanks for that!

A lot will depend on whether Milera is available. I'm using that spot (F4) as a spot to play the breakevens, with a view to getting back Walters in a few weeks but keeping up premium-level scoring.

Having said that I'll probably prioritise Zorko this week and won't be able to get him + Hutchings. But other injuries can come up so it's good to know.

 

[samFFC]

So from this point onwards last year, Parker apparently went 108. Is this true? I don’t know what to do anymore.

Looks like it:
https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pg-sydney-swans--luke-parker?year=2017&fantasy=y

But also last year Swans went 0-6 then romped into finals. His season tracked that, generally scoring 80s/90s when they lost, but tonning up in the wins. He isn't doing that this season.

 

[dales.girl38]

Did somebody mention having a spreadsheet where you track your player's week to week to see who is losing you the most money and to keep track of what price you brought players in at? I'm finding it hard to keep track of who has made money relative to when I traded them in (note: it's probably not a pretty picture, blissful ignorance might be better).

 

[SM]

Billings tons up in Saints wins and did that again this year in their only win so might just hold him for now.

Did somebody mention having a spreadsheet where you track your player's week to week to see who is losing you the most money and to keep track of what price you brought players in at? I'm finding it hard to keep track of who has made money relative to when I traded them in (note: it's probably not a pretty picture, blissful ignorance might be better).

Yeah that's me.



One thing that has occurred to me (in the above discussion about Top 6 FWDs) is that when a player misses a game their 0 isn't figured into their average, but for your team obviously you cop a premium missing a game. So should be factored in somehow.

 

[Jozzy]

Billings tons up in Saints wins and did that again this year in their only win so might just hold him for now.



Yeah that's me.

View attachment 494154

One thing that has occurred to me (in the above discussion about Top 6 FWDs) is that when a player misses a game their 0 isn't figured into their average, but for your team obviously you cop a premium missing a game. So should be factored in somehow.

My word, very impressive stuff mate!

 

[SM]

My word, very impressive stuff mate!

Most of it is formula driven, all I do is update for any games missed, total points scored (anyone I've brought in since Rd 1 I manually add their score for that week), their current price, and their BE.

For all the good it's done me!

 

[Iskender Time]

Why would you move premiums on for team completion?

Because I dont believe Parker or Billings are premiums (Those who will be top 10 in their position).
Last round I moved on Parker for Mcrae. In round four I moved Billings (then $623k, now $551k) on for R Gray (then $636k, now $693k). The sums on the points scored will also tell a good story on that trade. With Parker to Mcrae I dropped a disapointment and bought into the best scorer in the comp. The downside is fielding a dodgy rook like Finlayson but he and Mutch gained value and Finlay can be delt with this week. There would be a stack of cheaper players that will give me what Parker has, only without the nostalgia of past season. The Swans are a different team now. Even JJK makes me a lttle nervous as a pick.