Trades Round 9 Trades - Can I Buy a DEF Rookie ?

[raymagoo]

Anyone agonising over Carroll v Hamilton like me?

I can't take both and Hamilton being slightly cheaper and having DPP doesn't make much difference to me.

They look to score similarly (maybe Carroll a higher ceiling), but it comes down to JS I think.

Hamilton's JS is unknown and hard to predict given the change in coach. GWS aren't doing well and he may get a run of games.

Any Blues fans who can share a view on Carroll? I see he's retained his spot with Hewett returning but is there anyone else lining up for his spot?

Probably competing with setterfield who is a bitch! Carroll harder in a contest already

 

[SC fish]

Any thoughts?

Tempted to hold.

I’d like to move on NOD & Daicos but I don’t like def downgrade options

Can you downgrade Dixon/Ward/Daicos to MRJ or Hamilton, then upgrade NOD to a DEF keeper? Dunno how much cash you have left but should be possible

 

[SC fish]

Anyone agonising over Carroll v Hamilton like me?

I can't take both and Hamilton being slightly cheaper and having DPP doesn't make much difference to me.

They look to score similarly (maybe Carroll a higher ceiling), but it comes down to JS I think.

Hamilton's JS is unknown and hard to predict given the change in coach. GWS aren't doing well and he may get a run of games.

Any Blues fans who can share a view on Carroll? I see he's retained his spot with Hewett returning but is there anyone else lining up for his spot?

Tough choice - I'm taking neither (getting MRJ) but I'd probably lean towards Hamilton due to DPP and lower price

 

[Raveneyes]

2.3% ownership? YES PLEASE

$800k of Demon poo flushed away from my team, and the GIANT doorman makes his first appearance EVER in my teams. Also get the must have rooks this week, and add $235k to my bank (or le puswah as that superstar Obese Arachnid refers to it!)

That cash in the bank next week to go
Ward > Clark
Coleman > ANYBODY THE HELL I WANT! (Probs get a RND 14 DEF to keep the SDK/Paddy swing)

 

[arsene wenger1]

problem atm is there are no decent rookie defenders. Hows this Cleary kid debuting tonight?

 

[SC fish]

Now that teams have dropped what are your thoughts on the same INS but trading out Rosas instead of Gibcus? So it’d end up being…

NOD > Dawson
Rosas > Clark
Dixon > MRJ
View attachment 1399041View attachment 1399042

Yep I'd keep Rosas and hold Gibcus

 

[Ingy]

Which of you legends are already outta boosts … like me

If you’ve still got boosts you have a small chol

Used one this week, still got two left.

Four trades in one week during the byes is going to be fun. My tiny chol and I are going to enjoy that

 

[A Bit Dusty]

With Pendles out i think I'll beef up the back line. Do you trade NOD > Dawson or Gibcus > Docherty.

Doch not the best choice for my byes but it probably gives me another excuse to trade Butters....

Dawson

 

[Duckworthy]

Almost game time. Don't forget to check your VC's, C's and E's.

Good luck kenties

 

[Plugger35]

View attachment 1399092

2.3% ownership? YES PLEASE

$800k of Demon poo flushed away from my team, and the GIANT doorman makes his first appearance EVER in my teams. Also get the must have rooks this week, and add $235k to my bank (or le puswah as that superstar Obese Arachnid refers to it!)

That cash in the bank next week to go
Ward > Clark
Coleman > ANYBODY THE HELL I WANT! (Probs get a RND 14 DEF to keep the SDK/Paddy swing)

View attachment 1399099

Welcome to the ex-Jackson owners club, I flushed that useless turd for Witts a couple of weeks ago and it's one of the best trades I've ever made.

 

[Raveneyes]

Used one this week, still got two left.

Four trades in one week during the byes is going to be fun. My tiny chol and I are going to enjoy that

I have one left now. Dunno if I can wait until byes!

Would love to save it for Round 13 or 14, then go hard on players that have already had the bye.

 

[Raveneyes]

Almost game time. Don't forget to check your VC's, C's and E's.

Good luck kenties

...and to you too, my fine feathered friend!

 

[PoopingHindi]

still tossing up between Carroll, Clark and Hamilton.
I’ve had all of them in at one stage this week.

seriously considering bypassing the round 12 bye pair in the hope something better comes along.

 

[THECHIEFTON]

With Pendles out now I'm waiting to see how McComb goes tonight before I trade. If he spuds it I'll probably go early on Clark. Rather field him over SDK. I can see him scoring 30 the 1 time I have him on the field.

 

[Jiska]

Jiska you had him last year, yeah? You still watching him? Thoughts?

Love him. Just accumulates the ball and they play through him. Kicks the ball long every time. Plays a similar role to the original gull. I’m keen as mustard Duckworthy. In after his Bye most likely.

 

[GamerKnight]

still tossing up between Carroll, Clark and Hamilton.
I’ve had all of them in at one stage this week.

seriously considering bypassing the round 12 bye pair in the hope something better comes along.

Clark by the little toe of a baby seagull

 

[marcmurphy3]

Petracca or wait to 2 weeks for Mills?

Could also afford Keays or Laird instead of Trac but need to factor in price?

 

[Raveneyes]

Petracca or wait to 2 weeks for Mills?

Could also afford Keays or Laird instead of Trac but need to factor in price?

Also might need to factor in the byes.

 

[Mateyman]

Petracca or wait to 2 weeks for Mills?

Could also afford Keays or Laird instead of Trac but need to factor in price?

I thin Tracc at current price is value

 

[Duckworthy]

I'm sure it's already been mentioned. Apologies
The 3 bubble rookie trade-ins this week are Rioli (Rich), Carroll (Carl), and Hamilton (GWS)



FFS!

 

[kananooks]

I'm sure it's already been mentioned. Apologies
The 3 bubble rookie trade-ins this week are Rioli (Rich), Carroll (Carl), and Hamilton (GWS)

View attachment 1399348

FFS!

perfect opportunity to upgrade butters. also reaffirms my decision to cash in on gibcus.

regards to the rooks. flip a coin.

ive done a last minute change of carroll to hamilton for the extra 20k. extra money to make. and dpp. plus his stats without turnovers would be pretty good scores.

 

[Choppers]

I finished up going Bowey > Crisp, Dixon > Khamis (so I could get Hewett onfield and Paddy to F6) and that useless flog, Stephens to MRJ....

Now I have Khamis's 66, if Hewett is a late out.

 

[TheRednWhite]

NOD -> DC has been done

Next 2 trades will be

Dixon/Duddin (both spuds) -> MRJ/Hamilton
Bowey -> Zorko

 

[JDC!]

Is it worth doing a trade like Hough --> Rioli/Carroll/Hamilton for some cash generation or is too 'sideways'?

 

[toxic]

Is it worth doing a trade like Hough --> Rioli/Carroll/Hamilton for some cash generation or is too 'sideways'?

Yes it's worth it