Round 9 trades (if no Gawn yet, quit)

[Caztheconquerer]

Judd_Magic What would you do with this mess?

View attachment 922174

vast inboxed you mate

 

[Dark Sharks]

Kiss my lunchmeat Devon ya little kent

 

[Barry Roundhouse]

I need to know if Nobel and/or Doedee are going to play..

If only one doesn't play, i will likely go this, but id need to make a decision today...



I think i should just do this and save myself the stress....

 

[vast]

Kiss my lunchmeat Devon ya little kent

Should I trade him to Polson or Ackland via Darcy Cameron?

 

[Andrew Birch]

HELP HELP HELP
What would you do with this poor side.
I was thinking:

Hill --> Ling
Williamson --> Helmet (Daniel)
Taylor --> Close

Please pick my team to bits. Thoughts??
View attachment 922198

If it were my team I'd go

Hill > Stewart
Mcinerney > Close
Taylor > Georgiades
Bank $70K

 

[Red Syrah]

Really not sure on who to get in:

Dan Butler (been shit since I brought him in) > Parker

OR

King / Taylor / Starc / Noble > B.Smith

One of the above 4 duds will also go to Close to pay for upgrade.

Will prob need to keep Starc bc at least I know he plays, but can't be sure of Noble and will need a E if Doedee is out.

 

[Andrew Birch]

I need to know if Nobel and/or Doedee are going to play..

If only one doesn't play, i will likely go this, but id need to make a decision today...

View attachment 922202

I think i should just do this and save myself the stress....
View attachment 922204

You won't know today. Nobody can avoid flying blind from here on. May luck be in your favour.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Likely to cop the Keays tag this week too.

McGarth broke that tag pretty easy.
Hoping JY can deal with Alicca Keays .

 

[Gene Simmons]

what I was trying to point out is Option 2 gives you flexibility with your 3rd trade

I'm keeping Smith and upgrading rookies - but that's just me.

Unfortunately, I'm about $10k short of going Noble -> Daniel....

However I could go Doedee -> to either Daniel or Haynes...

 

[Dark Sharks]

If Polson is named these trades go in the bin, and i'll need to restructure adding in another Carlton premo.

 

[m!nt]

Desperate for some help, sorry to ask everyone.

Question - do I bring in Petracca and two rookies or B Smith, Ridley and 1 rookie?

(Does B Smith have it in him to be a top 6 forward?)

My team as is:

Trade options 1:

Trade options 2:

 

[jdeezy]

Only one of those I start on-field with any confidence is Rankine.

Mayes will probably be dropped for Rocky.

Hinkley has already said Rocky and Lienert are in for Bonner and Marshall, so Mayes and Georgiades are both still in this week.

 

[rocker_oz33]

What's better.

Taylor to Georgie.
Neddy to Close.
Willo to Stewart.

Or .

Dev to Georgia.
Taylor to Close.
Willo to Lloyd.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Desperate for some help, sorry to ask everyone.

Question - do I bring in Petracca and two rookies or B Smith, Ridley and 1 rookie?

(Does B Smith have it in him to be a top 6 forward?)

My team as is:

Trade options 1:

Trade options 2:

Neither option.

...assuming you have some money in the bank

McInerney >McPherson (via Rivers) Ling, if you have no money*
Brown > Close
Hill > Stewart

Sideways trading Devon won't get those 7 rookies off your field. Downgrade your bench rookies & upgrade your on-field rookies. #keepitsimple

 

[Andrew Birch]

Hinkley has already said Rocky and Lienert are in for Bonner and Marshall, so Mayes and Georgiades are both still in this week.

Inb4 Sutty 4 Mayes

 

[TempletonTheRat]

What's better.

Taylor to Georgie.
Neddy to Close.
Willo to Stewart.

Or .

Dev to Georgia.
Taylor to Close.
Willo to Lloyd.

so effectively Neddy > Stewart or Dev > Lloyd

I'd go 1 but they are both good options

 

[rocker_oz33]

so effectively Neddy > Stewart or Dev > Lloyd

I'd go 1 but they are both good options

So keep Devon 4 rookies on feild.

Trade Devon 5 rookies on feild.

Even tho Devon scoring like a rookie.
But no bye unless rested.

 

[m!nt]

Neither option.

...assuming you have some money in the bank

McInerney >McPherson (via Rivers) Ling, if you have no money*
Brown > Close
Hill > Stewart

Sideways trading Devon won't get those 7 rookies off your field. Downgrade your bench rookies & upgrade your on-field rookies. #keepitsimple

Thanks a lot.

 

[TempletonTheRat]

So keep Devon 4 rookies on feild.

Trade Devon 5 rookies on feild.

Even tho Devon scoring like a rookie.
But no bye unless rested.

his average is 77 - has to be better than your worst rookie on field.

 

[Benchpress]

Andrew Birch
I was looking at doing
Hill(off-field) > Georgiades via Rivers
King (on-field) > Close
DSmith (on-field) > Petracca

But with your wisdom I probably should be doing
Hill > Stewart
McInerney > Close
King > Georgiades (would use Gardner but wont have enough money for Stewart, also have Sturt but he's half a chance of playing this week).
That was my original plan, but thought I need Petracca before he becomes too expensive then I saw Stewart will be cheaper next week and also want Duncan but I'm poor.

I guess really it all comes down to who will score more out of Stewart/D.Smith vs Petracca/Rookie

 

[Scythe94]

Pondering a desperation move:
Simpkin -> Georgiades
McInerney -> Close OR Hill -> Ling/Watson
Pittospud -> SSSP Gawn

Would then be hoping for Simpkin to get Keyes-d this weekend, opening the door for the patented Roughead manoeuvre when he's down around 400k in a couple of weeks. I have no other way to get Max and it's depressing.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Judd_Magic What would you do with this mess?

View attachment 922174

No wonder you've been having some lower scores - carrying Fyfe didn't help - you are playing one premo short and suffer one more rookies score than you should.
I know, as I have been carrying him until the last round

 

[WaynesWorld19]

his average is 77 - has to be better than your worst rookie on field.

Yes .....and with GREAT DISGUST, is the same rationale for holding Rozee over the next couple of weeks ......please give me strength

 

[Benchpress]

Yes .....and with GREAT DISGUST, is the same rationale for holding Rozee over the next couple of weeks ......please give me strength

Been having decent 1st quarters lately but then fades again like our hope for him

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Been having decent 1st quarters lately but then fades again like our hope for him

He's on a fat HFF ......just nothing going thru him