Round 9 trades (if no Gawn yet, quit)

[Andrew Birch]

Still no trades done as yet. What would you do with this team? Will probable put dodo on the pine.
I was thinking:
Hill -> Ridley
Mclnerney -> Close
Taylor -> Georgiades

Or
Hill -> Stewart
Mclnerney -> Close
Taylor -> Georgiades
Thoughts?
View attachment 922973

Stewart & Ridley should score similar. Ridley has a game in hand though, so him.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Will be interesting to finally see what all the fuss has been about with Don Draper.

Done absolutely nothing, proven absolutely nothing, offered a lucrative contract and attempt to be poached by St Kilda... hasn't even played yet.



He'd wanna be as good as Ackland as a minimum after all that.

 

[Ollie1981]

Stewart & Ridley should score similar. Ridley has a game in hand though, so him.

Or can you see a better trades. That's the best I could come up with.

 

[RoughysMullet]

Ling but not particularly enamored with either of them.

Yeah my desperation for a defender rookie has reached epic proportions thanks to SHill and Poodee injuries

 

[Northernsoul74]

Yeah my desperation for a defender rookie has reached epic proportions thanks to SHill and Poodee injuries

Yep I’m holding off as late as possible to see if Gould gets names this week. It would be Willo down to him or Ling but the Blues game starts before sat teams announced.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Will be interesting to finally see what all the fuss has been about with Don Draper.

Done absolutely nothing, proven absolutely nothing, offered a lucrative contract and attempt to be poached by St Kilda... hasn't even played yet.



He'd wanna be as good as Ackland as a minimum after all that.

He was recently described as "just like Polson, except much taller" so he can definitely play.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Yeah my desperation for a defender rookie has reached epic proportions thanks to SHill and Poodee injuries

Welcome to my world kent. Had Brander and Rivers as perma spuds on the bench for the past 4 weeks.

Meanwhile every time Hill walks i wet my pants thinking he's going to give me an on field donut. Happened last week in fact.


And all while i've had to carry Starcevich on field as well the POS! 38, 31, 51, 48 during this period.

I've got him on field again this week because it's just not worth trading him when there's no options.



Some prick becomes Hurn this week.

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Who would you trade out for Georgiades though? The only real options to downgrade to Georgi are Bennell or Buda and all that would achieve would be to make your forward line weaker as you'd have to move a premo fwd to the mids . Also depends on whether you want/need hard currency for upgrades in Rd10

I would take the cash and use it on Noble > Stewart next week.

I could do Willo or Noble via DPP (Rivers to Defence, Close to Mids). Means Rankine and then 1 of Georgi/Aarts is on field each week down fwd and then mid bench would be Close, Buda and Benell

I think the simplest option is Ling and then Noble to Stewart next week as you said.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Or can you see a better trades. That's the best I could come up with.

You have a Rd10 bye problem in Def with 5 missing, so I would sort that out this week before Willo bleeds more cash & while Mcpherson is cheaper than him. You should have just enough cash

Williamson > McPherson
Hill > Stewart
McInerney > Close

 

[Quazza]

He was recently described as "just like Polson, except much taller" so he can definitely play.

the Polsgod on track to win our scratch match BnF participation award

 

[vast]

Will be interesting to finally see what all the fuss has been about with Don Draper.

Done absolutely nothing, proven absolutely nothing, offered a lucrative contract and attempt to be poached by St Kilda... hasn't even played yet.



He'd wanna be as good as Ackland as a minimum after all that.

It never dissapoints.

 

[Benchpress]

Who will make more money from this point McPherson or Georgiades?

 

[Dark Sharks]

Is Georgi a must have?

Already jumped 49k, but looks like he'll get an exted run of games with old mate Marshall out, so should put up another 100k at least by the way he's scored.



Thing is i remember people in the gameday threads saying his 86 score was bullshit and he was lucky to have got more than 60.

 

[MagicGnome97]

Who to field:

Sam Simpson or Close?

Curtis Taylor or Georgiades?

 

[Benchpress]

Who to field:

Sam Simpson or Close?

Curtis Taylor or Georgiades?

I need to decide the same on the first. From last game you'd think Close, looks like a genuine small forward

 

[Ollie1981]

You have a Rd10 bye problem in Def with 5 missing, so I would sort that out this week before Willo bleeds more cash & while Mcpherson is cheaper than him. You should have just enough cash

Williamson > McPherson
Hill > Stewart
McInerney > Close

cheers

 

[Loose at HB]

Rightio kents. Here's the current debacle


Bit disengaged with SC after last night given I'm already 100+ behind par so there's a little bit of "no ****s given" about the way I'm approaching this.
Cash gen is ****ed but whatever.
Currently thinking of;
Willo -> Ling
Taylor -> Close
Lunchmeat -> Petracca

Think Trac is a must have and clear F1 and is likely worth 80+ points over that flog Devon. Ling and Close should match Willo/Curtis and will make $$$.
Hill stays by virtue of the fact he isn't going to lose $$$ this week and I can use him as my C loophole when Maxxy goes 250 tonight.

Next week Hill/Budarick/Mahony out to Stewart and a couple of spuds.

Can anyone else think of anything better? Obviously if Ling is dropped I'm ****ed and eating a donut but again no ****s given

 

[mochacinolatte]

Is Georgi a must have?

Already jumped 49k, but looks like he'll get an exted run of games with old mate Marshall out, so should put up another 100k at least by the way he's scored.



Thing is i remember people in the gameday threads saying his 86 score was bullshit and he was lucky to have got more than 60.

Bought Sam Simpsom last week for 55k price rise. Depends on how desperate you need cash gen

 

[Dark Sharks]

Bought Sam Simpsom last week for 55k price rise. Depends on how desperate you need cash gen

Yeah i wasn't planning on it but i don't think Georgi can be ignored unfortunately.

He'll make 100k in the next 2-3 weeks minumum.


Looks like Georgi and Close are both must trades this week unfortunately. That's annoying.

 

[Quazza]

Who to field:

Sam Simpson or Close?

are we even 100% sure Simpson will be named?

thats the news Im waiting for as if he's dropped, I'll ditch him for Close rather than Bud

 

[Northernsoul74]

are we even 100% sure Simpson will be named?

thats the news Im waiting for as if he's dropped, I'll ditch him for Close rather than Bud

Latest from Geelong is Steven unlikely and sounds like they’ll give Selwood another week off.

 

[Faz 2000]

LEL at everyone jumping off Willo. Just wait, he's gonna smash out a 85+ and then it's Cash-Gen City, Population: Me.

 

[go you pups]

Only 1 team in the top 15 had Dusty before this round started.
Hopefully they didn't have the funds to get him in this week, would be a massive leg up for you.

Geez

Betcha none of those teams copped the Essendon/Melbourne farce either otherwise we'd be hot on their heels...

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Rightio kents. Here's the current debacle
View attachment 923010

Bit disengaged with SC after last night given I'm already 100+ behind par so there's a little bit of "no fu**s given" about the way I'm approaching this.
Cash gen is f’ed but whatever.
Currently thinking of;
Willo -> Ling
Taylor -> Close
Lunchmeat -> Petracca

Think Trac is a must have and clear F1 and is likely worth 80+ points over that flog Devon. Ling and Close should match Willo/Curtis and will make $$$.
Hill stays by virtue of the fact he isn't going to lose $$$ this week and I can use him as my C loophole when Maxxy goes 250 tonight.

Next week Hill/Budarick/Mahony out to Stewart and a couple of spuds.

Can anyone else think of anything better? Obviously if Ling is dropped I'm f’ed and eating a donut but again no fu**s given

so what are you doing with the 5 defenders who have a bye next week?

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Geez

Betcha none of those teams copped the Essendon/Melbourne farce either otherwise we'd be hot on their heels...

Wasn't looking for Dee's players when I checked but most seemed to have Gawn and Petracca at least, but no way to tell if they had them from the start or had traded in.