Round 9 trades (if no Gawn yet, quit)

[rabzz04]

Trades done so far - Taylor and McInerny to Close and B.Smith
Still deciding on what to do with Doedee (134k in bank, no bench cover). Do I sideways trade a rookie on my bench for Ling? Plan was to always hold Doedee and turn Starcevich into Stewart next week and defence is done.

Trading Doedee (to say McPherson) allows me to trade up two rookies next week to premos (potentially Star to Stewart and Simpson to premo mid around 520k)...

Thoughts??


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Glorin]

Trades DONE
OUT:
WILLIAMSPUD
MCINERNEYSPUD
CURTISTAYLOR

IN
LING LONGMIRE
CLOSE CAT

and....

PATRICK RYDER (hold me, this could hurt)

I love this trade. I so want to do it, but not sure I have the plums for it.

 

[Gold Rocks]

His scoring is awesome
Saints playing 2 rucks hopefully means no need to rest

You think close will have job security if they get smashed by west coast and then a bye with 4 players healthy to take his spot in Narkle, Stevens, Sellwood and Gaz?

 

[Glorin]

You think close will have job security if they get smashed by west coast and then a bye with 4 players healthy to take his spot in Narkle, Stevens, Sellwood and Gaz?

Geelong are going to have their bye between rds13-15 so not sure how that affects him short term. What Close does is opens up another DPP option at low cost freeing up more cash than another rookie. Good chance to play another 1-2 weeks after this and then he has done his job. Dont see the problem.

 

[DGroover]

Bennell
Hill
Mcinerney Out

Close
Ling
Hurn In


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[toxic]

You think close will have job security if they get smashed by west coast and then a bye with 4 players healthy to take his spot in Narkle, Stevens, Sellwood and Gaz?

No one has job security

 

[MITS]

No one has job security

My cousin has a job in security. But his job isn’t that secure

 

[toxic]

My cousin has a job in security. But his job isn’t that secure

Cue the dad jokes

 

[SC fish]

Ended up going Brander, Macca and Buda to Stewart, Frodo and Close

 

[Gene Simmons]

Question for Doedee owners... have you held him?

My dilemma, I currently have both Doedee (D4) & S.Hill (D6) onfield (so I will be forced to use Starcevich score for one of them).

Option 1
Doedee -> Haynes... Is this trade too short sighted + it will leave me with less than <$20k in the bank.

Option 2
Doedee -> McPherson. Leaves me with about $220k profit.

Option 3
Hill -> McPherson. $50k profit.

The general consensus will make up my mind because it's doing my head in

Cheers guys

 

[Schulzenfest]

Question for Doedee owners... have you held him?

My dilemma, I currently have both Doedee (D4) & S.Hill (D6) onfield (so I will be forced to use Starcevich score for one of them).

Option 1
Doedee -> Haynes... Is this trade too short sighted + it will leave me with less than <$20k in the bank.

Option 2
Doedee -> McPherson. Leaves me with about $220k profit.

Option 3
Hill -> McPherson. $50k profit.

The general consensus will make up my mind because it's doing my head in

Cheers guys

None of the above. Doedee will be back next week so I'm not doing one or two, and McPherson is too expensive to downgrade to so I'm not doing 3. Trade Hill for Ling and actually make some cash.

 

[d0nsm8]

Hey guys, I’m trading Fyfe today, but need some money to upgrade my D6 to Stewart next round. I don’t want to spend anymore than $540 000. Who should I bring in? I’m tossing up between Duncan and Parker. I already have Dangerfield, Simpson and will have Stewart next week, so maybe Parker would be better?

 

[Gene Simmons]

Hey guys, I’m trading Fyfe today, but need some money to upgrade my D6 to Stewart next round. I don’t want to spend anymore than $540 000. Who should I bring in? I’m tossing up between Duncan and Parker. I already have Dangerfield, Simpson and will have Stewart next week, so maybe Parker would be better?

I would go Parker too.. ultra POD and ultra consistent.. Take out his one bad score of 45 in Round 6... He has averaged 119 over the other 7 games.

 

[Phoenix_9]

None of the above. Doedee will be back next week so I'm not doing one or two, and McPherson is too expensive to downgrade to so I'm not doing 3. Trade Hill for Ling and actually make some cash.

I’m in the exact same situation and I’m on board the Hill to Ling train too.

 

[Faz 2000]

Will finalise today...

King to B Smith
Green/McInerney to Close
Brander to Hurn

Willo covered for Doedee and did an almost passable job.

 

[Gold Rocks]

No one has job security

Geelong are going to have their bye between rds13-15 so not sure how that affects him short term. What Close does is opens up another DPP option at low cost freeing up more cash than another rookie. Good chance to play another 1-2 weeks after this and then he has done his job. Dont see the problem.

Thanks ive had so many injuries im about 2/3 premiums short but not sure what to do as was going to upgrade Stevens to whitfield or do i go close for king or Keane in the back line.

 

[Plugger35]

Last trade Brander > McPherson

Hopefully he survives my defender injury curse, the last two defenders I've traded in were Young and Doedee.

 

[Phoenix_9]

Last trade Brander > McPherson

Hopefully he survives my defender injury curse, the last two defenders I've traded in were Young and Doedee.

You’ve made my decision between Ling and McPherson, very easy, cheers!

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Last trade Brander > McPherson

Hopefully he survives my defender injury curse, the last two defenders I've traded in were Young and Doedee.

I'd love to bring in McPherson .....but having 3 Crows DEF would be catastrophic with upcoming byes

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Has this always been a feature .....went to replace Bennell onfield today, forgot he'd played (these gametimes are doing my head in)

Anyway, frustrated that I was .....I was still able to choose a player on the bench to still put the (E) on .....I hadn't decided on the (E) due to potential trades & waiting to see who was named

Has this always been the case .....yes I'm a dumb campaigner

 

[Quazza]

Final trade of Brander > Thigh Master now locked

Don't let me down you cheap bald god

 

[stevebbb]

Has this always been a feature .....went to replace Bennell onfield today, forgot he'd played (these gametimes are doing my head in)

Anyway, frustrated that I was .....I was still able to choose a player on the bench to still put the (E) on .....I hadn't decided on the (E) due to potential trades & waiting to see who was named

Has this always been the case .....yes I'm a dumb campaigner

View attachment 924540

Blatant flex of your midfield

 

[Quazza]

Has this always been a feature .....went to replace Bennell onfield today, forgot he'd played (these gametimes are doing my head in)

Anyway, frustrated that I was .....I was still able to choose a player on the bench to still put the (E) on .....I hadn't decided on the (E) due to potential trades & waiting to see who was named

Has this always been the case .....yes I'm a dumb campaigner

View attachment 924540

Always been the way mate

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Always been the way mate

No wonder Andrew Birch always beats me ......I knew there had to be a logical reason for it

 

[Quazza]

No wonder Andrew Birch always beats me ......I knew there had to be a logical reason for it

Interesting

I find he generally always outscores me as he's a lot better than me at this stupid game