iluvessendon
Rookie
Re: Round 10 - Trades
montagna and murphy or ablett and rookie?
montagna and murphy or ablett and rookie?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Rounds 9 & 10 - Trades
- Thread starter IDIG
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- May 27, 2006
- 44,781
- 88,901
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- I'm aware of and love the Miami Dolphins
- Moderator
- #852
Re: Round 10 - Trades
To be honest I think it depends on the rest of your midfield and team. How many good captain options do you have? How many rookies are you starting? How many trades do you have left?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
B: Hodge; Goddard; Enright; Goodwin; Waters; Maguire; Davis (Gram; Webberley)
C: Ablett (c); Barlow; Dal Santo; Judd (vc); Ball; Trengove (Stevenson; Shuey)
R: Sandilands; Hille (Warnock; Lobbe)
F: Pavlich; Brown; O'Keefe; Hall; Ballantyne; Podsiadly; Watts (Gumbleton; Gray)
Underlined are my possible trades for this week.
I would very much like to get Goodes in.
Thinking any of:
OPTION 1:
Ballantyne > Goodes
Trengove > Murphy (JUST short of Bartel
)
OPTION 2:
Gray > Goodes (depends on severity of injury)
Trengove > Montagna
OPTION 3:
Trengove > Goodes
Waters > Gilbee
OPTION 4:
Trengove > Goodes
Ballantyne > Franklin/Grundy
Or any other multitude of options. Hmm. $191,700 in the bank, any thoughts? 12 trades left.
To be honest I think it depends on the rest of your midfield and team. How many good captain options do you have? How many rookies are you starting? How many trades do you have left?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
B: Hodge; Goddard; Enright; Goodwin; Waters; Maguire; Davis (Gram; Webberley)
C: Ablett (c); Barlow; Dal Santo; Judd (vc); Ball; Trengove (Stevenson; Shuey)
R: Sandilands; Hille (Warnock; Lobbe)
F: Pavlich; Brown; O'Keefe; Hall; Ballantyne; Podsiadly; Watts (Gumbleton; Gray)
Underlined are my possible trades for this week.
I would very much like to get Goodes in.
Thinking any of:
OPTION 1:
Ballantyne > Goodes
Trengove > Murphy (JUST short of Bartel
)OPTION 2:
Gray > Goodes (depends on severity of injury)
Trengove > Montagna
OPTION 3:
Trengove > Goodes
Waters > Gilbee
OPTION 4:
Trengove > Goodes
Ballantyne > Franklin/Grundy
Or any other multitude of options. Hmm. $191,700 in the bank, any thoughts? 12 trades left.
reddahaydn
Senior List
Re: Round 10 - Trades
hmmm i cant believe u dont have ablett, however i'd go montagna and murphy...i'd rather ablett and murphy tho...
mine:
to trade silvagni to roberton and bastinac to ROK this week of next week?
hmmm i cant believe u dont have ablett, however i'd go montagna and murphy...i'd rather ablett and murphy tho...
mine:
to trade silvagni to roberton and bastinac to ROK this week of next week?
themightybloods
Senior List
Re: Round 10 - Trades
im looking at harbrow in for kennelly and franklin in for brown
im looking at harbrow in for kennelly and franklin in for brown
reddahaydn
Senior List
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Definately option 2To be honest I think it depends on the rest of your midfield and team. How many good captain options do you have? How many rookies are you starting? How many trades do you have left?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
B: Hodge; Goddard; Enright; Goodwin; Waters; Maguire; Davis (Gram; Webberley)
C: Ablett (c); Barlow; Dal Santo; Judd (vc); Ball; Trengove (Stevenson; Shuey)
R: Sandilands; Hille (Warnock; Lobbe)
F: Pavlich; Brown; O'Keefe; Hall; Ballantyne; Podsiadly; Watts (Gumbleton; Gray)
Underlined are my possible trades for this week.
I would very much like to get Goodes in.
Thinking any of:
OPTION 1:
Ballantyne > Goodes
Trengove > Murphy (JUST short of Bartel
OPTION 2:
Gray > Goodes (depends on severity of injury)
Trengove > Montagna
OPTION 3:
Trengove > Goodes
Waters > Gilbee
OPTION 4:
Trengove > Goodes
Ballantyne > Franklin/Grundy
Or any other multitude of options. Hmm. $191,700 in the bank, any thoughts? 12 trades left.
themightybloods
Senior List
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Why would you get rid of brown? I agree with redda
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Maybe you should do this;
Harbrow > Hodge and Franklin > Chapman.. Make yourself $400k
For starters, Franklin > Brown is a sideways trade and even worse, Brown is still playing, he might have a few niggles but im 100% sure he will get over that in the coming weeks..
Maybe you should do this;
Harbrow > Hodge and Franklin > Chapman.. Make yourself $400k
Re: Round 10 - Trades
So many trade options this week I could use 3
B Hodge Goddard Enright Shaw Water Goose Davis (Kennelly Webberly)
C Ablett Swan Judd Cooney Barlow Martin (Trengrove Howlett)
R Sandilands Hille (Lobbe Warnock)
F Pavlich Brown ROK PODS Franklin Dangerfield Tippett (Medhurst Gumby)
Was thinking about
Trengrove > Goodes
Medhurst/Tippett > Rohan,Playfair or Watts... leaning towards Watts at this stage.
These trades can switch obviously just depends on if I want MPP flexibility.
Dont have enough $$$ to do a double upgrade this week so Kennelly can wait.
Thoughts?
So many trade options this week I could use 3
B Hodge Goddard Enright Shaw Water Goose Davis (Kennelly Webberly)
C Ablett Swan Judd Cooney Barlow Martin (Trengrove Howlett)
R Sandilands Hille (Lobbe Warnock)
F Pavlich Brown ROK PODS Franklin Dangerfield Tippett (Medhurst Gumby)
Was thinking about
Trengrove > Goodes
Medhurst/Tippett > Rohan,Playfair or Watts... leaning towards Watts at this stage.
These trades can switch obviously just depends on if I want MPP flexibility.
Dont have enough $$$ to do a double upgrade this week so Kennelly can wait.
Thoughts?
MattBrads14
Debutant
- Feb 3, 2010
- 69
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Arsenal
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Getting rid of cyril, been a pain in my forward line all year,
Lookin to downgrade for D7 or (depending on a few things) possible cow spot on the pine
Options are
Playfair(not sure bout him, was last week a one off, JS?) or
Watts(really impressive, good hands clean under pressure, but does he score enough, can he get some more of the pill) or even
Leroy Jetta(hit some good form and looks like he could be quite good this year plus hes a bit of a different pick)
SO
Playfair + 124,500 or
Watts + 92,000 or
Leroy Jetta
Open to other sugestions
Getting rid of cyril, been a pain in my forward line all year,
Lookin to downgrade for D7 or (depending on a few things) possible cow spot on the pine
Options are
Playfair(not sure bout him, was last week a one off, JS?) or
Watts(really impressive, good hands clean under pressure, but does he score enough, can he get some more of the pill) or even
Leroy Jetta(hit some good form and looks like he could be quite good this year plus hes a bit of a different pick)
SO
Playfair + 124,500 or
Watts + 92,000 or
Leroy Jetta
Open to other sugestions
themightybloods
Senior List
Re: Round 10 - Trades
well i have 136k in the bank so maybe just upgrade hall to franklin
well i have 136k in the bank so maybe just upgrade hall to franklin
Re: Round 10 - Trades
How about these trades
Medhurst > Watts
Trengrove > Goodes
Then MPP Goodes to the forward line... or is it worth holding onto Mehurst and trade Tippett (who has already lost so much) to Watts/Playfair/Whoever every one else is talking about
Do these trades look okay?
How about these trades
Medhurst > Watts
Trengrove > Goodes
Then MPP Goodes to the forward line... or is it worth holding onto Mehurst and trade Tippett (who has already lost so much) to Watts/Playfair/Whoever every one else is talking about
Do these trades look okay?
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
Re: Round 10 - Trades
just traded out propliza for watts (on bench/ cash cow) have 780.000 to get a mid do l get the best in gazz or plan 2 get chappy/pav/judd OR save some cash to up grade tag kennlley next week
just traded out propliza for watts (on bench/ cash cow) have 780.000 to get a mid do l get the best in gazz or plan 2 get chappy/pav/judd OR save some cash to up grade tag kennlley next week
Pure_Ownage
TheBrownDog
Re: Round 10 - Trades
I'd do Trengove > Rohan (better JS than Playfair maybe) then Tippett > Goodes depending on whether you can afford such a double trade. Then you upgrade Martin in a week or two and Rohan becomes your 7th mid and your MPP.
So many trade options this week I could use 3
B Hodge Goddard Enright Shaw Water Goose Davis (Kennelly Webberly)
C Ablett Swan Judd Cooney Barlow Martin (Trengrove Howlett)
R Sandilands Hille (Lobbe Warnock)
F Pavlich Brown ROK PODS Franklin Dangerfield Tippett (Medhurst Gumby)
Was thinking about
Trengrove > Goodes
Medhurst/Tippett > Rohan,Playfair or Watts... leaning towards Watts at this stage.
These trades can switch obviously just depends on if I want MPP flexibility.
Dont have enough $$$ to do a double upgrade this week so Kennelly can wait.
Thoughts?
I'd do Trengove > Rohan (better JS than Playfair maybe) then Tippett > Goodes depending on whether you can afford such a double trade. Then you upgrade Martin in a week or two and Rohan becomes your 7th mid and your MPP.
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Possibles at the moment-
Martin -> Judd & White-> Graham. Leaves me with only about $35K
Martin-> Montagna & White -> Graham. Leaves me about $85K
Bastinac-Montagna is also doable, but with less cash left over.
Will leave me with Ablett, Dal Santo, Pendlebury, Cooney, Barlow as my other mids, and Sandilands as first ruck.
Trouble is I still have a rubbish forward line, but I can look at fixing that next week- $50K more will help with that.
Anyone?
Possibles at the moment-
Martin -> Judd & White-> Graham. Leaves me with only about $35K
Martin-> Montagna & White -> Graham. Leaves me about $85K
Bastinac-Montagna is also doable, but with less cash left over.
Will leave me with Ablett, Dal Santo, Pendlebury, Cooney, Barlow as my other mids, and Sandilands as first ruck.
Trouble is I still have a rubbish forward line, but I can look at fixing that next week- $50K more will help with that.
Anyone?
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
Re: Round 10 - Trades
l think watts is cheap low break-even can play forward and ruck maybe gary rohan he is 198.000 ish and is a mpp
l think watts is cheap low break-even can play forward and ruck maybe gary rohan he is 198.000 ish and is a mpp
Re: Round 10 - Trades
just done
duncan to watts
cyril to petrie (mpp bonus)
nw bring in ROK
just done
duncan to watts
cyril to petrie (mpp bonus)
nw bring in ROK
Nightman Cometh
Draftee
- Apr 4, 2010
- 9
- 0
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Dal Santo or Montagna?
Dal Santo or Montagna?
Re: Round 10 - Trades
I was wondering if I missed the Rohan train
But what about Medhurst then? persistent foot injury apparently and Tippett has also lost so much value.
Not sure which one
A Trengrove > Rohan or
B Medhurst/Tippett > Watts
Then whoever is left > Goodes
I was wondering if I missed the Rohan train
But what about Medhurst then? persistent foot injury apparently and Tippett has also lost so much value.
Not sure which one
A Trengrove > Rohan or
B Medhurst/Tippett > Watts
Then whoever is left > Goodes
Re: Round 10 - Trades
Sorry I meant who should I put on the ground out of Tippett, Watts, Rockcliff this week
Sorry I meant who should I put on the ground out of Tippett, Watts, Rockcliff this week
Pure_Ownage
TheBrownDog
Re: Round 10 - Trades
You haven't missed it his BE's are still neg.
Obviously Tippett and Medhurst are worries. But I think Tippett is a bigger worry as he's been crap all year, is likely to lose money this week, and the way Adel are going there's no real prospect of it turning around.
Whereas Medhurst, if he can get fit, has that potential...and unless the Pies are hiding something, it's not like he has a stress fracture, so I'd stick fat for one more week.
I was wondering if I missed the Rohan train
But what about Medhurst then? persistent foot injury apparently and Tippett has also lost so much value.
Not sure which one
A Trengrove > Rohan or
B Medhurst/Tippett > Watts
Then whoever is left > Goodes
You haven't missed it his BE's are still neg.
Obviously Tippett and Medhurst are worries. But I think Tippett is a bigger worry as he's been crap all year, is likely to lose money this week, and the way Adel are going there's no real prospect of it turning around.
Whereas Medhurst, if he can get fit, has that potential...and unless the Pies are hiding something, it's not like he has a stress fracture, so I'd stick fat for one more week.
Pure_Ownage
TheBrownDog
Re: Round 10 - Trades
watts is fwd only $145 k rohan $198k mpp
rohan's BE is lower
watts is fwd only $145 k rohan $198k mpp
rohan's BE is lower
- Status
