-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Scarlett - 3 weeks with guilty plea
- Thread starter Sloth
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
It is supposed to be a pretty simple system.
http://www.afl.com.au/tribunal system/tabid/13707/default.aspx
Someone posted a bit earlier all the details. They seem spot on to me, 225 points = 1 week with an early plea, and left with some carry over points. Maybe the MRP will make it medium impact (325 points) to try and bump it up to 2 weeks.
Can't understand why people are pulling all these random suggestions out of the air like 4 or 6 weeks, and completely ignoring the actual MRP system.
It is supposed to be a pretty simple system.
http://www.afl.com.au/tribunal system/tabid/13707/default.aspx
Someone posted a bit earlier all the details. They seem spot on to me, 225 points = 1 week with an early plea, and left with some carry over points. Maybe the MRP will make it medium impact (325 points) to try and bump it up to 2 weeks.
Can't understand why people are pulling all these random suggestions out of the air like 4 or 6 weeks, and completely ignoring the actual MRP system.
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
Just saw the replay of the incident on "Housewives News"
Scarlo gave him a bop, there was like a 1-2 second pause, then Ballantyne went down like someone had potted him from the grassy knoll.
Dumb from Scarlo but fair dinkum was that the most embarassingly fake stage ever???
Just saw the replay of the incident on "Housewives News"
Scarlo gave him a bop, there was like a 1-2 second pause, then Ballantyne went down like someone had potted him from the grassy knoll.
Dumb from Scarlo but fair dinkum was that the most embarassingly fake stage ever???
- Aug 17, 2009
- 29,150
- 26,018
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Phila 76ers , Phila Eagles , Man U
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
Please don't talk about staging when you've got Stevie J in your team. When he stages for a free in front of goal and gets a goal out of it do you think it's a bad thing ??
I think not.
Please don't talk about staging when you've got Stevie J in your team. When he stages for a free in front of goal and gets a goal out of it do you think it's a bad thing ??
I think not.
- Thread starter
- #106
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
I can't believe the naivety on this thread. This is the AFL we're talking about. As if they'd tolerate a deliberate punch to the head. You've seen what they give for in-play offences, this is a whole different level
I can't believe the naivety on this thread. This is the AFL we're talking about. As if they'd tolerate a deliberate punch to the head. You've seen what they give for in-play offences, this is a whole different level
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
I'm on the record as saying Johnno's a good enough player that he doesn't need to do that sort of stupid shit.
I'm on the record as saying Johnno's a good enough player that he doesn't need to do that sort of stupid shit.
- Moderator
- #109
hawkman
Hall of Famer
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
Pretty sure he has some points left over from the Hawthorn game last year, so he is probably looking at minimum 2 maximum 3
Is there a site that lists these?
Pretty sure he has some points left over from the Hawthorn game last year, so he is probably looking at minimum 2 maximum 3
Is there a site that lists these?
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
Wonder what Ballantyne was saying to Scarlett monents before the Barry hall copy cat try hard punch landed.
Wonder what Ballantyne was saying to Scarlett monents before the Barry hall copy cat try hard punch landed.
- Mar 14, 2009
- 2,258
- 2,718
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
And scarlett got upset because he is a premiership player
And scarlett got upset because he is a premiership player
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
Is there any chance it can go straight to the tribunal like what happened with barry hall???
Hall's punch wasnt assessed with the Intentional, high contact, high impact etc. It went straight to the tribunal and bypassed the MRP assessment.
I dont think it will but what do others reckon??
Scarlett is very very lucky he didnt get him an inch higher or he might have broken his jaw, luck is was more of a glancing blow but its just the intent of the action that i think will have him in trouble.
On another note, am just watching the replay of the game. I am a massive Stevie J fan but i think he set the record for most dives in a single game last night. Quiet funny.
Is there any chance it can go straight to the tribunal like what happened with barry hall???
Hall's punch wasnt assessed with the Intentional, high contact, high impact etc. It went straight to the tribunal and bypassed the MRP assessment.
I dont think it will but what do others reckon??
Scarlett is very very lucky he didnt get him an inch higher or he might have broken his jaw, luck is was more of a glancing blow but its just the intent of the action that i think will have him in trouble.
On another note, am just watching the replay of the game. I am a massive Stevie J fan but i think he set the record for most dives in a single game last night. Quiet funny.
Plugger35
Umpiring Expert
- Sep 27, 2008
- 139,976
- 162,539
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, Black Caps, Sea Eagles, Subiaco
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
Should only be a couple of weeks at most, wasn't that hard a punch and Ballantyne made it look worse than it was by taking a dive.
Ballantyne should get as many weeks for provoking players and diving, he is a blight on the game.
Should only be a couple of weeks at most, wasn't that hard a punch and Ballantyne made it look worse than it was by taking a dive.
Ballantyne should get as many weeks for provoking players and diving, he is a blight on the game.
Hoffy95
Norm Smith Medallist
Hoffy95
Norm Smith Medallist
- Oct 25, 2007
- 2,722
- 67
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Thunder
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
Yeah, like they're ever going to impose the staging rule. If Balla's get's done for that, their will be 20 players with cases to answer for every week.
Scarlett should get 3-4 with an early plea imo.
Yeah, like they're ever going to impose the staging rule. If Balla's get's done for that, their will be 20 players with cases to answer for every week.
Scarlett should get 3-4 with an early plea imo.
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
The AFL need to start somewhere before soccer culture becomes the norm. The warning shot re Kane Cornes did nothing.
The AFL need to start somewhere before soccer culture becomes the norm. The warning shot re Kane Cornes did nothing.
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
Poor by Scarlett and by Ballantyne. Agree with the High Contact, Deliberate and Low Impact for 1 week post concessions, all it deserves at worst.
For all the ranting in this thread after seeing the video there really isn't anything in it.
Poor by Scarlett and by Ballantyne. Agree with the High Contact, Deliberate and Low Impact for 1 week post concessions, all it deserves at worst.
For all the ranting in this thread after seeing the video there really isn't anything in it.
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
For 2012, the Commission approved the following recommendations:
...
Staging
- MRP instructed to be more stringent on staging, with excessive exaggeration of contact in an unsportsmanlike manner to be a reportable offence in addition to feigning contact.
This is the interesting one - the video shows that Ballantyne obviously throws himself backwards 0.5 to 1.0 seconds after Scarlett makes contact with him, flipping himself onto his back, which definitely constitutes 'excessive exaggeration of contact'. The exaggeration is proven by the fact that he suffered no ill effects from the contact, was able to take his shot at goal, and didn't need to leave the field after the incident. I don't expect the MRP to have the balls to do anything about it though, even though it is clearly written into the rules.
My guess in the MRP 'lotto' is anywhere between 3-5 weeks for Scarlett.
And to all the Collingwood and Hawthorn supporters bleating on about SJ being a diver - whether or not it is true, it is irrelevant to the discussion of this incident. Take your whingeing to Bay 13.
For 2012, the Commission approved the following recommendations:
...
Staging
- MRP instructed to be more stringent on staging, with excessive exaggeration of contact in an unsportsmanlike manner to be a reportable offence in addition to feigning contact.
This is the interesting one - the video shows that Ballantyne obviously throws himself backwards 0.5 to 1.0 seconds after Scarlett makes contact with him, flipping himself onto his back, which definitely constitutes 'excessive exaggeration of contact'. The exaggeration is proven by the fact that he suffered no ill effects from the contact, was able to take his shot at goal, and didn't need to leave the field after the incident. I don't expect the MRP to have the balls to do anything about it though, even though it is clearly written into the rules.
My guess in the MRP 'lotto' is anywhere between 3-5 weeks for Scarlett.
And to all the Collingwood and Hawthorn supporters bleating on about SJ being a diver - whether or not it is true, it is irrelevant to the discussion of this incident. Take your whingeing to Bay 13.
- Dec 7, 2001
- 23,449
- 8,525
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Re: Scarlett reported for striking
Perceived staging or diving by the fans and media does not mean it acutally happened.
Slow mo replays are just that, not real time.
The Scarlett incident shows Pav and the other freo player who were there, immediately remonstrating and angry at Scarlett.
Perceived staging or diving by the fans and media does not mean it acutally happened.
Slow mo replays are just that, not real time.
The Scarlett incident shows Pav and the other freo player who were there, immediately remonstrating and angry at Scarlett.
Similar threads
- Poll
