Scott v Hinkley: Who would you rather?

[MCG-Unit]

Scott

 

[Power Raid]

sack hinkley

 

[Freomaniac]

aussierulesrules , bird_man , joop , projectv , The 747 , Gavin Excell and Kreuuuzeurns ,


My obsession of ken Hinkley is as bad as my obsession with Ross Lyon lol

 

[Osho]

For dinner? Ken
Over a beer? Ken
A romantic weekend in Frankston? Ken
At an intervention? Chris.

 

[Freomaniac]

This is like asking if you would rather get either kicked or punched in the balls.

Oh nice


Right on Tough man Tony Abbott budgie smugglers lol

 

[projectv]

aussierulesrules , bird_man , joop , projectv , The 747 , Gavin Excell and Kreuuuzeurns ,


My obsession of ken Hinkley is as bad as my obsession with Ross Lyon lol

 

[Shadow89]

Hinkley. To his credit, Hinkley has either developed or revamped numerous players within the club to become quality contributors. Wines, Houston, Amon, Bergman, Butters, Rozee, Duursma, Byrne-Jones, Marshall and Georgiadis are all contributing to a top 4 side having been developed internally.

Scott has nowhere near that track record.

Rightio.

...Blicavs
...C. Guthrie
...Duncan
...Close
...T. Stewart
...Miers
...Holmes
...J. Henry
...Ratugolea
...O'Connor
...Z. Guthrie
...Kolodjashnij
...Menegola
...S. De Koning
...Bews
...T. Atkins
...Parfitt


Nearly all are Premiership players, all drafted, and all had varying levels of success/development under Scott. Only two aren't Premiership players, and they may have been had they not been injured.

Pretty sure we can put this whole 'doesn't develop players' argument, to bed now.

 

[RUNVS]

I'd rather not date either of them if I were honest.

 

[NetworkNerd]

Rightio.

...Blicavs
...C. Guthrie
...Duncan
...Close
...T. Stewart
...Miers
...Holmes
...J. Henry
...Ratugolea
...O'Connor
...Z. Guthrie
...Kolodjashnij
...Menegola
...S. De Koning
...Bews
...T. Atkins
...Parfitt


Nearly all are Premiership players, all drafted, and all had varying levels of success/development under Scott. Only two aren't Premiership players, and they may have been had they not been injured.

Pretty sure we can put this whole 'doesn't develop players' argument, to bed now.

Bomber drafted Duncan... But your point is still correct!

 

[Taper]

View attachment 1714541

Need one of these for Freomaniac of Ken Hinkley.

 

[Taper]

aussierulesrules , bird_man , joop , projectv , The 747 , Gavin Excell and Kreuuuzeurns ,


My obsession of ken Hinkley is as bad as my obsession with Ross Lyon lol

Is there anyone who would still rather Hinkley over Scott?
Whateley is a huge Hinkley fan, and I highly doubt he'd rather Hinkley over Scott.

 

[Engimal v3]

Is there anyone who would still rather Hinkley over Scott?
Whateley is a huge Hinkley fan, and I highly doubt he'd rather Hinkley over Scott.

Hinkley is a tremendous coach. Port need to extend him so he can focus on winning them a flag.

 

[sobrave]

Hinkley is a tremendous coach. Port need to extend him so he can focus on winning them a flag.

Since clarko is cooked, I've heard Kenny wants to coach north. It'll be a shame to see him go but we do need to share him around.

 

[Papa G]

For dinner? Ken
Over a beer? Ken
A romantic weekend in Frankston? Ken
At an intervention? Chris.

Hinkley has the palate of an fussy 4 year old. Lives on cheese toasties.
Ken doesn't drink alcohol.
Romantic weekend? He looks like an old man's ball sack, if that's your thing.
Intervention? He 'd ust say Youse would have to work harder, for longer, that'd be it.

 

[Taper]

Hinkley v Brad Scott would be an interesting comparison.
Who would you rather?

 

[The Dougster]

Since clarko is cooked, I've heard Kenny wants to coach north. It'll be a shame to see him go but we do need to share him around.

There is no way that Ken deserves a step up after what he's done at Port

 

[NetworkNerd]

Hinkley

Has 2 coach of the year awards. Scott has none

 

[raskolnikov]

Hinkley v Brad Scott would be an interesting comparison.
Who would you rather?

Hinkley has underachieved with a great list.
Scott has overachieved with average lists at two clubs.

Brad easily. Port would have won at least one flag over the last ten years with him as coach.

 

[CharlieMortdecai]

Hinkley v Brad Scott would be an interesting comparison.
Who would you rather?

Didn't realise how old the thread is and assumed that was the comparison. Hinkley v dual premiership coach Scott? No contest

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Hard to split

both likely to be sacked by the end of next year

One won a flag the following year and the other has a great shot at doing so this year.

P.S. We haven't sacked a coach since John Devine in 1988.

 

[The Nostradamus]

^random bump but pop off queen

 

[catstorm]

Hinkley

Has 2 coach of the year awards. Scott has none

hmmm, right.

 

[NetworkNerd]

View attachment 2095106
View attachment 2095107

hmmm, right.

That's premiership coach. Not coach of the year.

Year	Winner	Club
2003	Paul Roos	Sydney
2004	Mark Williams	Port Adelaide
2005	Neil Craig	Adelaide
2006	John Worsfold	West Coast
2007	Mark Thompson	Geelong
2008	Mark Thompson (2)	Geelong
2009	Ross Lyon	St Kilda
2010	Mick Malthouse	Collingwood
2011	John Worsfold (2)	West Coast
2012	John Longmire	Sydney
2013	Ken Hinkley	Port Adelaide
2014	John Longmire (2)	Sydney
2015[9]	Luke Beveridge	Western Bulldogs
2016	Luke Beveridge (2)	Western Bulldogs
2017[10]	Damien Hardwick	Richmond
2018	Nathan Buckley	Collingwood
2019	Chris Fagan	Brisbane Lions
2020	Ken Hinkley (2)	Port Adelaide
2021	Simon Goodwin	Melbourne
2022[11]	Craig McRae	Collingwood
2023	Adam Kingsley[12]	Greater Western Sydney

 

[ClintEastwood]

That's premiership coach. Not coach of the year.

Year	Winner	Club
2003	Paul Roos	Sydney
2004	Mark Williams	Port Adelaide
2005	Neil Craig	Adelaide
2006	John Worsfold	West Coast
2007	Mark Thompson	Geelong
2008	Mark Thompson (2)	Geelong
2009	Ross Lyon	St Kilda
2010	Mick Malthouse	Collingwood
2011	John Worsfold (2)	West Coast
2012	John Longmire	Sydney
2013	Ken Hinkley	Port Adelaide
2014	John Longmire (2)	Sydney
2015[9]	Luke Beveridge	Western Bulldogs
2016	Luke Beveridge (2)	Western Bulldogs
2017[10]	Damien Hardwick	Richmond
2018	Nathan Buckley	Collingwood
2019	Chris Fagan	Brisbane Lions
2020	Ken Hinkley (2)	Port Adelaide
2021	Simon Goodwin	Melbourne
2022[11]	Craig McRae	Collingwood
2023	Adam Kingsley[12]	Greater Western Sydney

Coach of the year is an abitrary award. Premierships on the other hand ...

 

[Freomaniac]

Is there anyone who would still rather Hinkley over Scott?
Whateley is a huge Hinkley fan, and I highly doubt he'd rather Hinkley over Scott.

Which Scott Brother are we talking about?

Chris Scotts coaching stint at Geelong has pulled in 2 Flags, Possibly 3 if he can add one in 2024.

Brad scotts coaching stint at North Melbourne is mixed, But it depends on who you ask.

I liked Brad Scotts every final at North Melbourne. Made finals in 2012 and 2014, 2015, 2016.