SEASON 2018

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tangleswalker said:
Word is that the result has been overturned and the game ruled a draw retrospectively.
The joint is absolutely flying at the min.....
Click to expand...
Spoke to my mate from Healesville they said

2 goal umpires, time keeper and scoreboard all came to the same score Healesville winning by a point.

Apparently Monbulk believe mistake was made in the 3rd?

Absolsutely bizzare by the league to even investigate but then again those mupetts actions never suprise me
 
tigers99 said:
Spoke to my mate from Healesville they said

2 goal umpires, time keeper and scoreboard all came to the same score Healesville winning by a point.

Apparently Monbulk believe mistake was made in the 3rd?

Absolsutely bizzare by the league to even investigate but then again those mupetts actions never suprise me
Click to expand...

H'Ville have to pay 5k to appeal is the mail.

Surely once flags are waved that is it
 
toxic said:
H'Ville have to pay 5k to appeal is the mail.

Surely once flags are waved that is it
Click to expand...
Well that’s what I always thought. Opens up a can of worm. Are the league saying now any umpire mistake is up for investigation and they can overturn results?

How the hell was a mistake made by all 4 “score keepers” exactly the same. Something very fishy is going on.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

toxic said:
H'Ville have to pay 5k to appeal is the mail.

Surely once flags are waved that is it
Click to expand...

Actually, it used to be quite common for results to be overturned in the week after the match. For example, in 1934 Seville was given a 1 point win over Powelltown by the YVFA after protesting that a goal that had been disallowed by the goal umpire should have been included. It just hasn't happened recently because we're usually better organised these days. But if the video makes it clear that a mistake was made, then the league is obliged to correct the result.

They installed a fancy new electronic scoreboard at Monbulk a few weeks ago, didn't they? I don't remember any scoring controversies happening when Glen James was doing the job.
 
Derby103 said:
Actually, it used to be quite common for results to be overturned in the week after the match. For example, in 1934 Seville was given a 1 point win over Powelltown by the YVFA after protesting that a goal that had been disallowed by the goal umpire should have been included. It just hasn't happened recently because we're usually better organised these days. But if the video makes it clear that a mistake was made, then the league is obliged to correct the result.

They installed a fancy new electronic scoreboard at Monbulk a few weeks ago, didn't they? I don't remember any scoring controversies happening when Glen James was doing the job.
Click to expand...
Lol how do you know what happened in 32?

Regardless are you saying if a clear goal was callled incorrectly they should overturn results. What about in AFL when score reviews were deemed incorrect which the Afl has done on multiple occasions on a Monday.
 
Last edited:
This is yet another debacle. How on earth did no one happen to pick this up on the afternoon of the actual game. How many of these ridiculous situations continue to “pop up” under the current regime? Maybe instead of attempting Outer South East domination, which is on the nose anyway, maybe start getting the simple things directly under their nose right such as simple Maths.
 
Derby103 said:
Actually, it used to be quite common for results to be overturned in the week after the match. For example, in 1934 Seville was given a 1 point win over Powelltown by the YVFA after protesting that a goal that had been disallowed by the goal umpire should have been included. It just hasn't happened recently because we're usually better organised these days. But if the video makes it clear that a mistake was made, then the league is obliged to correct the result.

They installed a fancy new electronic scoreboard at Monbulk a few weeks ago, didn't they? I don't remember any scoring controversies happening when Glen James was doing the job.
Click to expand...

How can you say it should be overturned?
Players played the entire last qtr believing the scoreboard.
The notion of overturning the result is absurd imo
 
toxic said:
How can you say it should be overturned?
Players played the entire last qtr believing the scoreboard.
The notion of overturning the result is absurd imo
Click to expand...

So not one single person was able to bring it to any match day official that something may be amiss with the score on the actual day of the game? And why did both goal umpires scorecards add up to the exact same margin on the day resulting in a tie? Must have been some sort of epiphany on Sunday when one of the Monbulkians telepathically recalled something was not right with the score and decided to then sit through the entire game on Valley Vision, abacus in hand counting each score. Seriously all this episode is missing is the Benny Hill music.
 
Tangleswalker said:
So not one single person was able to bring it to any match day official that something may be amiss with the score on the actual day of the game? And why did both goal umpires scorecards add up to the exact same margin on the day resulting in a tie? Must have been some sort of epiphany on Sunday when one of the Monbulkians telepathically recalled something was not right with the score and decided to then sit through the entire game on Valley Vision, abacus in hand counting each score. Seriously all this episode is missing is the Benny Hill music.
Click to expand...

No, Both goal umpires, scoreboard and time keeper scorer all came to a win to Healesville by 1 point..

Not a single official source came to any different score. So basically 4 different people all at seperate areas made exactly the same
Mistake according to the league.

The mistake was made in the 3rd apparently but apparently no protest at the quarter break. clearly no one noticed until days later some how.

Something very strange happening here.
 
tigers99 said:
No, Both goal umpires, scoreboard and time keeper scorer all came to a win to Healesville by 1 point..

Not a single official source came to any different score. So basically 4 different people all at seperate areas made exactly the same
Mistake according to the league.

The mistake was made in the 3rd apparently but apparently no protest at the quarter break. clearly no one noticed until days later some how.

Something very strange happening here.
Click to expand...

Strange...

Lets just call it bullsh1t

It's far easier
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

mon will not play heals next year and I'm discussed about that. Neither will win the flag this year so don't bother arguing
 
HeavyHitter said:
LOL at Powelltown appointing Mario Bandera as head coach.
They obviously don't have google at their club otherwise they would of known his past.
Bloke is a psychopath. I promise and I mean promise he will be sacked before the last round
Click to expand...

LOL. Dunno what Powelltown were doing. Should have contacted ANYONE from the NFNL
10571z said:
Wow some clubs are insane. 1 phone call to virtually anyone from the northern football league! Just 1 phone call.

Enjoy Powelltown.
Click to expand...
 
In other news after the power brokers down at league HQ reversed the H’ville M’bulk game result to a draw the appeal lodged by H’ville has been upheld and the 1 point victory now stands. You couldn’t make this stuff up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

N
  • Sticky
SEASON 2025
2 3
Replies
57
Views
7K
josha93
J
M
SEASON 2024
71 72 73 74 75
Replies
2K
Views
184K
MortlockWatcher
MortlockWatcher

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top