Should Port Adelaide, Bulldogs, MFC and Stk be allowed Top Up players

[Elite Crow]

sorry i missed the Kangaroos win, so what 3/9 in the premiership season! All i said was that in the Brisbane and Carlton games the Crows also struggled, if we were switched on and we won that Carlton game we would of finished 8th in a terrible season. The Crows list is lacking the top end midfield talent that Port has (Boak, Gray, Wingard, Wines, Hartlett, Polec).

Thats what I said, your midfield is better on the back of being shit mind you. Only Gray and Polec were not from your top 10 picks.

 

[wayb2912]

Ok so Robbie Gray pick 55, Westhoff pick 70, Ebert traded for pick 28, Polec+Impey for pick 13, Schulz traded for pick 71, Hombsch + Neade for pick 29. I think our recruiters have done alright. Maybe if you guys didn't cheat in the Tippett deal you would of had 2 extra 1st rounders on your list. You also traded a 1st rounder for Richard Tambling and 2 1st rounders for Brad Crouch so stop whinging that you don't have 1st round talent


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[AlbertonBloke]

Perhaps but the same could be said about Wada.

You are lucky the whole club didn't get banned

 

[Elite Crow]

Ok so Robbie Gray pick 55, Westhoff pick 70, Ebert traded for pick 28, Polec+Impey for pick 13, Schulz traded for pick 71, Hombsch + Neade for pick 29. I think our recruiters have done alright. Maybe if you guys didn't cheat in the Tippett deal you would of had 2 extra 1st rounders on your list. You also traded a 1st rounder for Richard Tambling and 2 1st rounders for Brad Crouch so stop whinging that you don't have 1st round talent


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I was talking about your midfielders and imagine if you didn't waste top ten picks on Moore and Butcher.

You are not very good with your facts are you? We gave up pick 10 and a pick which ended up being in the 20s for Crouch and Brown.

The pick we ended up giving away for Tambling was in the 20s as well.

I haven't whinged about our lack of first Rd picks, all I've said is our recruiters have done well without them and your club should be way ahead for all the low picks you've received for being shit.

If you are going to retort get your facts right, you are wasting my time.

 

[Defacto]

Wow this thread really has turned into a port vs Adelaide shit fight

 

[Kram]

The AFL made the obvious and correct decision, time to move on.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

The AFL made the obvious and correct decision, time to move on.

It ceased being a thread about the top up issue quite a ways back