Media Sterge Tonight presents: The Top 7 Rookies S23 (extended) edition

[miggs]

It's in the Mobbs Medal thread.

Every rookie that posted got a vote.

Except miggs.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

why did hoops get perma banned and I tried to find a thread for the EKA medal for season 22 but failed doing so

BigJoeD_ banned him for not joining the Royals

 

[NaturalDisaster]

It's ok, I'm sure if you didn't play for the spam rats, Mellty still wouldn't have given you a vote

 

[miggs]

It's ok, I'm sure if you didn't play for the spam rats, Mellty still wouldn't have given you a vote

Didn't fit his agenda. So wouldn't even have been considered.

 

[Sterge]

It's ok, I'm sure if you didn't play for the spam rats, Mellty still wouldn't have given you a vote

Mellty gave dodgy votes to try and get his horse over the line lets not forget that.

 

[Kennedy Parker]

S16
S18
S20
S21
S19
S17

Too early to call on 22 and 23

 

[NaturalDisaster]

S16
S18
S20
S21
S19
S17

Too early to call on 22 and 23

I'm making a call that the season 24 lot will be the best.

No reason, just a random prediction

 

[Blacky]

BigJoeD_ banned him for not joining the Royals

Grizzly Adams did have a beard

 

[BRAB]

Mellty gave dodgy votes to try and get his horse over the line lets not forget that.

Utter bullshit.

 

[nahnah]

I just had a look it seems like burningdwarf and miggs did get robbed of a few votes, a couple ahead of them I've never seen before

 

[Blacky]

S16
S22
S18
S20
S21
S19
S17
S23

Not too early at all

 

[nahnah]

oh and BRAB

 

[NaturalDisaster]

oh and BRAB

lol

 

[BRAB]

What rookie season was Blacky in?

We have objective proof that that season was the best.

 

[miggs]

Utter bullshit.

Come on mate

 

[Kennedy Parker]

Not too early at all

I don't think the S22 class will look as strong as it is now in a season's time. Even now they've only got 1 A-grader arguably 2.

S23 could be anything.

 

[BRAB]

Come on mate

You're one of the only rookies that can't be upset by Millky95's votes

 

[Blacky]

View attachment 359655

What rookie season was Blacky in?

We have objective proof that that season was the best.

I was such a bad rookie that you could slot me into this season seamlessly

 

[NaturalDisaster]

I don't think the S22 class will look as strong as it is now in a season's time. Even now they've only got 1 A-grader arguably 2.

S23 could be anything.

Youre a B+ grader cloudy

 

[Blacky]

I don't think the S22 class will look as strong as it is now in a season's time. Even now they've only got 1 A-grader arguably 2.

S23 could be anything.

I kind of get that argument, but there are about 6 who I think will be multi All SFA

 

[Kennedy Parker]

Youre a B+ grader cloudy

Not bad for someone who's in his 4th season and close to the end.

 

[Blaze Storm]

Iirc Last year had a real top notch 7 or 8 then fell away massively after the top 7 in my countdown plus hoooops was about all there was (i remember struggling to fill the 7), imo this year is more balanced and bats a lot deeper lots of quality this season without many real standouts.

Not meant to offend anyone just my opinion as an expert rookie watcher

That's OK, I'm an expert at not being exceptional. Some might say I'm the most exceptionally unexceptional person ever.

Except they wouldn't.

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

That's OK, I'm an expert at not being exceptional. Some might say I'm the most exceptionally unexceptional person ever.

Except they wouldn't.

What was that about turn of phrase and the murder of the English language old chum?

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

Off the top of my head and I'm probably wrong there was

tgrs Far Kern BRAB Bet on Blue burningdwarf Oddhawk Hooooops miggs plus more I reckon

That's a very handy top 8

Brab is rubbish and hoooops has been permabanned.

Would add naturaldisaster in instead of brab if i was doing the thread now

Thatsapaddlin also.

Ko_Ko got an EKA vote as well.

Yep, likely bunch.

 

[Blaze Storm]

What was that about turn of phrase and the murder of the English language old chum?

Let me put it in a way that you, the ellucidator of much and naught amiss might thenceforth phrase such a comment reflexively that one, upon so digesting the manifest importance and subsequently, upon closer inspection, transposing the meaning in such a way that it becomes ordinant, would at full consequence grasp the direct inferences contained therein.