Supercoach 2009 - Discussions

[jonoman89]

Is it too risky starting yarran and gumbleton in the forwards ?

Though it gives me 5 elite backs 3 elite mids and 3 elite forwards

Or is it safer to go yarran and dale thomas with 4 elite and a david myers/raines sorta defender ? 2 elite and kerr'ish/bateman'ish/boak'ish kinda mid ?

I have Yarran as a starting 22 rookie, he is a bit risky so i'll be watching him NAB cup. Gumbleton will definitely get game time (Knights has said he will play Neagle and Gumby at the same time as Lloyd and Lucas), and will be extremely useful on the bench.

Together? I wouldn't. Young players' scores fluctuate too much.

P.S. i'd much rather have more elites in the midfield than other positions, seeing as their scores are the most reliable. The midfield will always get the ball, other positions wont.

 

[Itsblackandwhite]

I have Yarran as a starting 22 rookie, he is a bit risky so i'll be watching him NAB cup. Gumbleton will definitely get game time (Knights has said he will play Neagle and Gumby at the same time as Lloyd and Lucas), and will be extremely useful on the bench.

Together? I wouldn't. Young players' scores fluctuate too much.

P.S. i'd much rather have more elites in the midfield than other positions, seeing as their scores are the most reliable. The midfield will always get the ball, other positions wont.

Touche

Cheers buddy - the midfield should be looked at all over again

 

[kreuze control]

haha just realised carlton's total value is the highest in the game!

and anyone know why waters didnt play tonight?

 

[Souup]

haha just realised carlton's total value is the highest in the game!

and anyone know why waters didnt play tonight?

Elbow injury

 

[kreuze control]

Elbow injury

should i trade him for nicoski?

 

[dazy]

ey guys
wat did u guys think about pendlebury 123 sc points do u think he will be a worthy selection im thinking about taking judd out for pendlebury to free up the salary a bit but scared if it would make my midfeild to week only then haveing kerr vanberlo hasleby coughlan and rich. just a couple of opinions thanks guy.

 

[Athomas]

I wouldn't take Judd out, but Pendlebury could be good again this year.

Oh and don't get Nicoski whoever said that... or Waters.

 

[Biggie]

should i trade him for nicoski?

Not yet.

But he showed some good signs tonight.

 

[Lace Out]

Anyone been having trouble logging in to play the last few days or is it just me?

 

[rocklovelive]

Just you.

 

[Carlton Kid]

just you

 

[Carlton Kid]

Just traded Boak out for Griffen after doing some research.

 

[dazy]

Just traded Boak out for Griffen after doing some research.

wat did tyhe research tell you. if u would like to share it with us

 

[harro37]

cousins $465,500 is that a bit too pricey

 

[pie chucker]

What do you think of Ben Johnson? Priced at $378k but is capable of stacking up some big numbers like a few years ago.