-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Swans Board Official Trade Ideas Thread Part II
- Thread starter robbieando
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Re: Bucannon traded to brisbane
No source yet other than what was on Sunrise. Someone on the Brisbane board said SEN were running with it as well.
Edit: Apparently we lost Pick 22 and gained Pick 28 in the deal.
No source yet other than what was on Sunrise. Someone on the Brisbane board said SEN were running with it as well.
Edit: Apparently we lost Pick 22 and gained Pick 28 in the deal.
Re: Bucannon traded to brisbane
If they can push through a "reasonable" early deal to secure Seaby...then Swans are in a good position to negotiate hard ball for Jolly!
If they can push through a "reasonable" early deal to secure Seaby...then Swans are in a good position to negotiate hard ball for Jolly!
With Hawks Campbell retiring...means they have to get a decent ruckman if they are going to be any chance! Forget Burgoyne
There have been too many "decent" posters with foreknowledge...for Hawks not to be in this ...Jolly move ... up to their eye balls!
There have been too many "decent" posters with foreknowledge...for Hawks not to be in this ...Jolly move ... up to their eye balls!
- Banned
- #857
Dude... why? it seems like that is an auto response from you? Plz essplain?
I don't know.
Me...OK.If I were Hawks seeing how valuable Jolly was this year... he is an excellent ~50m shot at goal!
9+Kennedy!
- Banned
- #859
Huh?Dude... why? it seems like that is an auto response from you? Plz essplain?
I don't know.
Me...OK.If I were Hawks seeing how valuable Jolly was this year... he is an excellent ~50m shot at goal!
9+Kennedy!
Seems like the obvious question.
If you're keen for Hawks to get involved in a Jolly trade, surely you have an idea of what you'd like in return.
Re: Bucannon traded to brisbane
West Coast did very well to extract our 2nd rounder. Sure we got a good deal for Bucky but i would of just ontraded 28 for Seaby. I guess with the Jolly development, it sort of forced our hand.
West Coast did very well to extract our 2nd rounder. Sure we got a good deal for Bucky but i would of just ontraded 28 for Seaby. I guess with the Jolly development, it sort of forced our hand.
Nah contrary to popular belief
... I don't entirely run SSFC!I trust Roos ,Stewie & team...they have proven time and time again they are really good at trading and drafting!
But Collingwood need something in ruck division too!
vonn
Bigfooty Legend
10k Posts
Pokemon is Life
Meet-Up Master
Pantskyle
Podcaster
WCE Wings Guernsey
Casey Tutungi Future Fund
- Sep 29, 2008
- 20,495
- 12,341
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Re: Bucannon traded to brisbane
That's what I thort Jeffers but then I realized we will be compensated for with jolly, and hopefully the kid the pies give us is worth a second rounder.
That's what I thort Jeffers but then I realized we will be compensated for with jolly, and hopefully the kid the pies give us is worth a second rounder.
- Banned
- #863
Presumably this doesn't stop you having a view on possible trades.Nah contrary to popular belief
I trust Roos ,Stewie & team...they have proven time and time again they are really good at trading and drafting!
I defer to Liz and many other posters here!
Fair dinkum I would crack the nanna!
Sydney I am proud to say are not cheap and trade fair!.. even seemingly to disadvantage... but they get who they want!
Re: Bucannon traded to brisbane
I have a theory....
Minor placings mean little... Swans tend to find/target someone prepared to move outside a "footy" state!
Woo them!!!!.... like only the great "Malfunction" can
They (paleyer) show less interest (they don't batt eyelids) at others in return for "we will definitely pick you!"
Crazy I know
I have a theory....
Minor placings mean little... Swans tend to find/target someone prepared to move outside a "footy" state!
Woo them!!!!.... like only the great "Malfunction" can
They (paleyer) show less interest (they don't batt eyelids) at others in return for "we will definitely pick you!"
Crazy I know
Re: Bucannon traded to brisbane
I actually think a bit differently re the timing.
As soon as we've signed off on a deal for Seaby, we're signalling that we're resigned to trading Jolly. Our strongest card with Jolly is that we don't need to trade him. Unless the Hawks enter the fray for Jolly, it will essentially be a choice of trading him to Collingwood or keeping him. If they know that keeping him is really on the cards, they might actually cough up a semi-decent player - ie not Ryan Cook!
If they can push through a "reasonable" early deal to secure Seaby...then Swans are in a good position to negotiate hard ball for Jolly!
I actually think a bit differently re the timing.
As soon as we've signed off on a deal for Seaby, we're signalling that we're resigned to trading Jolly. Our strongest card with Jolly is that we don't need to trade him. Unless the Hawks enter the fray for Jolly, it will essentially be a choice of trading him to Collingwood or keeping him. If they know that keeping him is really on the cards, they might actually cough up a semi-decent player - ie not Ryan Cook!
TheMase
Brownlow Medallist
I would think the club would be far more open to a second round downgrade (28 - 22) if we believe we will get value out of Jolly.
Trade week looking pretty good for us thus far.
Trade week looking pretty good for us thus far.
- Banned
- #870
Paul Roos was just on SEN, saying the Swans will try to trade Jolly back to Melbourne, but Jolly understands that he's contracted for two years, and that the Swans would need a significant improvement on pick 15, which is what they gave up to get him. Roos was adamant pick 14 would not get it done.
doona
SMFC
Re: Bucannon traded to brisbane
We don't need to trade him. He still has 2 years of his contract left.
From what I understand Paul Roos said that he will try and get a deal through, but like O'Keefe if no on eis willing to pay the price he wont be traded.
We are already resigned to loosing Jolly, IF THE DEAL I RIGHT
We don't need to trade him. He still has 2 years of his contract left.
From what I understand Paul Roos said that he will try and get a deal through, but like O'Keefe if no on eis willing to pay the price he wont be traded.
We are already resigned to loosing Jolly, IF THE DEAL I RIGHT
- Banned
- #873
I seem to think that Hawthorn are in prime position to nab Jolly at this stage.
That is fair. We got him when he was a no name for pick 15 and turned him into one of hte best ruckmen in the league, we should be well compensated for him, better than what we gave awy to get him anyway.
As has been said, either:
Pick 9 plus Kennedy from the Hawks (if they start up negotiations with us, unlikely considering the Pies have apparently been talking with Jols for a few weeks and they are wanting Burgoyne)
or
Pick 14 plus Dawes or Nathan Brown (Brown sounds very unlikely)
As has been said, either:
Pick 9 plus Kennedy from the Hawks (if they start up negotiations with us, unlikely considering the Pies have apparently been talking with Jols for a few weeks and they are wanting Burgoyne)
or
Pick 14 plus Dawes or Nathan Brown (Brown sounds very unlikely)
- Status
