The 2013 'Which Player Should I Start On The Field?' Thread (TWPSISOTFT)

[VSTone]

^ gotta wonder if gibbs hammy from earlier in the season is playing up, his DT sluttiness has been shite the last couple of weeks...

Staker v Power or Terlich V Roos?

 

[Pinochio]

^ gotta wonder if gibbs hammy from earlier in the season is playing up, his DT sluttiness has been shite the last couple of weeks...

Staker v Power or Terlich V Roos?

stakers scores are hard to ignore

good point on gibbsy....grimes is prob gonna get the gig...

 

[Crawb]

think i may play nicholls and bench big coxy...seems kinda wrong when looking at my team :/


what about gibbs or grimes???.....gibbs needs a stint on the pine to think about what he has done over the last 3 weeks!!!

Grimes is not your D7 surely....

 

[Scrotes2000]

Hopefully Cox does a bit better with NicNat out. I'm playing him in my forwards atm with Leuey and Nicholls in the ruck.

 

[Pinochio]

Grimes is not your D7 surely....

he is man

after i went terlich to grimes...grimes is now my D7 (good or bad thing lolz)

who to play you reckon mate?

 

[Iskender Time]

he is man

after i went terlich to grimes...grimes is now my D7 (good or bad thing lolz)

who to play you reckon mate?

I'd be going with Gibbs if Robbo is back in. It is being said that this will take him away from recent non DT friendly tagging roles.


Assuming all will be named, which one should I field out of Robbinson, Franklin and Macaffer?

 

[JDWCE]

I'd be going with Gibbs if Robbo is back in. It is being said that this will take him away from recent non DT friendly tagging roles.


Assuming all will be named, which one should I field out of Robbinson, Franklin and Macaffer?

Franklin easily has the biggest upside, but hasn't shown anything this season.

I'd go Robbo as he plays the Suns.

Franklin will probably be up against Carlisle at this stage, unless he goes to Roughy.

Although Macaf against GWS could be a go-er.

Tough calls.



Who should I play out of Cotchin, Stanton or T Mitchell.

Other alternative is to trade either Stanton or Cotchin to Beams and just play him. Money is no issue

 

[btemplar88]

cotchin or Sam Mitchell on the field. have a feeling cotchin is not going to have a good week and Mitchell will come out firing after his last 2 sht weeks

 

[Spider Klein]

cotchin or Sam Mitchell on the field. have a feeling cotchin is not going to have a good week and Mitchell will come out firing after his last 2 sht weeks

Cotchin on fire the last couple and neiter really has a favourable draw so I play Cotch.


Who to bench,
Cox (thinking might be better DT wise without Nic Nat)
Franklin (Maybe after 2 weeks off he will come out firing)
Nicholls (recent runs on the board.)

Would usually bench Buddy but that leaves no Ruc Emergency because Cox plays forward. leaving Cox/Nichols as ruck emergency I still have Staker forward emergency.

 

[kaisasosai]

Cotchin on fire the last couple and neiter really has a favourable draw so I play Cotch.


Who to bench,
Cox (thinking might be better DT wise without Nic Nat)
Franklin (Maybe after 2 weeks off he will come out firing)
Nicholls (recent runs on the board.)

Would usually bench Buddy but that leaves no Ruc Emergency because Cox plays forward. leaving Cox/Nichols as ruck emergency I still have Staker forward emergency.

I'd definitely bench Cox. Looks to be struggling....but with out NN playing he may see more of the ball? Looked pretty average last week though.

 

[RBW_007]

Staker vs Nicholls?

 

[toptigers]

Am also looking at Cox, Nicholls or Franklin.

Thinking I will bench Franklin, no doubt it will come back to hurt me.

 

[LanLion]

Cotchin on fire the last couple and neiter really has a favourable draw so I play Cotch.


Who to bench,
Cox (thinking might be better DT wise without Nic Nat)
Franklin (Maybe after 2 weeks off he will come out firing)
Nicholls (recent runs on the board.)

Would usually bench Buddy but that leaves no Ruc Emergency because Cox plays forward. leaving Cox/Nichols as ruck emergency I still have Staker forward emergency.

Bench Buddy. If it was another premo, you'd be like "he's gotta prove himself". Nicholls has done well against the other big ruckman in the comp, so why not against Kreuzer? Dixon is back but I'd say his ruck time is gonna be very limited.

Staker vs Nicholls?

Tough one. I'm edging towards Nicholls myself just, cos Staker could be anywhere from 40 to 90 (also a goal dependent 90), whereas I'd say Nicholls is a guaranteed min 70.

 

[LanLion]

Start Jaegermeister or Titchell?

 

[jbiddy89]

It's my Fantasy Elite GF and I am looking for who to play in my FWD line.... (need 5)

Have Bird, Gray, Sylvia, L.Hansen, Gia, Dwyer

 

[kierez4ever]

Am also looking at Cox, Nicholls or Franklin.

Thinking I will bench Franklin, no doubt it will come back to hurt me.

nah dont worry, his past form hasnt justifed being played on the field

Staker vs Nicholls?

yeh Nicholls, he's more consistent

Start Jaegermeister or Titchell?

Jager, Tichell has been playing in the FWD line a lot in past 2-3 weeks

It's my Fantasy Elite GF and I am looking for who to play in my FWD line.... (need 5)

Have Bird, Gray, Sylvia, L.Hansen, Gia, Dwyer

would bench Dwyer, Gia+Hansen scorin 90 odd in the past month, the rest are proven guns with Bird having a quite one last week



Who should I play on field: Hartlett or Hibberd?

 

[LanLion]

Who should I play on field: Hartlett or Hibberd?

Tough one. Both going alright again after big dips in form. I'd pick Hibberd, just cos Hartlett screwed me over this year.... Reckon Hibberd will pick up for such a big game.

 

[tryonthis]

Who should I play on the field between Roughead and T. Nicholls?

My fear is that Roughie only scores well when he kicks 3-5 goals in a given match.

 

[kierez4ever]

Who should I play on the field between Roughead and T. Nicholls?

My fear is that Roughie only scores well when he kicks 3-5 goals in a given match.

gotta back your premiums; realistically at worst roughead will score 75+

 

[Willo #6]

My fear is that Roughie only scores well when he kicks 3-5 goals in a given match.

I don't really get when people say this. The guy is (this year) our best goalkicker and one of the best in the comp. He should get 3 goals a game.

 

[OneEyedHawk]

I really want to get Boomer onto my field, as I reckon he may go big vs Dees. Who should i play him in front of?...I was initially thinking Westhoff, but he's at home vs Brisbane and loves it at home.
B: Goddard, Heppell, Hartless, Ibbotson, Gibbs, Terlich (Clisby & Thurlow)
M: Ablett, Swan, Griffen, Pendles, A.Swallow, S.Mitchell, Stevie J., TMitch (KMart & Cokehoon)
R: Z. Clarke, Nicholls (Currie & McBean)
F: Cox, Martin, Rockliff, Cloke, J. Kennedy, Westhoff (B.Harvey & Paparone)

 

[Crawb]

I really want to get Boomer onto my field, as I reckon he may go big vs Dees. Who should i play him in front of?...I was initially thinking Westhoff, but he's at home vs Brisbane and loves it at home.
B: Goddard, Heppell, Hartless, Ibbotson, Gibbs, Terlich (Clisby & Thurlow)
M: Ablett, Swan, Griffen, Pendles, A.Swallow, S.Mitchell, Stevie J., TMitch (KMart & Cokehoon)
R: Z. Clarke, Nicholls (Currie & McBean)
F: Cox, Martin, Rockliff, Cloke, J. Kennedy, Westhoff (B.Harvey & Paparone)

West-what? You should be starting Harvey over Westhoff every week! Why is Westhoff still in your team. Should have got rid of him like everyone else did 3 months ago!

 

[OneEyedHawk]

West-what? You should be starting Harvey over Westhoff every week! Why is Westhoff still in your team. Should have got rid of him like everyone else did 3 months ago!

True. His sucky-ness has kinda levelled out a bit since that mid-season slump, but yeah, he's still shit. Have reversed my trades and re-jigged the team...so which 1 do I bench out of:

Cox (vs Dogs at Etihad)
Westhoff (vs Brisbane at home)
Buddy (vs Ess)

 

[kierez4ever]

True. His sucky-ness has kinda levelled out a bit since that mid-season slump, but yeah, he's still shit. Have reversed my trades and re-jigged the team...so which 1 do I bench out of:

Cox (vs Dogs at Etihad)
Westhoff (vs Brisbane at home)
Buddy (vs Ess)

nah the hoff is still a good pick, 85 average in past 5 games, defs bench buddy DEFS

 

[OneEyedHawk]

nah the hoff is still a good pick, 85 average in past 5 games, defs bench buddy DEFS

thanks mate, i took your advice.