Review The Grand Final Disaster of 2017.

Remove this Banner Ad

So is the premiership drought ladder:
1. Melbourne
2. St Kilda
3. Fremantle/Carlton
5. Us
6. North Melbourne
7. Essendon
8. Brisbane
9. Port
10. West Coast
11. Collingwood/Gold Coast
13. Geelong/GWS
15. Sydney
16. Hawthorn
17. Bulldogs
18. Richmond

??

Ouch
 
Yep,,,best team won,,,,the boys weren't right between the ears today,,and needed on field leadership,,,where that stems from i have no idea,,because at the moment ,,Tex sure aint up to it..Sloane certainly didn't fly the flag,,Dougy,,,Lynch ,,and a few of the other senior players showed nothing,,,,so where do head ..???... I thought M.Crouch + all all of our back line tried their guts out ,,filthy on Jelly Bean Jenkins ( the most over paid,,under performing bloke in our team ( he had a few mates today )..They had their chance at the big dance and listened to the crowd instead of the music...All in all..the boys gave us a lot of joy this year,,,,Thanks for that,,and lets hope we take a bit from it .... 2018...here we come
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Was on the Crows bandwagon today and it brought back memories of 2014. The best team of the season doesn't always win the flag unfortunately.

It'll sting for a long time, but the Crows were still the best side this year. You'll be in the mix again next year. Don't be too hard on yourselves.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Does anyone think that the AFL will ever be even a remotely fair competition? I struggle to think it ever will be. Way too much Victorian bias!
Nope. And they like it that way. We'll always be the invaders to their VFL.

While half the teams know that regardless of how putrid they've been for years, if they make a grand final they get instant home ground advantage, and the other half know that if they make it, they're travelling, it'll never be fair.

Be like having the Cricket World Cup final in India every single time regardless of where the group stages are.
 
Does anyone think that the AFL will ever be even a remotely fair competition? I struggle to think it ever will be. Way too much Victorian bias!
Yep I agree bloody 100% such rigged bull**** biased umpires all a Victorians keeping their own arses nice and clean no room for anyone else even when most of the vic teams are complete ****
 
We overrate Tex. Sorry.
I don't.

He's serviceable. He's a leader. Other players jump on board when he does something and so do the fans.

Unfortunately he's no better than serviceable. Unfortunately he is limited in his leadership by how much he can impact a game. He only has 1 effort at each contest, and he's lucky if he even makes it to the contest. That's why McGovern was so badly missed today, for all those high flying balls that were bombed in early.

Tex isn't the player he looked like being before doing his knee. But he is serviceable. 50 goals a yr for the last 3 yrs or so is serviceable in a forward line that has multiple options. No better, no worse.
 
It shows just how good that Sydney side of 2012 was to win a GF at their opponents home ground.

You have to be a 5 goal better side to begin with and THEN have things go your way
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Teams that have been spanked in grand finals over the last 20 years - are these the heaviest defeats in that time? Not too many rebounded back to win one soon after.
Sydney 1996
Carlton 1999
Melbourne 2000
Collingwood 2002
Brisbane 2004
Port 2007
Fremantle 2013 or 14... whenever it was
West Coast 2015

And playing groups that lose one before they win one generally don't bounce back either.

Combine the two and you're probably in trouble.

I feel like we only had one bite at the cherry here.
 
Yep I agree bloody 100% such rigged bull**** biased umpires all a Victorians keeping their own arses nice and clean no room for anyone else even when most of the vic teams are complete ****
What annoys me about all this is how much money people that live in SA has just made Victoria. We all know how much Victorians think they are better thank SA and we have just contributed to that.
 
On the plus side "the killers"'were probably the best grand final choice the afl have gone with in a long time?

Lol. That's the only positive I got. That and I thought people would finally see how badly hartigan performs under pressure. But apparently no one cares that he turns it over for goals straight back over his head and it's all Jenkins fault.
 
Teams that have been spanked in grand finals over the last 20 years - are these the heaviest defeats in that time? Not too many rebounded back to win one soon after.
Sydney 1996
Carlton 1999
Melbourne 2000
Collingwood 2002
Brisbane 2004
Port 2007
Fremantle 2013 or 14... whenever it was
West Coast 2015
ok, we were never in it but under 6 goals is hardly a spankin - is it?
 
No surprise that when the real heat is on and we need players to stand up the same ones turn to mush. Mackay, Atkins, Jenkins, Seedsman, Cameron, Lynch. Otten on Rance was useless. Our delivery into the forward line was predominantly to Richmond’s favour.
Eddie took no leadership today. He had to be selfish and take ownership and kick the goals instead of trying to give off.

Richmond did what they have to all the other teams they have played in the finals. We were out coached, out worked and the Richmond bandwagoners and Victorian media lapped it up. Richmond played the better, but to dish that shite up on the big stage shows we have a long way to go and players need to be shown the door or play their contracts out in the sanfl. Our wings and half forwards today were shizenhousen and should never play for the best 22 again. With smith out for a whole season that just makes it even more hard to bear.

I’m gutted. Not only for the loss, but for the amount of shit we will receive from the 18whatever flogs. Had to put up with one who I invited into my home and stirred the shit all day long. Too all my willpower not to punch his lights out. Having to listen to all the vic media flogs go on about it is going to be bearable only because I won’t be watching or reading anything to do with this match ever again.

Club has to play hardball at the trade table. Get some players with some mental fortitude and trade out all those who don’t or don’t want to be here next year.

Just gutted.
 
Rance is a disgusting defender, let me be the first to call out his grappling and worse yet his incessant tunnelling! He runs forwards under the ball and the umpires don't call anything. His mate Astbury has also jumped on board.

If the AFL wants to save keyforwards, contested marks and big men then they have to intervene with some holistic rule changes. They're becoming irrelevant and defenders are allowed to climb them like ladders.

Richmond the clear better team today but the umpires did you no favours. Worst grand final I've seen in a while.

Could you explain what tunnelling is?
 
I'd like to say the pain of a bad GF loss goes away, but I am still annoyed with our 2015 performance. And that is not even factoring the small fortune I spent travelling to game from Perth (and taking my mum with me).

If WCE aren't there this time next year, I hope you guys get another chance with a different result.
 
Richmond didn't allow us to freewheel and attack the goal mouth.

Dusty won the medal but it was Houli and Rance who them the Premiership.

Their ability to.take away our forward space is what won them that game.

No umpire conspiracies from me. They had a plan to beat us and implemented it.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Review The Grand Final Disaster of 2017.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top