The League's most over-rated player?

[Swanny36]

jeez it would have to be Buddy Franklin wouldnt it??...
nah just just kidding the most over rated player in the league at this point in time would have to be Darren Glass he is having a shocker of a year...normally brilliant but having a shocker this year...
but for the over rated player over there career so far it would have to be Jared Brennan(bris) has done nothing..

 

[Bay Pie]

Even better figures, wow pie supporters wot do you say?

Enjoy the next 5-6 years once Lloyd,Lucas, Michael & Fletcher retire.

 

[HBF]

Dale Thomas.

 

[stevedarui]

Grant Birchall

 

[buddythegreat]

i dont think brennan is a rated player hence he cant be overated really,he is only discussed becuasee he's a number 3 pick

 

[buddythegreat]

can some explain how carlton ever rate ackland high enough to offer 3 years geez

 

[senrulzisback]

Grant Birchall

WHAT?
Are you alright?
Grant Birchall?
Who eveR overrated him?
If he is anything than he is underrated!

 

[buddythegreat]

senrulzisback i think someone is baiting hawks fans birchall is clearly the pick on 2005 draft his disposal outstanding excellent decision making,pace and strenth,bet the pies wish they picked him

 

[stevedarui]

He is a fantastic receiver

 

[senrulzisback]

senrulzisback i think someone is baiting hawks fans birchall is clearly the pick on 2005 draft his disposal outstanding excellent decision making,pace and strenth,bet the pies wish they picked him

Absolutely right!
I love his long kicks

 

[Furn]

The hawthorn football club.

1 semi final in 7 years!! 7 straight wins this year... so what?? have they played geelong, adelaide or the doggies?? enough is enough they are awesome but anyone would think theyd won 5 flags!!!

geelong


daylight


hawthorn, doggies


st kilda without injuries and tough bodies = 10 flags

unfortunetly we are weak as dogs (*&^%$

yep beat Adelaide by 45 points

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

Not that I think this guy can't play ... he can .. and very well. However, he has been elevated to a level far above that to which he deserves.

There is a mania surrounding a guy who really has had only 2 very good seasons ... Judd.

Comments such as "As only Judd can do" really annoys me. Most midfielders can do what he can .. some even better.

 

[senrulzisback]

The hawthorn football club.

1 semi final in 7 years!! 7 straight wins this year... so what?? have they played geelong, adelaide or the doggies?? enough is enough they are awesome but anyone would think theyd won 5 flags!!!

geelong


daylight


hawthorn, doggies


st kilda without injuries and tough bodies = 10 flags

unfortunetly we are weak as dogs (*&^%$

1. Yes we beat Adelaide
2. Doggies have had the easiest run out of the top 3
3. Just wait for round 17
4. 10 flags my ass the saints are the ones that are overrated.

 

[GeneralDisarray]

Jarrad Waite... daylight... umm yeah, Jarrad Waite and no one comes close.

 

[kingcarey18]

Nick Dal Santo.

thank god someone finally said him he is the most over-rated player in the competition hes the softest guy in the afl


and daniel wells is over rated aswell has the ability thats what hes rated on just doesnt produce it

 

[buddythegreat]

tambling has lacked any sought of credability since arriving under leather faces arm,yes the talented aboriginal who hawthorn should have picked the headline goes in 2004 but really hes a soft as nathan brown,he has the heart of a pea yet when the support from guys like tambling who has a few years left on contract the vfl seems a much better option

 

[Beckers]

Grant Birchall

you do???? As most footy fans outside of Hawthorn wouldn't even know who he was, could you please explain how he is over rated??

 

[pacman]

Josh Fraser
Jeff Farmer
Campbell Brown
Shane Crawford
Kozi
Matthew Scarlett
Darren Glass
Marc Murphy
most of the collingwood and hawthorn list

Need some lemon,lime and bitter

 

[deano the hawka]

Stupid person for thinking Matthew Scarlett is overrated.

I think that many Essendon players are overrated, because of what my close mates say about some players. One of my mates said that Essendon have the fastest team in the AFL, and the list included Jason Winderlich, Mal Michael or Dustin Fletcher (forgot) and Lloydy and more (can't remember at the moment).

For now i say that Winderlich is most overrated

 

[Simon_Nesbit]

Saying that Dream-team selection = being rated....

Bock = OVERRATED. His ineptitude contributed or directly responsible for four of the first five goals.

Fraser - try looking at the ball in the rucksometimes.....

Judd - Yeah I know he's not fit, but doesn't look like it atm. Then they say he's one of "the best two players in the competition" (with Brown).

Under-rated: Franklin & Fevola - both taking on and beating two players with regularity.

 

[HighettBomber]

senrulzisback i think someone is baiting hawks fans birchall is clearly the pick on 2005 draft his disposal outstanding excellent decision making,pace and strenth,bet the pies wish they picked him

Birchall is not over-rated generally, probably under-rated, he's a fantastic player. But you definately over-rate him, saying he is clearly the pick of the 2005 is just plain BS.

 

[DarwinRoo]

I'm going to have to pull one out from left field and say that Shannon Watt is over-rated, because his skills and decision making have been a liability to the Kangas for years, yet he's still in the team every week. If he could improve his skills and decision making he would be a handy player, but when he makes the same errors week in week out you have got to wonder!

How can a bloke who is probably not rated by 99% of the football world be over rated?

North supporters dont talk him up as a superstar and no one in the media rates him much either.

 

[Silvagnis]

Jarrad Waite... daylight... umm yeah, Jarrad Waite and no one comes close.

He was playing on Pavlich who is a superstar tonight, but he still pantsed that hack Rocca.

A shame Waite doesn't own a handbrake like Pendlebury who pulled and let Franklin take an uncontested chest mark when he could have got to it.

The softest "rising star" in the AFL refused to go.

 

[Spudregus_87]

1. Kosi
2. Chris Tarrant
3. Cam Mooney
4. Anthonty Rocca
5. Russel Robertson
6. Luke Ball
7. Josh Fraser
8. Jarred Brennan
9. Brian Lake (Harris)
10. Stephen Milne

 

[davefromjerra]

1. Kosi
2. Chris Tarrant
3. Cam Mooney
4. Anthonty Rocca
5. Russel Robertson
6. Luke Ball
7. Josh Fraser
8. Jarred Brennan
9. Brian Lake (Harris)
10. Stephen Milne

Milne kicked 7 goals against your side last week. He might be annoying but he goes all right.