The obscure XI's you've always wanted to make but never found the appropriate place thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Jim Maxwell's 50 Year XI
*Gilly
Sangakkara
V Richards
Lara
Tendulkar
Ponting
Ben Stokes
Warne
Lillee
Thommo
Warne
Kallis (12th)

Thanks, Gough.

I think you meant to include McGrath at number 11, rather than repeat Warne.

An interesting selection for various reasons. I wouldn't have Thommo in the top 25 bowlers I have seen, let alone as one of the three specialist fast bowlers in the side. The selection of JR Thomson gave Maxwell his cue to re-tell the tedious Lillian Thomson bit.

How no West Indian quicks from the 1980s or 1990s made it, particularly Marshall, is beyond me.

Gilchrist was a fine opener in ODIs, but it's questionable whether he would perform consistently in this position in a fictional Test match on top of his workload as a 'keeper.

Maxwell originally selected Sobers, but then remembered he had never called a Test match in which Sobers was playing. Which led to 'The Voice of Summer' shoe-horning Ponting as the number 6 (yes, I remember Ponting playing his early Tests at 6 before he was dropped a few times and later starred as a number 3).

There is no clear-cut choice as captain. Maxwell opted for Richards and, to his credit, admitted that Richards was an ordinary tactician and implied that the Windies of the mid-to-late-1980s were so imposing that the captain's role was merely incidental.
 
Former Brisbane Heat players currently contracted with other BBL clubs:

Joe Burns
Matt Renshaw
Chris Lynn (C)
Alex Ross
Ben McDermott (wk)
Sam Heazlett
James Bazley
Cameron Gannon
Mark Steketee
Paddy Dooley
Billy Stanlake

A surprisingly well-balanced team!
Renshaw is back at the Heat.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

An Australian Test XII made up of players whose place of birth includes the name of another Australian Test player.


Cameron Bancroft (Attadale)
Rob Quiney (Brighton)
Kurtis Patterson (Hurstville)
Peter Handscomb (Box Hill)
Callum Ferguson (North Adelaide)
Mitchell Marsh (Attadale)
Alex Carey (Loxton)
Trent Copeland (Bathurst)
Jhye Richardson (Murdoch)
Peter George (Woodville)
Nathan Lyon (Young)

Jon Holland (Sandringham)
 
An Australian Test XII made up of players whose place of birth includes the name of another Australian Test player.


Cameron Bancroft (Attadale)
Rob Quiney (Brighton)
Kurtis Patterson (Hurstville)
Peter Handscomb (Box Hill)
Callum Ferguson (North Adelaide)
Mitchell Marsh (Attadale)
Alex Carey (Loxton)
Trent Copeland (Bathurst)
Jhye Richardson (Murdoch)
Peter George (Woodville)
Nathan Lyon (Young)

Jon Holland (Sandringham)


Bravo (like how I used the name of two Test players to give you kudos there???)

This is an outstanding effort
 
An Australian XI who appear in famous photographs


Victor Trumper (1905)

photo1.PNG

Rick McCosker (1977)

photo2.PNG

Don Bradman (1948)

photo3.PNG

Steve Waugh (2001)

photo4.PNG

Glenn Maxwell (2023)

photo5.PNG

Trevor Chappell (1981)

photo6.PNG

Alex Carey (2023)

photo7.PNG

Shane Warne (1997)

photo8.PNG

Merv Hughes (1989)

photo9.PNG

Jeff Thomson (1975)

photo10.PNG

Rodney Hogg (1984)

photo11.PNG

12th man: Colin Miller (2001)

photo12.PNG
 
Last edited:
Took some research, a strong all-rounder flavour to this one (positions 6-8 cover strong middle order batting and more than handy pace attack).
  1. Roy Fredericks
  2. Majid Khan
  3. Viv Richards
  4. Kevin Pietersen
  5. Mohammed Azharuddin
  6. Chris Cairns
  7. Ian Botham
  8. Wasim Akram
  9. Ray Lindwall
  10. Denis Lindsay (wk)*
  11. Daniel Vettori*
 
Last edited:
The 'England caps are worthless' Test XI

Jason Roy
Tom Westley
+James Bracey
Sam Billings
Will Jacks
Liam Livingstone
Tom Curran
Jamie Overton
Matt Parkinson
Matthew Fisher
Jake Ball
 
You left out a few......................

Barry Wood
Tim Curtis
John Stephenson
Mark Lathwell
Graham Barlow
Kim Barnett
+Sam Billings
Paul Jarvis
Allan Igglesden
John Price
Mason Crane

PS - I had Jake Ball, but since you had already mentioned him I looked for someone else.

It wasn't hard.
I went for recent caps who are still playing but would get nowhere near a test XI now.


We had a habit of giving caps at the end of lost ashes dead rubbers to hopeless cases who were given an innings or two to bowl poorly then discarded and treated like it never happened. Mason Crane, Simon Kerrigan, Boyd Rankin, Scott Borthwick.

Adam Lyth got close but he scored a test century. Pattinson was harshly treated I think.

Can do a similar one from my childhood, when the talent pool was far thinner. Most were crap but Steve James probably deserved a longer run.

Ian Ward
Steve James
Ed Smith
Usman Afzaal
Darren Maddy
Aftab Habib
Gavin Hamilton
+Warren Hegg
Mike (A M) Smith
Min Patel
Jimmy Ormond
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The true allrounders XI

Brendon McCullum
Abraham de Villiers
Vijay Manjrekar
Clyde Walcott
Javed Miandad
Derek Sealy
Robert Christiani
Mark Boucher
+Syed Kirmani
Mahmudullah
John Richard Reid

Boucher could easily be the WK in this side
 
The true allrounders XI

Brendon McCullum
Abraham de Villiers
Vijay Manjrekar
Clyde Walcott
Javed Miandad
Derek Sealy
Robert Christiani
Mark Boucher
+Syed Kirmani
Mahmudullah
John Richard Reid

Boucher could easily be the WK in this side
Matthew Wade?
 
Matthew Wade?
Doesn't quite qualify unfortunately.

Only 17 people do. The others are:
Jim Parks (Eng)
Dick Lilley (Eng)
Tatenda Taibu (Zim)
Aamer Malik (Pak)
Clifford McWatt (WI)
Taslim Arif (Pak)

Javed and Taslim both qualified in Border's two 150s match
 
The "dismissed by Jimmy Anderson 10 or more times in test cricket" XI

Graeme Smith (17)
Sachin Tendulkar (14)
Ricky Ponting (12)
Virat Kohli (25)
Jaques Kallis (15)
A B Devilliers (15)
MS Dhoni (19)
Pat Cummins (12)
Mitchell Johnson (17)
Nathan Lyon (22)
Jasprit Bumrah (13)

12th: Kane Williamson (13)
 
Very gettable XI given recent occurrences

L Hutton
A Sandham
W R Hammond
P B H May
H C Brook
*B A Stokes
K S Ranjitsinhji
+H Wood
S C J Broad
W W Read
J M Anderson
 
Took some research, a strong all-rounder flavour to this one (positions 6-8 cover strong middle order batting and more than handy pace attack).
  1. Roy Fredericks
  2. Majid Khan
  3. Viv Richards
  4. Kevin Pietersen
  5. Mohammed Azharuddin
  6. Chris Cairns
  7. Ian Botham
  8. Wasim Akram
  9. Ray Lindwall
  10. Denis Lindsay (wk)*
  11. Daniel Vettori*

EDIT: I forgot to add the criteria

Answer: Players who made a century off less than 100 balls. The first 9 all did it from that spot in the order as well.
 
EDIT: I forgot to add the criteria

Answer: Players who made a century off less than 100 balls. The first 9 all did it from that spot in the order as well.
Thought we had to do them as puzzles and other people would try and get the answer. I didn’t get anywhere with guessing yours by the way.
 
Hmm. Highest score for England in each position in the order?
Bingo. Bit light in the spin department though.
The true allrounders XI

Brendon McCullum
Abraham de Villiers
Vijay Manjrekar
Clyde Walcott
Javed Miandad
Derek Sealy
Robert Christiani
Mark Boucher
+Syed Kirmani
Mahmudullah
John Richard Reid

Boucher could easily be the WK in this side
And this one was 11 Test players who had at least one run, one wicket, one catch and one stumping, if anyone was left wondering

That list is the same for one wicket and one stumping as well.
 
Bingo. Bit light in the spin department though.

And this one was 11 Test players who had at least one run, one wicket, one catch and one stumping, if anyone was left wondering

That list is the same for one wicket and one stumping as well.

Outstanding. Here's another:

1. John Edrich
2. Viv Richards
3. Walter Hammond
4. Bert Sutcliffe
5. Ted Dexter
6. Sam Loxton
7. Ian Botham
8. Denis Lindsay (wk)
9. Imran Khan
10. Wasim Akram
11. Michael Holding
 
Outstanding. Here's another:

1. John Edrich
2. Viv Richards
3. Walter Hammond
4. Bert Sutcliffe
5. Ted Dexter
6. Sam Loxton
7. Ian Botham
8. Denis Lindsay (wk)
9. Imran Khan
10. Wasim Akram
11. Michael Holding
Something about hitting boundaries/sixes?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

The obscure XI's you've always wanted to make but never found the appropriate place thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top