The official "X v Y" thread

[DeadlyAkkuret]

If you must pick Gartlett, lose Walker. (Just my opinion)

Cousins V Chad Cornes V Ling V Foley V Kerr

 

[munk3ymark]

If you must pick Gartlett, lose Walker. (Just my opinion)

Cousins V Chad Cornes V Ling V Foley V Kerr

That's where I was heading. Chornes from that lot, followed by Foley- Chornes is a proven gun, and Foley's on the way up to becoming gun. Ling's certainly a unique pick, but I don't know that he'll get any better than the 80-90 ppg he's had in the past, and the other two are wait and see for me.

I may be a little too careful in my thinking about Cuz and Kerr, and hope if they do start to go nuts I'm smart enough to jump on board!

 

[Lotch]

If you must pick Gartlett, lose Walker. (Just my opinion)

Cousins V Chad Cornes V Ling V Foley V Kerr

Cornes

 

[Mick_15]

Mackie vs Adcock is backline

Or

Hasleby vs Adcock vs Tuck in the midfield


Last minute decisions

Adcock and Tuck

If you must pick Gartlett, lose Walker. (Just my opinion)

Cousins V Chad Cornes V Ling V Foley V Kerr

Cornes, Kerr, Cuz, Foley, Ling is my order for that one.


Didak vs Roughed is my dilema.

 

[Lotch]

Mackie vs Adcock is backline

Or

Hasleby vs Adcock vs Tuck in the midfield


Last minute decisions

Anyone got an idea? I think Hasleby will go up in value but have average scores. Adcock could be an idea for a mid spot. But many are going with Tuck

Or could just have adcock in backline instead of mackie like others have got.

At just over 400,000 will Adcock's price/scores increase

 

[a1118374]

DILLEMMAS

drummond + s johnson vs deliedio + x ellis
is the main one

2nd ziebell vs rich vs otten or should i try find money to go ziebell forward and keep otten rich robinson midfield

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Anyone got an idea? I think Hasleby will go up in value but have average scores. Adcock could be an idea for a mid spot. But many are going with Tuck

Or could just have adcock in backline instead of mackie like others have got.

At just over 400,000 will Adcock's price/scores increase

Mackie & Adcock

I'm expecting Adcock to have a really good year, so if his value doesn't go up a little I'd be suprised.

I upgraded and now I have a choice between Ball and J. Selwood instead of Cornes, Foley, Kerr etc.

So, Ball V J. Selwood

 

[Spartan]

boomer vs pav vs buddy

pick 1.

 

[Mick_15]

boomer vs pav vs buddy

pick 1.

Boomer, will be there all year, another captain choice.


Didak v Roughed?

 

[Lotch]

boomer vs pav vs buddy

pick 1.

Boomer

Simply because he is captain, mid named in forward line. And buddy could easily have a quiet week(s) and be cheaper.

Pav I thought would already be in most teams.

 

[Biggie]

Rich v Anthony for a starting position.

Geary v Henderson?

 

[Lotch]

Boomer, will be there all year, another captain choice.


Didak v Roughed?

Roughed because Buddy is apparently playing more up the ground this year

So he (Roughy) will be more of a focal point for Hawthorn, less likely to get double teamed and because I'm not sure about Didak.

Buddy will still kick heaps of goals though.

 

[Lotch]

Rich v Anthony for a starting position.

Geary v Henderson?

I think most will pick Rich but Anthony could be prolific.

Not sure about either of those players.. probably geary

 

[marcmurphy3]

WHich 3 out of Anthony, Beams and Robinson?

 

[Spartan]

Boomer, will be there all year, another captain choice.


Didak v Roughed?

I like it Rough.

Rich v Anthony for a starting position.

Geary v Henderson?

Geary will score more.

Henderson is safer.

 

[munk3ymark]

WHich 3 out of Anthony, Beams and Robinson?

Anthony will probably give you higher scores, but may not keep his (supposed) spot after this week- at least you know Robinson is starting tonight. Still like Beams as well though, but not so sure when/if he'll start.

 

[Parasite]

WHich 3 out of Anthony, Beams and Robinson?

Out of those three, I'd go Beams, Anthony and Robinson, but not necessarily in that order

 

[Judd_Magic]

Last piece of the puzzle -


Houlihan, Otten, (Anthony, Robinson) <-- Bench

VS

Frawley/Henderson/Geary (not sure who), Rich (Otten, Anthony) <--Bench


Cheers.

 

[Toadvine]

Sorry wrong thread

 

[The Voice of Sport]

Sorry wrong thread

Nice Post!!

Skipworth v Krakouer?

 

[DeadlyAkkuret]

So, um, Ball or Selwood?

 

[Biggie]

So, um, Ball or Selwood?

Selwood.

Ball might get injured throwing himself at the contests. If he could notch 22 games he could be a great unique pick.

Joel looking to have a big year

 

[Roos4eva]

Enright and Foley or Heath Shaw and Joel Selwood?

I really want Foley in my team, but Selwood is Selwood.

 

[UpTheGuts]

Rich v Anthony for a starting position.

Geary v Henderson?

henderson. He can kick. Outside of drummond, few others in the lions backline can

 

[Hot Tiges]

Selwood. Ball always seems to be injured. But a unique pick.

My last one. Enright VS Newman VS Gilbee VS Pratt. Concerned too much over Goddard.