None of those players really look any good.
Who is best value out of:
Cross, S. Burgoyne, Dal Santo, Thompson?
-
LIVE: Sydney v Brisbane Lions - 2:30PM AEST Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 61% chance -- What's your tip? -- Ticketing Buy, Sell -- Teams on Thurs »
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Grand Final
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round PF Winner: Still Me
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
The official "X v Y" thread
- Thread starter Ben the Gooner
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Who is best value out of:
Cross, S. Burgoyne, Dal Santo, Thompson?
Ablett & Malceski v Selwood & Gilbee.
Option 1 gives me a captain option week in, week out but option 2 gives me an extra keeper- if Malceski doesnt get back to his 07 form. Thoughts?
Option 1 gives me a captain option week in, week out but option 2 gives me an extra keeper- if Malceski doesnt get back to his 07 form. Thoughts?
trix17
Team Captain
Boomer (fwd) + Dal Santo + Skipworth (fwd)
OR
N.Niewoldt + Hayes + Henstchel.
for some reason i really like the idea of having hayes, i dont think many people will have him and i reckon he is a consistent gun, so if i go 1st option i still might choose hayes.
but thats ooff topic, advice on my predicament would be helpfull
OR
N.Niewoldt + Hayes + Henstchel.
for some reason i really like the idea of having hayes, i dont think many people will have him and i reckon he is a consistent gun, so if i go 1st option i still might choose hayes.
but thats ooff topic, advice on my predicament would be helpfull
The_Kid_23
Rookie
Very tough one!
Roo v Harvey - Id go Harvey to start just because or Roo's delayed preseason
Dal v Hayes - Id go Hayes, just prefer him, think he will do better
Skip v Hen - Id go Skip given his preseason to date
So on majority id go option 1, HOWEVER i think Roo will come good after a few rounds and has the ability to post some monster scores when he does
My question..
Boomer and Didak or Pav and Gia?
Roo v Harvey - Id go Harvey to start just because or Roo's delayed preseason
Dal v Hayes - Id go Hayes, just prefer him, think he will do better
Skip v Hen - Id go Skip given his preseason to date
So on majority id go option 1, HOWEVER i think Roo will come good after a few rounds and has the ability to post some monster scores when he does
My question..
Boomer and Didak or Pav and Gia?
Hmm, tough one. Possibly the second one.. just!Pav is super consistent and Gia like-wise, flys under the radar a bit.
My Dilemma.. Bartel, Newman, J White + 20k VS T Tuck, Bock and Hille + 22k?? I see J White as the 2nd ruck for Syd as Pyke is still learning and Currie not mentioned? I'd accept the 40-50 average if I can get more from Newman and Bartel vs Tuck and Bock choy.
Boak vs. Hasleby (+100k)
Hasleby is a risk with injury and lack of match fitness. However, he has the potential to rise, proving he can be a 100+ performer over a season.
Boak is set to break out IMO, all class. Port should bounce back this year, and that should help his scores, averaged 85 last year, pretty consistent but doesn't get the big ones.
Can't quite get the cash together for Foley though.
Hasleby is a risk with injury and lack of match fitness. However, he has the potential to rise, proving he can be a 100+ performer over a season.
Boak is set to break out IMO, all class. Port should bounce back this year, and that should help his scores, averaged 85 last year, pretty consistent but doesn't get the big ones.
Can't quite get the cash together for Foley though.
Ablett & Malceski v Selwood & Gilbee.
Option 1 gives me a captain option week in, week out but option 2 gives me an extra keeper- if Malceski doesnt get back to his 07 form. Thoughts?
Option 1 gives me a captain option week in, week out but option 2 gives me an extra keeper- if Malceski doesnt get back to his 07 form. Thoughts?
Jimbo_Jones
Rookie
M.Richo, B.Harvey, L.Franklin, S.Goodwin
or
M.Richo, J.Bartel, J.Brown, N.Del Santo
or
M.Richo, J.Bartel, S.Goodwin, N.Del Santo
Your thoughts???
or
M.Richo, J.Bartel, J.Brown, N.Del Santo
or
M.Richo, J.Bartel, S.Goodwin, N.Del Santo
Your thoughts???
eugene_tomas
Team Captain
the 2nd one clearly i rekon
gilbee or gibbs
davenport/swift or suban/petrenko
gilbee or gibbs
davenport/swift or suban/petrenko
Don't know why your picking between a back and a mid, but gilbee for the consistency.
Suban and Petrenko would seem more likely of regular game time. I like Davenport, but PA have a dozen players on the fringe of selection it would seem.
For me NDS, Pendlebury or Ball? At this point I'm leaning towards Ball as the word is he is fit and raring to go, and Pendlebury is likely to come in for a hard tag this year.
I'd go Option 1, Reason being, Expect gilbee to be tagged this year to stop his run from defence.
M.Richo, J.Bartel, J.Brown, N.Del SantoM.Richo, B.Harvey, L.Franklin, S.Goodwin
or
M.Richo, J.Bartel, J.Brown, N.Del Santo
or
M.Richo, J.Bartel, S.Goodwin, N.Del Santo
I don't think goodwin will keep his form from last year, An this combo looks the best out of the 4.
Ablett/Brown. I;m prediciting Reiwoldt will drop heavily in price, while ablett is a keeper you need from the start
Judd expect a huge year form him
Judd over NDS (Judd is proven champion... NDS amy struggle again)
Tuck over Masten (Masten may struggle in a struggling team)
My conundrum is:
Lucas(5th fwd)/Kreuzer(2nd ruck)/Houlihan(5th back)/$18,200 bank
VS
NKrakouer/Leuenberger/PBurgoyne/$111,800
Could use extra cash to upgrade a Mid????
Tuck over Masten (Masten may struggle in a struggling team)
My conundrum is:
Lucas(5th fwd)/Kreuzer(2nd ruck)/Houlihan(5th back)/$18,200 bank
VS
NKrakouer/Leuenberger/PBurgoyne/$111,800
Could use extra cash to upgrade a Mid????
- Status
