The Player A Vs Player B SUPERMEGATHREAD!!

[popathon]

Mcleod vs Birchall?

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

Mcleod vs Birchall?

Birchall. Will dominate this year i reckon.

Cross vs Hayes?

Didak vs Murphy?

Shammer vs Prismall vs Sherman?

The answers to these questions will decide my team once and for all!!

 

[samwise]

Still need opinions on Gram Vs Waters

waters comfortably in my opinion

 

[samwise]

think i should upgrade goodes for stanton/priddis for about 30-40k?
or possibly downgrade him for salopek or someone else?

 

[Jack Mack]

G'Day all, I'm new around the forums, been reading for a few months.

i'm also new to Super Coach so I have created my on league, maybe get to know some of y'all a little better.
(plus pc won't let me join other leagues)

Super Coach Pup or Pro ..come and have a go

Code: 987334

All the best and good luck
Jack

Just 2 days to go!

 

[thewhippersnapper]

Birchall. Will dominate this year i reckon.

Cross vs Hayes?

Didak vs Murphy?

Schammer vs Prismall vs Sherman?

The answers to these questions will decide my team once and for all!!

That's my opinion anyway. Can't split Cross, Hayes and even Stanton. They are all pretty much the same price and they'll all average about the same (95-100).

 

[Hirdy!!]

Chad Cornes and Warren Tredrea

or

Peter Burgoyne and Robert Murphy?

 

[hinrich-gun]

kennelly or mattner?

 

[JuddyisGod]

Chad Cornes and Warren Tredrea

or

Peter Burgoyne and Robert Murphy?

Cornes and Tredrea


Didak or Rob Murphy or Fevola?

 

[Hirdy!!]

Pavlich and Tredrea

or

Lucas and Cloke

 

[hinrich-gun]

tough one ^^^ prob fev.. didak isnt any special and murphy coming off a knee reco or 2

mattner or kennelly

s.higgins or sherman

 

[samwise]

That's my opinion anyway. Can't split Cross, Hayes and even Stanton. They are all pretty much the same price and they'll all average about the same (95-100).

cross will be more consistent than lenny, however lenny has the ability to score much higher than cross. lenny can get tagged and do poor but could potentially have an amazing year this year and average around 110 but could also get injured. new medical staff meant to be good this year though.

as a saints fan i go cross just because i dont like getting stkilda players as i just think they will get injured and are not the only stars in the team and will therefore go up and down sometimes such as dal santo, hayes, gram etc.

 

[JuddyisGod]

tough one ^^^ prob fev.. didak isnt any special and murphy coming off a knee reco or 2

mattner or kennelly

s.higgins or sherman

Kennelly

can't split the other two

 

[hinrich-gun]

thanx.. another one

mattner or petterd or wilson or surjan or symes or c.brown
and
higgins or sherman

ONE OF THEM

 

[geelong16]

Didak or Rob Murphy or Fevola?

rob murphy for consistentcy, fevola for the odd sensational game, didak for nothing. Overall go murphy

I need help, Travis cloke or Shannon Grant or Corey Jones or Aaron Davey or Cameron Mooney? I have 340k left and one more player to buy in my forward line. I already have Deledio, Murphy, Thomas, Burton, Porplyzia and Monfries i just dont know where to chuck the last 340k to, help would be greatly appreciated

 

[JuddyisGod]

thanx.. another one

mattner or petterd or wilson or surjan or symes
and
higgins or sherman

ONE OF THEM

Symes or Mattner - probably Symes just

 

[hinrich-gun]

higgins or sherman

ling or eagleton

will symes get much game time at adelaide?

 

[geelong16]

higgins or sherman

ling or eagleton

will symes get much game time at adelaide?

Sherman could possibly be sensational this year, runner up in brisi best and fairest in 06 had a shocker last year due to injuries holding him back. Higgins im guessing will rise this year to play every match but because of the strength in the bulldogs midfield i dont know how much ball he will see there, he may take a hafl forward/pocket position. I would go Sherman, Brisbanes midfield is one of the weaker ones and if Sherman has managed to get his fitness back to the level he was at in 06 i would guess he would play in the midfield for bris this year so go sherman

 

[hinrich-gun]

ok. thanx

and will symes get muchgame time?

ling or eagleton?

 

[thewhippersnapper]

Sherman could possibly be sensational this year, runner up in brisi best and fairest in 06 had a shocker last year due to injuries holding him back. Higgins im guessing will rise this year to play every match but because of the strength in the bulldogs midfield i dont know how much ball he will see there, he may take a hafl forward/pocket position. I would go Sherman, Brisbanes midfield is one of the weaker ones and if Sherman has managed to get his fitness back to the level he was at in 06 i would guess he would play in the midfield for bris this year so go sherman

I think I get dumber reading some of the posts on this board. Brisbane's midfield one of the weaker ones?

Lappin, Black, Johnstone, Adcock, Power.........

 

[Hirdy!!]

Pavlich and Tredrea

or

Lucas and Rob Murphy

 

[powaflag08]

Mcintosh, Priddis, C.Morton, Krezuer (ruck bench)

or

Wood, Swan, Houli, Luenberger (ruck bench)

or

Hille, Johnstone, Houli, Krezuer (ruck bench)?

 

[LemmingMaster]

I think I get dumber reading some of the posts on this board. Brisbane's midfield one of the weaker ones?

Lappin, Black, Johnstone, Adcock, Power.........

There is not much strength in that Midfield



Couglan v Griffen v Schammer ?

 

[Hirdy!!]

Matthew Pavlich and Albert Proud

or

Scott Lucas and Ed Barlow

 

[powaflag08]

There is not much strength in that Midfield



Couglan v Griffen v Schammer ?

Coughlan.

Can you answer mine?