The Player A Vs Player B SUPERMEGATHREAD!!

[Kentacula]

yeaaapp ellis 4 me to

and do people think heath shaw is actually going to have a good season or will he play more man marking type style with clement gone ...

People are backing H Shaw for a huge season. Will rise to maybe 400-420k imo.

 

[Just_ace]

OK

A) Judd vs B) Goodes
A) daniel Cross vs B) nigal lapin
A) giansiracusa vs B) nathan brown
A) gram vs B) waite
A) delidio vs B) akermanis


I think............................
B
A
A
A
A

what r ur opinions

 

[Kentacula]

Peter Burgoyne OR Andrew Mcleod OR Darren Milburn?

Hmm, Milburn or McLeod, probably Milburn.

 

[Kentacula]

OK

A) Judd vs B) Goodes
A) daniel Cross vs B) nigal lapin
A) giansiracusa vs B) nathan brown
A) gram vs B) waite
A) delidio vs B) akermanis


I think............................
B
A
A
A
A


what r ur opinions

B
A
A
B
B (only value wise)

 

[blues4flag]

Hmm, Milburn or McLeod, probably Milburn.

Yeah - never had Milburn in my DT before as a matter of principle. Though I guess DT goes before my personal thoughts on a player.

 

[Kentacula]

Embley or Salopeka

 

[Just_ace]

Embley or Salopeka

embly, i rate daniel pearce b4 salopek

 

[Kentacula]

embly, i rate daniel pearce b4 salopek

Theres too many Eaglers on this forum. Thanks anyways.

 

[the hairy cat mooney]

o'keefe vs gia vs lucas

and

mcphee vs H.shaw

 

[kingyubbo]

Lucas and Shaw

Bazza Hall V Deledio

 

[boris danes]

Bench depth is concerning me, not sure how much of a concern it really is though...

A) Cox + BENCH: Anthony/S.Selwood + Ebert + Tippett

B) McIntosh + BENCH: Hartlett/McNamara/J Hill

- Option B are all second yr+ players meaning more experience, more playing time initially etc., though not having Cox means unless Simmonds comes on strong, a trade for Cox is necessary

- Option A means I have a proven 100+ ruck all season, if Simmonds rucks well no real need for an upgrade as have the best in the business, though bench positions are dicier and less likely to play considerable game time

Any suggestions... really choosing from these guys only

 

[boris danes]

o'keefe vs gia vs lucas

and

mcphee vs H.shaw

Definately Lucas and Shaw.. Gia coming off an injury, Okeefe consistenly avg for his price, Lucas has the ability to go 130..60..130 etc but i feel is the best option of the three.

 

[flackjack]

Yeah - never had Milburn in my DT before as a matter of principle. Though I guess DT goes before my personal thoughts on a player.

Yup, it was quite a hard hit on SOS. Anyways he averages ~85 and doesn't miss too many. You get what you pay for with Milburn.

 

[Mordecai]

Do I start Milburn and Wood
or
BJones and Simmonds?

 

[rossi]

Yup, it was quite a hard hit on SOS. Anyways he averages ~85 and doesn't miss too many. You get what you pay for with Milburn.

I've had milburn every year since about 05 and he's always been consisitent

Can anyone help me with Waters and Bradshaw (or equivalent priced player) vs Newman and Symes... also what do people think about how Waters will perform when compared directly to Newman

 

[chronorox]

Who would be a better option for Cam Mooney at 336k?

Cloke? Deledio?

Help would be greatly appreciated

 

[Mello Man]

Hey guys just interested in what you would think is a better option here?

J.Gram
A.Didak
N.Foley

Or

J.Bowden
B.Houli
A.Schneider

 

[cammiss05]

I have $240k to spend on a midfielder:

Ricky Dyson (Shown some great signs pre-season should play all 22 games hopefully)

Byron Schammer (should get a bit more gametime in the middle but is not a great DTer possible he can manage 65+?)

Bachar Houli (not sure if he has CEMENTED his spot but had a stellar pre-season, but still not sold on him as much as the others)

Mark Couglan (too risky?)

Thanks

 

[Ray Ball]

Josh Drummond, Brendon Goddard or Birchell?

F&%k backs are hard to pick!

 

[Ray Ball]

Hey guys just interested in what you would think is a better option here?

J.Gram
A.Didak
N.Foley

Or

J.Bowden
B.Houli
A.Schneider

first one in my opinion.

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

Prismall and Leuenberger

or

Houli and Wood?

 

[Waite_30]

Jake Edwards vs. Gamble?

Edwards might not play much after Fisher returns. I don't know much about Gamble, but all i know is that he plays for the leagues best side, and might not get many games. Thoughts?

BTW, this is a reserves question.

 

[banana_bus]

Alan Didak vs Dale Thomas?

Obviously Thomas has the greater long term up side, but at almost 50k less, and being a seasoned player, Didak looks ok.

Both look to be getting a rotation through the middle.

 

[dont bowl there]

Alan Didak vs Dale Thomas?

Obviously Thomas has the greater long term up side, but at almost 50k less, and being a seasoned player, Didak looks ok.

Both look to be getting a rotation through the middle.

I would go Dale Thomas...only because I have him at the moment.

Question: Dale Thomas or Travis Cloke? Thinking Cloke will have more big games.

 

[jack_lord]

Nicoski vs Hurn?