The Player A Vs Player B SUPERMEGATHREAD!!

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Re: Martin Mattner or Shannon Hurn - or somebody cheaper?

Why do so many people think Ellis is going to be so good this year?

Same back too you. Why do so many people think Ellis is going to be bad this year?

 

[Jeremias]

2 choices

Am unsure what to do, so thought I would pose the question here.

What would you prefer out of the following:

1. Brett Deledio and Dane Swan

OR

2. Luke Hodge and Scott Lucas

Keep in mind that Hodge is suspended for round 1. My midfield reserves are Harry Taylor and Rhys Palmer so I will have to rely on one of them for a score whilst Hodge is out.

Which would you prefer, and why?

 

[sante]

Re: 2 choices

Use the proper thread....

 

[magpies77]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

I've gone with Bernie Vince, Nathan Thompsons best is behind him and unsure of Bradshaw.

dyson vs houli??

 

[Athomas]

Re: Martin Mattner or Shannon Hurn - or somebody cheaper?

Same back too you. Why do so many people think Ellis is going to be bad this year?

Because he was never that good last year.

 

[Virgil]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

Very difficult decision,, I think I'd go with Dyson, he seems the safer option.

I'd say Hayes and Deledio. Hayes is back to his 06 form and Deledio will have a far more consistent year than Frankie.

Combos:

Nathan Thompson VS Bernie Vince VS Daniel Bradshaw.

For me I'd go with Thommo because I'm not entirely sure that Vince is a 22 game player just yet, could be in and out like Douglas was last year, which would be pretty frustrating, but I agree that Vince will probably average more.

I think you're spot on with Hayes and Deledio as well.

 

[Jeremias]

Re: 2 choices

Use the proper thread....

Whoops - didn't see that thread. Will post in there now.

Sorry

 

[Jeremias]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

Deledio and Swan

vs

Hodge and Lucas (Hodge will miss round 1 so will need to relyon either Palmer or Taylor to fill in as a centre for 1 round)

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Re: Martin Mattner or Shannon Hurn - or somebody cheaper?

Because he was never that good last year.

He is young but will have inconsistant scores and you cant find much better at his price..

 

[KouDogg]

Re: Martin Mattner or Shannon Hurn - or somebody cheaper?

IMO Ellis will develope quite alot this year. He may move into the midfield so he could rack up quite a bit of the footy. He is excelent for his price and not much comes close to him (at that price), Hurn is probably the only other option however he is 19 grand more than him and may not be as consistant as Ellis.

 

[sante]

Re: Martin Mattner or Shannon Hurn - or somebody cheaper?

Ellis will struggle to get into the middle with Mitchell, Sewell, Lewis, Hodge, Crawford etc.

 

[jack_lord]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

J Drummond OR A McLeod (McLeod will save money to be spent elsewhere)

McPhee OR P Burgoyne?

Robert Murphy OR A Davey?

 

[Virgil]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

1) I'd still go with Drummond, very reliable player, McLeod can be a bit up and down, only backman I can think of who gets tagged on a regular basis.

2) Avoiding both TBH. Burgoyne hasn't impressed much and McPhee's new role could see him drop in points. I've chosen Milburn (at 20k less as well), but I'd take Burgo ahead of McPhee.

3) Definitely Robert Murphy, but I don't think either are particularly great options.

Deledio and Swan

vs

Hodge and Lucas (Hodge will miss round 1 so will need to relyon either Palmer or Taylor to fill in as a centre for 1 round)

Swan and Lids, I think Hodge missing the first round just doesn't make him a very good prospect to have from the start.

 

[powaflag08]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

Cloke or Franklin or Fevola?

 

[alwyndavey]

Re: R.Murphy V Fevola

I would pick Fev with Judd in the midfield he could be getting some good delivery in the forward line.

 

[Masss#10]

Cross or Hayes?

Which one?

Both are guns and most would say you can't go wrong with whoever you pick but who will have the better season?

 

[dont bowl there]

Re: Simmonds or Wood + 60K?

I think Simmonds only.
Wood is too expensive to have on the bench but too much of a risk to be starting on the ground.
I'm assuming you guys are starting him?

Got Wood on the bench and starting Simmonds.

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

Judd/Goodes + C.Cornes

or

Bartel + Gram/Newman

 

[Mordecai]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

Birchall + Boak/Gibbs

or

Milburn + Houli

 

[thewhippersnapper]

Re: Cross or Hayes?

Is this worth starting a new thread about?

I mean come on they are both guns, who the hell cares which one will average that extra 2 points more? Concentrate on picking the right mid pirced players.

 

[T Rick]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

Didak OR Monfries OR R. Murphy?

 

[Virgil]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

PF08; Cloke, much more consistant than the other two, they'll have you pulling out your hair .

H2G; can't go wrong with any of those players, I think I'd take Judd and Cornes, gives two great captains options if you're willing to take the punt.

Harro; stay away from Houli, that's my only thought on that one. Can't trust him to be named every week I don't think.

Didak OR Monfries OR R. Murphy?

Of those I'd pick either Didak or Murphy. Didak should hopefully get into the middle a lot more this season. Murphy takes a lot of marks leading out of the 50, and hopefully won't be brought down by injuries again. Don't think Monfries will improve all that much TBH.

 

[Colin D'Cops]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

Barry Hall (SYD)
vs.
Warren Tredrea (PTA) + 40k or so...?

 

[chickens_law]

Re: The Player A, Vs Player B thread

McIntosh + B. Johnson

or

Cox + Cloke

 

[DaVe86]

Re: Martin Mattner or Shannon Hurn - or somebody cheaper?

but crawford and lewis will take a few rounds to get back, giving Ellis a chance to cement his place early.