The 'Which Player Should I Start On The Field?' Thread (2)

[entourage]

If Ellis is not green vested on Friday night, Ellis or Bugg for B7?

Thank god the tigers are playing on Friday night!

I'd go Ellis, seems like a pretty good scorer to me, barring a vest he has potential for an 80+ I reckon, just gotta hope Hardwick gives him a full game.

Ellis will be my B7 assuming he is not vested.

 

[Pocket Aces]

Would not go Ellis, 4 straight vests coming into this week (2 red 2 green).

Buggs scores have dropped of tho, maybe upgrade Bugg if you can.

 

[James]

Would not go Ellis, 4 straight vests coming into this week (2 red 2 green).

Buggs scores have dropped of tho, maybe upgrade Bugg if you can.

I can upgrade Bugg>Scotland this week, but will go against the grain and hold onto both Bugg & Ellis for the season as my (B8 & B9) I'm not concerned about either losing value. Will upgrade my current B9 (Townsend) after he has made a bit more money though (currently 174k with a 17 B/E). I'm hoping he peaks at 200k at a minimum before turning him into a premium.

Ellis and Bugg can wax between B7 & B8 until after the byes. I'm just going by venue/opposition/likelyhood of vest etc in choosing which one to start from here on. So far I have started Bugg over Ellis in every game that Bugg has played (except for Rd 1 where I played both) but as you said Bugg has slowed down of late.

Ellis scores quite well for his limited TOG and Tigers are a very good DT this year, regardless of opposition. Surely Hardwick won't keep red vesting him much longer?

It's interesting that Bugg & Ellis are both scoring @ .69 points per minute, even though Bugg averages 72 & Ellis only 49. Plenty of upside for Ellis once he plays a few more full games.

 

[CaptScott]

Yeah, at this point I'm holding Ellis for the same reason. Were only just over third of the way through the season, plenty of time for him to pick up some full matches and fatten up a bit. I've also got Morris on the bench for emergency coverage, so I'm happy for Ellis to just sit it out for a while.

 

[earlyreflections]

Now that Mumford is back is it worth putting him on the field over Giles? Or better to wait for him to settle in?

I've had Mummy on my bench anxiously awaiting his return!

 

[Dwight Schrute]

Let him ease back into it IMO

Who to start out of Redden and Big O?

 

[lmach]

Now that Shaw is out, I have to start Darley and Morris on the field...

 

[Dwight Schrute]

Now that Shaw is out, I have to start Darley and Morris on the field...

I have to start Darley, Morris and Ellis .

 

[lmach]

Let him ease back into it IMO

Who to start out of Redden and Big O?

Big O I reckon. Playing GWS while Redden plays back-up to a in-form Renouf against Carlton.

I have to start Darley, Morris and Ellis .

Would hate to be in that position

 

[RickSanchez]

Darley v Ellis
Horsley v Greene

 

[Jessbek]

Devon v Treloar v Zorko?

 

[CrozaN]

Darley v Ellis
Horsley v Greene

Darley and Horsley IMO.

I am in with a tough one.

Got to play 2 of Zorko, Treloar, Porps.

At this stage im thinking Zorko and Treloar.....not sure, can go either way really.

 

[Korupt]

Adams or Zorko??

Zorko @ gabba, more ppm but vs Wce
Adams @ skilled vs Geelong

 

[yogibbear]

Adams or Zorko??

Zorko @ gabba, more ppm but vs Wce
Adams @ skilled vs Geelong

Zorko, cause WCE travelling to the gabba will be tough after a sunday derby.

My question:

Who to start on the field:
JMc vs. Devon Smith?

 

[Glenno23]

Adams or Zorko??

Zorko @ gabba, more ppm but vs Wce
Adams @ skilled vs Geelong

Zorko

Mine is Horsley Vs Treloar

 

[Spider Klein]

Zorko

Mine is Horsley Vs Treloar

I have Horsley, Zorko and Treloar and need to start 2

FWIW Treloar is the definite I have decided on. But maybe I am just blinded by his 119 last week.


So I will put in

Horsley v Zorko

Personally I am expecting people to say flip a coin cos really it is.

 

[scullman]

I have Horsley, Zorko and Treloar and need to start 2

FWIW Treloar is the definite I have decided on. But maybe I am just blinded by his 119 last week.


So I will put in

Horsley v Zorko

Personally I am expecting people to say flip a coin cos really it is.

That's tough as well. Horsley has been pretty consistent and they are up against a quality team this week and it's hard to scope how good Zorko will be this week. Flip a coin really

Any ideas on which 2 players to start out of Porplyzia, Treloar and Zorko???

 

[lmach]

That's tough as well. Horsley has been pretty consistent and they are up against a quality team this week and it's hard to scope how good Zorko will be this week. Flip a coin really

Any ideas on which 2 players to start out of Porplyzia, Treloar and Zorko???

Definitely Porps, not sure on the other two but.

Zorko v Treloar?

 

[Suma Magic]

I've gone Horsley & McDonald over Shiel & Magner

and

Zorko over Smith & Treloar.

 

[James]

Zorko, cause WCE travelling to the gabba will be tough after a sunday derby.

My question:

Who to start on the field:
JMc vs. Devon Smith?

Devon's Geelong Falcons boy. Will want to play well in front of his family & friends.

 

[QS]

Don't ask me why but I had multiple dreams about DT this weekend and one of them is that I got stung with Horsley as sub. Being a dream though I'm not sure how accurate my REM predictions are.
Subs shit me nonetheless though. Either him Magner or Coniglio to start...

 

[lmach]

I just know if I don't start Horsley he will pump out another 120.

 

[C_Turn]

I've started Zorko and Treloar over Jmac, Horsley, Magner etc..

What do people think about Jmac, I just have this feeling he'll be tagging someone and not likely to be able to produce a big score. It's just a punt though :S

 

[lmach]

JMac tags every week and hasn't scored below 72.

 

[Gugs9]

Can't decide between starting zorko or JMAC :/