The 'Which Player Should I Start On The Field?' Thread (2)

[lmach]

Definitely JMac.

 

[C_Turn]

Can't decide between starting zorko or JMAC :/

I'm in this boat aswell, i'm not sure why i have this bad feeling about JMAC ....

 

[James]

I need to choose 1 out of Horsley, Treloar, Devon Smith & Magner to start this week.

1) Horse: The obvious one with the highest average but playing the Pies @ the MCG.

2) Treloar: Coming off a 119 and named in the centre, but playing Geelong @ the Cattery.

3) Devon Smith: A Geelong Falcons boy playing "at home" this week in front of his family and friends. Could he have his break out DT game this week?

4) Magner: Overdue for a big DT score, but playing the red hot Bombers, will most likely tag Watson.

Thoughts?

 

[entourage]

Has to be Horse IMO

 

[mrpig]

Shiel vs magner?

I know shiel is a better scorer, but at geelong, geelong normally dominate at simmonds stadium and worried most of the gws players will not have the ball all that often

 

[Bender571]

2 Spot in the mids between Horse, McDonald, Magner and one of Treloar and Zorko.

Think I'll go with McDonald and Zorko

 

[RickSanchez]

Really not sure about playing Horse, I think I will play Greene. Had the week off and he's starting on the field. Pies will smash GC in the midfield, although second to the ball means Horse might get a lot of tackles.

 

[Shaxx Attaxx]

Darley or smedts? I hear Smedts is in for Scarlett?

 

[C_Turn]

Darley or smedts? I hear Smedts is in for Scarlett?

Wasn't that like 3 weeks ago.

I havn't heard anything but would love smedts to be playing

 

[CrozaN]

This will be a popular one this week.....who to start out of Redden or Stephenson......

 

[James]

This will be a popular one this week.....who to start out of Redden or Stephenson......

Well done to anyone who started Redden. I of course picked the bigger spud out of the 2. I realise Redden hasn't played yet, but surely he is good for at least 27 points today?

 

[lmach]

Carry on...

 

[earlyreflections]

Giles or Hickey?

 

[Cat for Life]

Swan or Watson?

 

[James]

Kruezer or Redden?

 

[amazingjoshy]

Hooray that this thread is relevant again

Prolly a common problem this week....Zorko vs Martin (or Cloke or Pav).....one to be benched???

 

[Jezza Jenkins]

dustin martin vs clancee pearce

 

[HolyRioli]

Ellis vs Shaw

Clay Smith vs Sam Gibson

 

[Suma Magic]

The only real decisions I had to make was Zorko over Martin and Shaw over Ellis.

I'm worried Ellis will get the vest this week.

 

[Ess_don]

Might as well dig this thread up after its been left well alone during the bye rounds!

Shiel vs JMac? Earlier in the year JMac was the "safer" option.. but now Im liking the look of Shiel, even seen him drift behind play a bit to rack up a few +6s and taking the marks from kick ins.
But they are playing the Swans.. Shiel may not get much open space and JMac may thrive, get his 10 tackles playing on Bolton..

O and I dont even have to ask for Zorko v Porpz, no contest! (cue Porpz to kick a bag on Matt Dea or something!)

 

[Jezza Jenkins]

Hooray that this thread is relevant again

Prolly a common problem this week....Zorko vs Martin (or Cloke or Pav).....one to be benched???

i reckon bench martin

 

[leungtl]

Prolly a common problem this week....Zorko vs Martin (or Cloke or Pav).....one to be benched???

Zorko > Pav > Martin > Cloke

dustin martin vs clancee pearce

Martin

Ellis vs Shaw

Clay Smith vs Sam Gibson

Shaw & Gibson

 

[amazingjoshy]

i reckon bench martin

Thats what Im thinking at this stage, but the wet weather forecast for the Freo Coll game has me looking at Pav and Cloke. Would love to bench Cloke but I've ridden his crap scores all year I just know he'll bust out and kick 10 if I do lol

 

[leungtl]

He won't kick 10 if McPharlin goes to him in the wet. They usually have pretty good contests.

 

[PIGSTi]

Morris V S. Shaw???