The which rookie do I start on the field thread?

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

I'm thinking about Nahas vs. Sidebottom. Nahas has been beyond superb this season, but i'm not sure about this new Richmond team with pretty much no midfield.
 
I'm thinking about Nahas vs. Sidebottom. Nahas has been beyond superb this season, but i'm not sure about this new Richmond team with pretty much no midfield.

no midfield rofl, very very rich coming from a west coast man.

nahas is a gun but not really for DT purposes, still he has alot more job security than sidebottom, he wont get dropped.
 
no midfield rofl, very very rich coming from a west coast man.

nahas is a gun but not really for DT purposes, still he has alot more job security than sidebottom, he wont get dropped.

By no midfield i was referring to you guys dropping Tuck and Coughlan and having a wounded Cotchin in there.

Also, job security is irrelevant since both are playing. This is a 'who do i start' not who do i get.
 
Who would be the better choice out of Pyke and Sellar in the ruck? I'm leaning towards Sellar after Pyke's disappointing effort last week...
 
Who would be the better choice out of Pyke and Sellar in the ruck? I'm leaning towards Sellar after Pyke's disappointing effort last week...

Id go Sellar also.

Anthony or Beams?

Beams has been scoring very well in the 90-100 mark for a while now.
But we all know he can dish out a 40 odd..

Havn't seen Anthony lower than 75 yet..

Consistency or chase a big one?
 
Who would be the better choice out of Pyke and Sellar in the ruck? I'm leaning towards Sellar after Pyke's disappointing effort last week...

3rd option there would be just take the donut - as it's all much of a muchness :D

Go Pyke - it's the week for rugby players!!
 
Id go Sellar also.

Anthony or Beams?

Beams has been scoring very well in the 90-100 mark for a while now.
But we all know he can dish out a 40 odd..

Havn't seen Anthony lower than 75 yet..

Consistency or chase a big one?

I think Anthony starts ahead naturally - but then you look at the opposition.

Anthony has easier opposition as well in terms of DT
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I'd go Anthony. Don't really rate the Collingwood midfield this week.
Might flip a coin between Sellar & Pyke. Really doing my head in.
 
I think Anthony starts ahead naturally - but then you look at the opposition.

Anthony has easier opposition as well in terms of DT

Scratch that - i had the opponents back to front

Anthony is a better DT player - however has a slightly tougher opponent.

It really is a coin flip - i'd go Anthony still though

me - i am playing both - with an aim of upgrading Foley to Swan/Hayes next week for the first week of finals - and having Beams as my back up for finals
 
Rich or Anthony?

Started rich last week and stuffed me of a 2100 score.

Anthony it is?

What every1 else doing?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

The which rookie do I start on the field thread?

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top