Werewolf TIAYG Werewolf

[Jhye Clark 13]

Dogs who claimed MP was a wolf yesterday was proved correct last night by the vig and he has returned with the above





JC has confirmed a flog role that they punted they had a seer and were correct finding MWPP as the cub.

Going by numbers in the game I am guessing it is a 4 v 4 v sk vs village (13ish with flogs {unconfirmed 2/3/4/5/6 or how many there are}, vig, joat, seers)

I'm still not 100% sold on dogs yet either.

My only concern lies in a game with so few numbers why we'd have two seers.

I'm also basing that on MC's N1 recap where the seer role looked just like that ... A true seer role.

 

[thewizardmelon]

I'm still not 100% sold on dogs yet either.

My only concern lies in a game with so few numbers why we'd have two seers.

I'm also basing that on MC's N1 recap where the seer role looked just like that ... A true seer role.

Makes you wonder doesn’t it. Two true seers in a small playing list is very unlikely. I’d love to offer more but I’ve got absolutely nothing sorry. Lynch me if you must! Just watch carefully which evil bandwagoners try to jump on.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Suspect BEaston was the Jobe.

 

[por_please_ya]

that would be insane… brilliant, but insane

This is exactly what I was trying to get at LOL. I thought evil all had a separate PM and didn't even know who their team mates were lmao

 

[por_please_ya]

I'm still not 100% sold on dogs yet either.

My only concern lies in a game with so few numbers why we'd have two seers.

I'm also basing that on MC's N1 recap where the seer role looked just like that ... A true seer role.

These are good points. Hard to know. I've seen a few games where there have been two legit seers. It's not common, but this is TIAYG.

And it's a he said she said, dogs vs wiz. If wiz is evil of course he's going to try and defend himself.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

These are good points. Hard to know. I've seen a few games where there have been two legit seers. It's not common, but this is TIAYG.

And it's a he said she said, dogs vs wiz. If wiz is evil of course he's going to try and defend himself.

Wizard is floundering. His faction now know who their head is.

Think we should trust dogs. I reckon there is 95% chance he is the Seer and 5% Mafia using their Seer results.

If there were two Seers, one could be wildcard, I guess but on balance I think BEaston was the Jobe and MCBG is just being vague or misdirecting.

 

[croweater 41]

These are good points. Hard to know. I've seen a few games where there have been two legit seers. It's not common, but this is TIAYG.

And it's a he said she said, dogs vs wiz. If wiz is evil of course he's going to try and defend himself.

I'm looking from this POV also.

In a small game evil probably don't want to out evil so early in the game. They'd like some cover and bargaining tools (for the lack of a better term) to work with opposing evil for some time.

To me it also wouldn't make sense if MWPP is telling the truth where evil don't know roles, that if Dogs is an evil (well probably mafia I'm guessing he wouldn't sell a second wolf out in a day unless he doesn't know of course) that he would run the risk of getting himself lynched when he could be the head and is unaware he is. But this is all again unknown and only going on MWPP's word.

Dogs 1/1 so far either fluked it or has knowledge or even further down a rabbit hole is a joker. But if evil aren't in PM's together then a joker is about a 1/1,000,000 possibility.

 

[croweater 41]

Wizard is floundering. His faction now know who their head is.

Think we should trust dogs. I reckon there is 95% chance he is the Seer and 5% Mafia using their Seer results.

If there were two Seers, one could be wildcard, I guess but on balance I think BEaston was the Jobe and MCBG is just being vague or misdirecting.

I think vague.

From nearly two days of gameplay this is a vague game and we are making the rules up as we go along.

I don't think he is misleading but is deliberately being as vague as possible as it is TIAYG.

 

[jmoo wan]

100% evil are in a PM together but don’t know their specific roles or powers - just like the flogs

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

100% evil are in a PM together but don’t know their specific roles or powers - just like the flogs

They should know their roles by the order they appear in the PM.

 

[jmoo wan]

They should know their roles by the order they appear in the PM.

maybe they just aren't that bright?

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Reckon we know the Wolves roles. I have no idea about Mafia beyond there will most likely be a Godfather , a goon and one other. Am really hoping it is not a funky role like the Apprentice and is something more reasonable in a small game.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Hmmn a few have buried themselves away today with lynch Mwerps or Wizard. Not confident about any of the lurkers.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Hmmn a few have buried themselves away today with lynch Mwerps or Wizard. Not confident about any of the lurkers.

With the lynch

 

[croweater 41]

Hmmn a few have buried themselves away today with lynch Mwerps or Wizard. Not confident about any of the lurkers.

Concerns on?

Pick unsighted but not unusual, Baz and Majestic? Ding and Harps also on some lurky lists.

 

[Frederico_WA]

Pick alive on D2(3?)? Maybe he thinks he's dead .... you know like those movie scenes when people wake up from being hit by a truck and say "am i dead?".

 

[por_please_ya]

I'm switching to thewizardmelon MC Bad Genius

MWPP can be killed overnight by the vig.

 

[por_please_ya]

His faction now know who their head is.

I also thought about this too!

Mafia still in the dark lol.

 

[Frederico_WA]

I'm switching to thewizardmelon MC Bad Genius

MWPP can be killed overnight by the vig.

This reasoning makes sense to me.

But ... who has the amulet? Any chance its been given to a wolf who has passed to MWPP?

 

[croweater 41]

This reasoning makes sense to me.

But ... who has the amulet? Any chance its been given to a wolf who has passed to MWPP?

I'm going to suggest the fact that Porps is voting there is a strong indication that the amulet (assuming porps was telling the truth there is one) was passed onto someone other than MWPP and TWM.

Also noting this both were able to be seer'd last night. If they had it the seer wouldn't have worked.

 

[The Majestic]

thewizardmelon MC Bad Genius

I think he's an evil melon.

 

[Frederico_WA]

por_please_ya where'd the amulet go?

 

[jmoo wan]

thewizardmelon MC Bad Genius

I think he's an evil melon.

I also think he should be the vote today!

 

[HARPSichord]

Switching to thewizardmelon thanks MC Bad Genius

 

[The Majestic]

Oh no have I suddenly started something lol