Live Event Toby Greene fronts the tribunal - Suspension appeal

[GetDimmaBack]

Still frames can make any incident look like anything. Based on that still shot I could say there is a player giving Toby Greene a full on knee to the ribs

You'd be saying that it was one of his team mates doing it!

...maybe they don't like him either.

 

[Anja_Nees]

Channel 9 reporting that Christian made the report after seeing footage that wasn’t captured by or made available to the broadcaster so there’s something a bit more damning out there.

The footage posted in this thread is honestly bad enough.

 

[BernieBrown]

Toby Greene is not Chris Judd you wally, and if you keep resorting to posting the same crap over and over, you clearly have lost the argument.

There simply is not available evidence that has been presented so far publicly that should result in a suspension for Greene.

You have yet to proven conclusively that what Greene did constitutes 'serious/gross misconduct'.

You would be a worse lawyer than Lionel Hutz.

If that dirty play doesn't count as misconduct it bloody well should!

 

[Blueboys11]

You'd be saying that it was one of his team mates doing it!

...maybe they don't like him either.

Exactly. It’s a still frame, so obviously didn’t happen but you could make any scenario up based on a photo

 

[Blueboys11]

It's mainly just Carlton supporters. Take a wild guess why.

I’ve just gone back through the thread and seen your Carlton supporter conspiracy theory. I’m genuinally intrigued now why??

 

[NonPhixion]

Is everyone ignoring the fact Bonts arms and hands were free the whole time Greene was roughing him up yet at no time did he try and grab Greene’s hands and stop him. Rather he’s just holding them out to the umpire, as if to say Ump look what happening, where is my free kick.

That says to me there was no gouging and at no stage did Bont feel seriously threatened he was in danger of injury. Reckon it’s a lot more of forceful pushing and rubbing down on the head than anything overly sinister. The hair pull at the end was probably the worst bit.

Might get one week for the totality of the incident but that would be it for me

Congratulations.
This is officially one of the dumbest posts I've ever come across on this forum and that is an achievement. Props to you sir.

 

[Thedeftouch]

Congratulations.
This is officially one of the dumbest posts I've ever come across on this forum and that is an achievement. Props to you sir.

Agreed. It was a truly impressive collection of incorrect facts, unfounded speculation and logical errors.

 

[Anja_Nees]

I can't really think of a player who was dirtier than Greene has been over a long period of time. Prick deserves to be de-registered. Why good blokes like Rance, Ward, Morris etc do their knees and not scumbags like Toby are the reason that commentators should never mention "footy gods" again..

Well there was 2016.

 

[Blueboys11]

Congratulations.
This is officially one of the dumbest posts I've ever come across on this forum and that is an achievement. Props to you sir.

Are you suggesting Bont attempted to stop the treatment he was receiving from Greene at any time despite having his arms free. If your getting gouged your fighting back hard.

Surely our resident freeze frame biased Brisbane poster here can show us some photos!

 

[Lindsay_Gilbee]

Channel 9 reporting that Christian made the report after seeing footage that wasn’t captured by or made available to the broadcaster so there’s something a bit more damning out there.

The footage posted in this thread is honestly bad enough.

Pretty shit that they don’t release this footage to everyone.

 

[Anja_Nees]

You’d think Toby would get bored of using the same old tactics:

“The plaintiff was dragged down stairs, repeatedly punched and kicked, struck with a crutch, pushed to the ground, pinned on the ground, and placed in a chokehold and/or headlock manoeuvre using legs,” the court documents claim.

 

[NonPhixion]

Are you suggesting Bont attempted to stop the treatment he was receiving from Greene at any time despite having his arms free. If your getting gouged your fighting back hard.

Surely our resident freeze frame biased Brisbane poster here can show us some photos!

Bont is literally in the most vulnerable position you can be in. Watch some MMA fights and see how easy it is to fight back in a position like that, especially after his probably busted his gut at the contest and is gassed.

 

[BarcusMontempelli]

If you rewatch, the other GWS player lying on the ground had his hand in Bonts face too. He was trying to stop him. He only has two hands.

Are you suggesting Bont attempted to stop the treatment he was receiving from Greene at any time despite having his arms free. If your getting gouged your fighting back hard.

Surely our resident freeze frame biased Brisbane poster here can show us some photos!

 

[BF Tiger]

I hope Bont gives the evidence that sinks Greene. Actions like Greene’s don’t deserve the protection of the player code.

 

[Anja_Nees]

I hope Bont gives the evidence that sinks Greene. Actions like Greene’s don’t deserve the protection of the player code.

Players code is on the way out anyway and GWS certainly weren’t quiet about Bont on Haynes. Doubt he’ll get any help from Bont.

 

[WillHayward]

The play had clearly stopped.
Greene then ran up and did his dirty deeds and then ran off.
Filthy little coward who needs his lights punched out

If I was Fagan I would sacrifice a player like McStay (who is useless anyway) to knock Greene flat out in the 2nd or 3rd quarter.

 

[Gadzorks]

The play had clearly stopped.
Greene then ran up and did his dirty deeds and then ran off.
Filthy little coward who needs his lights punched out

If I was Fagan I would sacrifice a player like McStay (who is useless anyway) to knock Greene flat out in the 2nd or 3rd quarter.

I genuinely don’t think Fagan could give a direction like that.

 

[jackenny]

This stuff happens almost every week. Not that it's a good look but you'd think he killed someone based on some comments in here.

Some of you haven't been outside of your basement to play sport competitively, and it shows.

To be fair, any deliberate contact to the face like that is looked at pretty disapprovingly. Nobody who has played or currently plays competitively sees contact to the face like that as a kosher action. Basically, I have very little sympathy for Greene if he gets rubbed out for that.

 

[market]

Here's a clearer shot of the eye gouging

View attachment 743016View attachment 743017

Looks like it could be touched, but we will go with umpires decision

 

[Orange Agent]

Anyone defending Toby needs to watch from the angle in this video, and tell me he's not a genuine piece of scum. Same guy who had criminal charges for assault with a dangerous weapon and assault causing serious injury

Serious question, how is this not a dangerous tackle?

 

[Orange Agent]

He looks up to see if the umpire is paying attention, then he attacks Bont's face/eyes

View attachment 743000View attachment 743001

Looks like the dog bit his arm to me.

 

[gimp!]

Serious question, how is this not a dangerous tackle?

Serious question, do you not know anything? It was paid as a dangerous tackle.

 

[Orange Agent]

View attachment 743007

The bruised eye is the bottom one in this pic. Clearly not a result of this incident.

 

[Orange Agent]

Serious question, do you not know anything? It was paid as a dangerous tackle.

Why wasnt he cited?

 

[gimp!]

Why wasnt he cited?

For what, giving away a free kick? You are actually a bot.