Confirmed Tom Barrass & 2025 F4 (WCE) traded to Hawthorn for 2025 F1, F2 & F3 (all Haw)

[Guardian Hawk]

I'm sure pick 14 (which would become Liam Baker) would turn it all around for us

Honestly, the price of pick 14 and extras (people are saying F2 is worth nothing cos of the F3 coming back as though Hawthorn will win the flag. In reality, it is an 8-10 pick upgrade on this year's results and could be more next year) is more than fair for Barass.

I think the MAIN reason it feels unfair to some West Coast supporters is because West Coast are looking to give that for Liam Baker. Baker is not worth pick 14 and is worth less than Barass. If you were keeping pick 14 (or giving less for Baker) I wonder if the thinking would shift?

 

[CobberRodgers]

Still has 3yrs left on his contract. Sorry TB, try again next year.

I’m tipping he’s worth less in 12 months time than he is now……..

Try again next year Eagles more like it.

 

[Astro35]

I’m tipping he’s worth less in 12 months time than he is now……..

Try again next year Eagles more like it.

Ok. I'm more than happy he's staying. He, however, might be shirty at the Hawks for failing to meet their handshake agreement (that's how it works, yeah).

 

[CobberRodgers]

Ok. I'm more than happy he's staying. He, however, might be shirty at the Hawks for failing to meet their handshake agreement (that's how it works, yeah).

I still think the deal gets done.

If it doesn’t though, yeah he may be shirty at the party he feels is responsible for the deal falling over.

 

[Iceman!]

Ok. I'm more than happy he's staying. He, however, might be shirty at the Hawks for failing to meet their handshake agreement (that's how it works, yeah).

I’m sure you will be thrilled watching the Eagles hit the draft with two picks inside 60

 

[THE_GUN]

So much angst over a pick 14. thankfully all the list managers have cooler temperaments.

To a poor many even the little things are precious
eagles have 2 picks #3 + #26 to rebuild and Reid

World of hurt coming

 

[THE_GUN]

Would have to be Monday. They need to get Baker done.

Wont be a problem they have pick #3 and F1 that could always use
The main priority should be what can be salvaged in the Barrass deal now the rug has been pulled from under them
They should just send Barrass flowers with a note

 

[Shueygod]

To a poor many even the little things are precious
eagles have 2 picks #3 + #26 to rebuild and Reid

World of hurt coming

And half our list 21 or under, you’d kill for a young talent the quality of Ginbey at the Tigers you clown.

 

[THE_GUN]

And half our list 21 or under, you’d kill for a young talent the quality of Ginbey at the Tigers you clown.

Who ?

 

[Shueygod]

Who ?

Name me a kid on tigers list that is anywhere near that quality.

 

[TigerTime88]

And half our list 21 or under, you’d kill for a young talent the quality of Ginbey at the Tigers you clown.

Not sure Gibney is the brag you think he is.

 

[stallon]

Not sure Gibney is the brag you think he is.

There is not a single player under 24 on your list that is fit to clean Ginbeys boots

 

[Farang83150]

Name me a kid on tigers list that is anywhere near that quality.

Don't bother engaging, he only comes into these threads to troll.

 

[THE_GUN]

Name me a kid on tigers list that is anywhere near that quality.

Gibcus maybe you might not have heard of him

But in a months time there will be another 6 your more familiar with

* I could name another 5-6 players but you probably never heard of them either as they are all young and not household names Tom Brown , Hugo Ralphsmith, Maurice Rioli , Seth Campbell , Judson Clarke

But i have to tell you the truth i only know about Ginbey because he cost you Sheezel i believe

 

[TigerTime88]

There is not a single player under 24 on your list that is fit to clean Ginbeys boots

I'm not arguing we have amazing young talent given we are really just entering our rebuild.

Gibney however is very very average and again not the brag you think he is.

 

[Hawks_Footy]

Still has 3yrs left on his contract. Sorry TB, try again next year.

Yep.. 30yo with miles on the clock, you'd be lucky to get a pick inside 30 at that point

 

[stallon]

I'm not arguing we have amazing young talent given we are really just entering our rebuild.

Gibney however is very very average and again not the brag you think he is.

Hes better than people think.
May not be an AA player,imo he looks like he will be a B+ player across half back.
Not every first rounder is a genuine A-grader unfortunately, but he might prove me wrong

 

[THE_GUN]

Hes better than people think.
May not be an AA player,imo he looks like he will be a B+ player across half back.
Not every first rounder is a genuine A-grader unfortunately, but he might prove me wrong

The thing is he is a young kid that has size but could be a player but could also just be another fail
Hardly a player to take notice of so far.

But surely you would have preferred 14 this year to a F1 plus a 2nd rounder next year
Hawks really did the dirty on the eagles here

 

[stallon]

The thing is he is a young kid that has size but could be a player but could also just be another fail
Hardly a player to take notice of so far.

But surely you would have preferred 14 this year to a F1 plus a 2nd rounder next year
Hawks really did the dirty on the eagles here

Barrass hasnt been traded yet. We dont know what we will end up with

 

[5minutes_of_Dew]

Richmond supporters are pretty rattled in this thread..

You've been crying in every reply you've made.

You need a hobby.

 

[Jupes]

ginbey coming along pretty well tbh

 

[bzparkes]

You've been crying in every reply you've made.

You need a hobby.

I have a hobby, it's called watching Richmond supporters be rattled and laugh at hawks supporters with their delusional trade proposals.

 

[Priddis Is Done]

Name me a kid on tigers list that is anywhere near that quality.

The one that's still in the womb that Hardwick railed harder than a donkey?

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Gibcus maybe you might not have heard of him

But in a months time there will be another 6 your more familiar with

* I could name another 5-6 players but you probably never heard of them either as they are all young and not household names Tom Brown , Hugo Ralphsmith, Maurice Rioli , Seth Campbell , Judson Clarke

But i have to tell you the truth i only know about Ginbey because he cost you Sheezel i believe

Holy shit. Gibcus?

Thats brutal

 

[JackOutback]

It’s alright, he’s used to having clubs agree to look after him only to have them let him down.