Hawkins was certainly more central to premiership success than Franklin ever was, despite the latter being a far superior player.Amartey sitting in stands provided more than Franklin or Reid in the '22 GF when Hawkins was rending the soul from the laydown Swans.
Take Hawkins contributions out and there's no 2009 or 2011 flags. Take his dominant first quarter out against Sydney in 2022 and maybe they'd have steadied and made a competitive game out of it.