Trade for GWS Pick #1

[kickthething]

Mumford wouldn't warrant B. Reid in a straight swap. An already declining ruckman for a young CHB who's previously been AA. Saying that, if it were somehow possible, grabbing Reid would ensure our Backline for 5+ years.

That to me is a totally ridiculous comment. And if you are talking injuries...Mumfords recent is not a body issue?? BTW Ben Reid aint been no ball of health lately. Had you not been watching Mummy prior to the cheeckbone, certainly no declining ruckman there.

 

[Pewdy]

That to me is a totally ridiculous comment. And if you are talking injuries...Mumfords recent is not a body issue?? BTW Ben Reid aint been no ball of health lately. Had you not been watching Mummy prior to the cheeckbone, certainly no declining ruckman there.

Mumfords recent injury, as someone sated before is nothing more than a freak injury. I think it's essential i retract my comment, as although it's my belief..it's been seen as outlandish by a few fellow Swans supporters, meaning i must be a little of the ball Although, you can't disagree that he has had a poor season, with the exclusion of 2-3 weeks prior to the Adelaide game.

Saying that, i do still believe Mumford wouldn't warrant B. Reid in a straight swap.

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

The only type of player we are chasing would be another ruckmen ( if Mumford goes) and a key position defender and they're a dime a dozen in the mid range picks

true but ben mcglyn and mitch morton need support for crumbing.what about lewis taylor,or billy hartung?thoughts?

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

It's ok, we get Lloyd Perris.

i hope we get him gr8 scholar if we got robinson we would have to get perris!

 

[Pewdy]

true but ben mcglyn and mitch morton need support for crumbing.what about lewis taylor,or billy hartung?thoughts?

I think they're the least of our worries with Membrey, Lamb and even Cunningham capable of playing that role. KPD's would definetily be our main target.

Another promising player in Perris, for next to nothing

Anyone aware of L. Parkers current contract sitaution? I thought they would of sighned him up by now.

 

[Sydswans0512]

If Mumford got offered more money there I'd be keen on a trade to get pick 1 but it wouldn't involve Grundy we are already short of KPDs

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

I think they're the least of our worries with Membrey, Lamb and even Cunningham capable of playing that role. KPD's would definetily be our main target.

Another promising player in Perris, for next to nothing

Anyone aware of L. Parkers current contract sitaution? I thought they would of sighned him up by now.

hey all im saying is a 170 to 177cm kind of small foward crumber.membreys a med, cunninghams starting to play defensive but as for lamb he seems to have became a half forward push to mid bloke so lewis taylor wouldnt be bad.
p.s if another club wants perris we have to bid it's one of the rules

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

If Mumford got offered more money there I'd be keen on a trade to get pick 1 but it wouldn't involve Grundy we are already short of KPDs

true but we DONT NEED BOYD!!!!! we just got tippett,membrey,we already have reid developing and soon LRT will be ready to go.

 

[Sydswans0512]

true but we DONT NEED BOYD!!!!! we just got tippett,membrey,we already have reid developing and soon LRT will be ready to go.

Did GWS tell everybody who they have to draft with pick 1 am I missing something?

 

[Pewdy]

hey all im saying is a 170 to 177cm kind of small foward crumber.membreys a med, cunninghams starting to play defensive but as for lamb he seems to have became a half forward push to mid bloke so lewis taylor wouldnt be bad.
p.s if another club wants perris we have to bid it's one of the rules

I see your point, i agree..we are lacking a few small speedy, forwards.

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

Did GWS tell everybody who they have to draft with pick 1 am I missing something?

well who do u think we need?what would u want?aish, scharenberg (that would b nice!)or 1 of VM boys kelly or billings?reply who u think

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

I see your point, i agree..we are lacking a few small speedy, forwards.

yeah! i saw hartung in the championships today and BROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOMMMM!!!!!
that kid can run and im pretty sure he's a small size.do u think perris will get picked up from the swans?(some idiot in another blog said the bulldogs!)

 

[Sydswans0512]

I'm thinking Kelly from what I've seen the guy doesn't stop running! Being from SA I'd like to see Aish or Scharenberg on our list.

 

[Pewdy]

yeah! i saw hartung in the championships today and BROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOMMMM!!!!!
that kid can run and im pretty sure he's a small size.do u think perris will get picked up from the swans?(some idiot in another blog said the bulldogs!)

I imagine with all the effort the swans have put into him, they'll make sure they acquire him. What ever means necessarily, i'd be extremely surprised if he didn't end up at the Swans next year.

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

I imagine with all the effort the swans have put into him, they'll make sure they acquire him. What ever means necessarily, i'd be extremely surprised if he didn't end up at the Swans next year.

what about this for a first round deal?

shane mumford(IF he wants to go!)
3rd round pick
jesse white

for

pick 10 or somethin like that
a chance at thier academy member michael gibbons
2nd round pick?
plz dont bag it out im just suggesting.(i say whit bcause we have tippett, naismith developing, pyke,then we have talls for eg when reids developed he can pinch hit.thoughts?)

 

[Sydswans0512]

I know pick 1 won't happen for us so I'd like our pick used on Bontempelli or Gardiner.

 

[Sydswans0512]

what about this for a first round deal?

shane mumford(IF he wants to go!)
3rd round pick
jesse white

for

pick 10 or somethin like that
a chance at thier academy member michael gibbons
2nd round pick?
plz dont bag it out im just suggesting.(i say whit bcause we have tippett, naismith developing, pyke,then we have talls for eg when reids developed he can pinch hit.thoughts?)

Then we lose our Ruckman and our backup

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

Then we lose our Ruckman and our backup

if bellchambers falls through get him in trade somehow.

 

[Pewdy]

what about this for a first round deal?

shane mumford(IF he wants to go!)
3rd round pick
jesse white

for

pick 10 or somethin like that
a chance at thier academy member michael gibbons
2nd round pick?
plz dont bag it out im just suggesting.(i say whit bcause we have tippett, naismith developing, pyke,then we have talls for eg when reids developed he can pinch hit.thoughts?)

If Mumford, indeed wanted to go. Our best option would be trading him to GWS in hope of the compensation pick they activated (10-13?). I'm unaware of Michael Gibbons, so i can't really comment there.

 

[Sydswans0512]

if bellchambers falls through get him in trade somehow.

It would take a fair bit to get him

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

If Mumford, indeed wanted to go. Our best option would be trading him to GWS in hope of the compensation pick they activated (10-13?). I'm unaware of Michael Gibbons, so i can't really comment there.

if ur interested go to afl.com and find the old rd3 prt2 video or go to mad monday show.com go to championships and find rams games and look at all rounds if ur interested.either same as perris or slightly better.but perris was more consistent in the championships.

 

[Sydswans0512]

If Mumford did leave I'd be looking for cheap options such as D Simpson or Currie again

 

[swansRgunBRUH!]

If Mumford did leave I'd be looking for cheap options such as D Simpson or Currie again

trade mummy,rd3 pick,and someone else and boom u've got another 1st round pick boo yah!!!!

 

[YorshireSwan]

I still have questions on his physical capabilities, but you have raised some valid points.

What are these questions that you have on his physical capabilities? I'm trying to understand where you are coming from ...

 

[alanlau34]

If anything you'd think the Swans would be wanting to trade OUT of the first round.