List Mgmt. Trade Hypotheticals (opposition posters post here)

[dlanod]

Fair enough.

Feel free to tell me to "get lost" and/or "find out myself", but how many spots do you need to reduce your list by? Is it 2?

Assuming you guys will be drafting at least 3 academy players plus trying to get a pick in the top 5, so 4 players min.

Will you have to delist/trade 6 players at least. Is there anyone on your list that is worth delisting or will those 6 be moved on in 2-1/3-1 trades?

Technically we don't have to delist any, as we're operating below our maximum already.

However the club has said it'd aim to only have the minimum number on our list next year, which means we will probably remove at least six players from our list.

Marchbank and Stewart have already requested trades. McCarthy will almost definitely move to Fremantle. Barrett seems a likely delistee, maybe with one of Downie or Simpson. That's five, before looking at the likes of Steele, Mohr, Finlayson and McKenna (assuming Patfull goes around again).

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Unless he's getting Haynes and Steele mixed up - because Steele to St Kilda is what is gathering momentum.

I know it's hard to confuse the two but maybe a slip of the keyboard?

Its not what they are now saying on the Saints board. Its been said that its not happening now. Don't know by who, but its what has been posted there today.

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

We should do Marchbank, Steele and 16 to Carlton for pick 5. Then do pick 5 and 7 for pick 1. Get McGrath. Then grab the academy boys with our other picks.
Draft could be:
McGrath
Setterfield
Perryman
(Insert any other academy player you rate)

Marchbank, Steele and Stewart or 16 for our first rounder next year and I'm on board. Pick 5 isn't on the table.

 

[Andre the Giant]

Marchbank, Steele and Stewart or 16 for our first rounder next year and I'm on board. Pick 5 isn't on the table.

You're not going to be happy if that's what you're expecting...

 

[Bokonon]

Marchbank, Steele and Stewart or 16 for our first rounder next year and I'm on board. Pick 5 isn't on the table.

Knew someone with a Carlton avatar would say that. Not saying youre wrong, lets hope the club negotiators can come up with a solution.

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

You're not going to be happy if that's what you're expecting...

TBF, you guys shouldn't be expecting pick 5. Our CEO and SOS have said repeatedly pick 5 isn't on the table, we aren't giving it up. I would suggest next year first rounder may be in play though, for the right deal that is.

 

[Ichabod Noodle]

Its not what they are now saying on the Saints board. Its been said that its not happening now. Don't know by who, but its what has been posted there today.

Well, if Steele to the Saints is off because he's staying then I'm going to be a very happy Noodle.

 

[Danny88]

TBF, you guys shouldn't be expecting pick 5. Our CEO and SOS have said repeatedly pick 5 isn't on the table, we aren't giving it up. I would suggest next year first rounder may be in play though, for the right deal that is.

All clubs posture about these things mate. We swore blindly Boyd wasn't being traded.... Until he was...

U will use pick 5 but ull be well compensated

 

[Great8]

TBF, you guys shouldn't be expecting pick 5. Our CEO and SOS have said repeatedly pick 5 isn't on the table, we aren't giving it up. I would suggest next year first rounder may be in play though, for the right deal that is.

Next years first rounder is fraught with danger for clubs around the bottom 6 this year. One of this years bottom 6 will be spooners next year IMO, Carlton could actually slide

 

[doodles98]

Jarrod Witts for James Stewart... straight swap

Our 3rd rounder for WHE
or
Blair or Oxley plus 4th rounder for WHE

 

[Ichabod Noodle]

Jarrod Witts for James Stewart... straight swap

Our 3rd rounder for WHE
or
Blair or Oxley plus 4th rounder for WHE

What is it with Collingwood fans wanting to offload Witts to us? This is about the third year in a row where we've had to say no to Witts in any number of various trade suggestions involving pretty much every player on our list.

 

[Danny88]

Jarrod Witts for James Stewart... straight swap

Our 3rd rounder for WHE
or
Blair or Oxley plus 4th rounder for WHE

You are kidding yourself if u want WHE for a third rounder

And those other players would clog a list not add to it

 

[doodles98]

You are kidding yourself if u want WHE for a third rounder

And those other players would clog a list not add to it

He's played 13 games in the last 2 years as a forward and kicked a grand total of 4 goals. He's not best 22 for you. He won't be best 22 for you in the future. He might've been a high draft pick but on exposed form from the last 2 years he is now worth a third rounder. No more!

 

[OrangeDuck]

Then maybe he won't go to Collingwood if that's the case.

 

[Danny88]

He's played 13 games in the last 2 years as a forward and kicked a grand total of 4 goals. He's not best 22 for you. He won't be best 22 for you in the future. He might've been a high draft pick but on exposed form from the last 2 years he is now worth a third rounder. No more!

I'll enjoy watching him play for someone else then

 

[_GT_]

He's played 13 games in the last 2 years as a forward and kicked a grand total of 4 goals. He's not best 22 for you. He won't be best 22 for you in the future. He might've been a high draft pick but on exposed form from the last 2 years he is now worth a third rounder. No more!

Well, if he is that hopeless, why are you sniffing around?? You desparate for list cloggers all of a sudden?

 

[JustInsideFifty]

Hi Giants. Not sure how your situation is for points and academy players this year and next, but wondered if something like this would interest you?
'Pies 2017 1st + 25 for 15 + 16
Would we need to find a little bit more, will you want those picks/points for this year or sounds ok?
To save you looking it up, points value would be close to even if our 2017 1st = Pick 10.

 

[JC100]

Hi Giants. Not sure how your situation is for points and academy players this year and next, but wondered if something like this would interest you?
'Pies 2017 1st + 25 for 15 + 16
Would we need to find a little bit more, will you want those picks/points for this year or sounds ok?
To save you looking it up, points value would be close to even if our 2017 1st = Pick 10.

You can't trade your 2017 first unless you get a first off someone else somewhere along the line. You won't be able to trade out 2018 next year either cause you already gave us 2015 & 2016


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[JustInsideFifty]

You can't trade your 2017 first unless you get a first off someone else somewhere along the line. You won't be able to trade out 2018 next year either cause you already gave us 2015 & 2016


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

We would be getting 2 firsts from you...

 

[grouse mate]

Hi Giants. Not sure how your situation is for points and academy players this year and next, but wondered if something like this would interest you?
'Pies 2017 1st + 25 for 15 + 16
Would we need to find a little bit more, will you want those picks/points for this year or sounds ok?
To save you looking it up, points value would be close to even if our 2017 1st = Pick 10.

How about pies '17 1st +25 for 16 and WHE?

 

[JustInsideFifty]

How about pies '17 1st +25 for 16 and WHE?

Do I then counter with Witts + 25 for 16 + WHE ?
Don't really want to argue about the value of those guys... just wondered if the pick deal is appealing from your side, it definitely is from ours and looks like it might be from yours too, depending on how you see your next 2 drafts going.

 

[BarryAglett]

Do I then counter with Witts + 25 for 16 + WHE ?
Don't really want to argue about the value of those guys... just wondered if the pick deal is appealing from your side, it definitely is from ours and looks like it might be from yours too, depending on how you see your next 2 drafts going.

Witts... It's like when in 2013 Pies supporters generously kept suggesting Didak...

 

[JustInsideFifty]

Witts... It's like when in 2013 Pies supporters generously kept suggesting Didak...

Wasn't here in 2013, but have read enough posts from GWS supporters to know you're not keen on Witts...

 

[Andre the Giant]

Witts... It's like when in 2013 Pies supporters generously kept suggesting Didak...

I would still prefer Didak now than Witts!

 

[Hawkboy62]

Hi, Now that Stevie J is going around again would you have any interest in Bruest? If so, what value would you put on him? Also would Tomlinson be on the table as part of a deal? No-one at our club knows if he would be willing to be traded, but you being flag favourites next year might sway him.