Trade period / National Draft 2024

[_RT_]

 

[richoatthedisco]

Probably makes more than Dustys playing earnings per year

No probably about it.

Let him set himself up for life in the NBA then get him when we're in our window.

 

[Morro]

Draper is the current standout, plenty of chat that there isnt one, but its him right now then day light IMO

 

[YeOldTiger]

the old man was a Melbourne Tiger.
sadly counts for nothing.
I hope OHB comes good.

Yep from memory was he Warren Giddey ?

 

[Daka]

We need good kicks of the ball.

 

[richoatthedisco]

Yep from memory was he Warren Giddey ?

Warwick.

 

[tigs2010]

Warwick.

Capper

 

[YeOldTiger]

Capper

Capper might get a game in our forward line right now lol

 

[Tiger51]

A very dark day and very little light on the horizon. Based on todays performances

should we TRADE

Baker,
Bolton,
Balta (?)
Short,
Broad,
Graham

and maybe DELIST

Coulthard,
Grimes,
Dusty,
Green (?)
Naismith
Colina
Young (?)
McIntosh (?)
Dow (?)
Sonsie (?)
Ralphsmith (?)
Bauer (?)
Vlastiun (?)
Kosi (?)

RETAIN

Blight
Gray
McAuliffe
Nankervis
Clarke
Hopper
Brown
Lynch
Prestia
Campbell
Miller
Hayes Brown
Smith
Miller
Lefeu
Banks
Fawcett
Rioli’s
Taranto
Mansell
Ryan
Gibcus
Ross
Trezise



Anyone I’ve missed?

 

[tigs2010]

Capper might get a game in our forward line right now lol

Probably already is in his own mind

 

[Tigerbob]

Hear me out. Trade Taranto and Hopper.

 

[HumanMeatball]

A very dark day and very little light on the horizon. Based on todays performances

should we TRADE

Baker,
Bolton,
Balta (?)
Short,
Broad,
Graham

and maybe DELIST

Coulthard,
Grimes,
Dusty,
Green (?)
Naismith
Colina
Young (?)
McIntosh (?)
Dow (?)
Sonsie (?)
Ralphsmith (?)
Bauer (?)
Vlastiun (?)
Kosi (?)

RETAIN

Blight
Gray
McAuliffe
Nankervis
Clarke
Hopper
Brown
Lynch
Prestia
Campbell
Miller
Hayes Brown
Smith
Miller
Lefeu
Banks
Fawcett
Rioli’s
Taranto
Mansell
Ryan
Gibcus
Ross
Trezise



Anyone I’ve missed?

Mr magic burner

 

[tigs2010]

Hear me out. Trade Taranto and Hopper.

Nah they can protect the kids. Trade the flankers.

Rather see one of them get snapped in half than our pick 1

 

[Bird Man]

Draper is the current standout, plenty of chat that there isnt one, but its him right now then day light IMO

Hard to tell some times as the Melbourne leagues are a lot tougher than SA. put any of the vic boys in that league and they get a big boost

 

[blaisee]

Hear me out. Trade Taranto and Hopper.

Hopper and Taranto and our our second round pick, for GWS first round pick

We do not pay any wages

Who says no?

 

[Tigerbob]

Hopper and Taranto and our our second round pick, for GWS first round pick

We do not pay any wages

Who says no?

GWS have moved on from players who can’t kick the football.

 

[Tigerbob]

Nah they can protect the kids. Trade the flankers.

Rather see one of them get snapped in half than our pick 1

Didn’t see much protection today.

 

[panatha1908]

Hear me out. Trade Taranto and Hopper.

If they could bring a top 10 pick, or 2 first rounders, or hopper a first and a second, and happy to continue paying their wages.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Smillie and FOS fit that too.

FOS is the great unknown.
Hope he has a good run injury wise.

 

[Morro]

Didn’t see much protection today.

lets not be like WC fans valuing Baker week to week, we are better than that

 

[Morro]

Draper is the current standout, plenty of chat that there isnt one, but its him right now then day light IMO

Coach_Required , you laugh, but you haven't had an original thought on a draftee yet, you are on FOS still based on other opinions of his form 12 months ago, so who is your current no1 laughy boy?

richoatthedisco , you disagree, so who is the current no 1 based on 2024 performances? Draper is currently, its not even a debate IMO.

I get FOS has been all the rage, but he hasnt fired a shot, so noone is risking pick 1 now.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Jagga going to win the Brownlow next year

I wanna know who's winning the Dusty errrr Norm Smith

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Dyson Daniels is the one. Played footy and is a mad Tiger fan.

Keen on Jack Daniels.

 

[Tomnat Tigers]

Coach_Required , you laugh, but you haven't had an original thought on a draftee yet, you are on FOS still based on other opinions of his form 12 months ago, so who is your current no1 laughy boy?

richoatthedisco , you disagree, so who is the current no 1 based on 2024 performances? Draper is currently, its not even a debate IMO.

I get FOS has been all the rage, but he hasnt fired a shot, so noone is risking pick 1 now.

You're putting too much emphasis on 2024 performances. Having good form in your draft year is important to a degree but for someone like FOS his performances in 2023 would have been enough to likely see him go second behind Reid had he been eligible. Recruiters already no what he can do and of all the players in the draft he has the least to prove when it comes to performing.

To say its not even a debate is a ridiculous call. Lombard and Jagga Smith have both performed well at VFL level whilst being better at the champs than Draper. Smilie and Langford have a number of performances on the board at u18 level and for the AFL academy. While Levi Ashcroft doesn't play a bad game and would have 10 times the hype if he wasn't tied to Brisbane.

 

[banzai]

A very dark day and very little light on the horizon. Based on todays performances

should we TRADE

Baker,
Bolton,
Balta (?)
Short,
Broad,
Graham

and maybe DELIST

Coulthard,
Grimes,
Dusty,
Green (?)
Naismith
Colina
Young (?)
McIntosh (?)
Dow (?)
Sonsie (?)
Ralphsmith (?)
Bauer (?)
Vlastiun (?)
Kosi (?)

RETAIN

Blight
Gray
McAuliffe
Nankervis
Clarke
Hopper
Brown
Lynch
Prestia
Campbell
Miller
Hayes Brown
Smith
Miller
Lefeu
Banks
Fawcett
Rioli’s
Taranto
Mansell
Ryan
Gibcus
Ross
Trezise



Anyone I’ve missed?

The retain list is bloody awful when you factor in how old Lynch, Prestia, Nank and Vlas are. It's quite depressing.

 

[tigs2010]

I wanna know who's winning the Dusty errrr Norm Smith

Smillie after he's tanked his way to Hawforn