Roast Tyson Stengle sacked after ****ing up again

[FR0GGY]

All Australian small forward

Sacking him will basically cost us pick 5 and 750k for 5 years.

 

[BACCS]

All Australian small forward

Honestly didn’t think they would select all 3 of Heeney, Bolton and Stengle. Blicavs as well? Seems like a massive Geelong circle jerk, which I guess is to be expected when you finish first.

 

[MrBarry]

Sacking him will basically cost us pick 5 and 750k for 5 years.

He won't be in the same class as Rankine by the time their careers end.

 

[AFC979810]

Sacking him will basically cost us pick 5 and 750k for 5 years.

You think he is really an All Australian if he doesn't play for Geelong?

I think he would have been underwhelming in our side.

 

[1970crow]

Honestly didn’t think they would select all 3 of Heeney, Bolton and Stengle. Blicavs as well? Seems like a massive Geelong circle jerk, which I guess is to be expected when you finish first.

This is a new length to go to in order to support a club decision. Tyson only AA due to the combination of selecting too many forwards in the forward line combined with a conspiracy theory on a Geelong bias.

He’s the gift that keeps on giving is BACCS.

 

[AFC979810]

Tyson only AA due to the combination of selecting too many forwards in the forward line combined with a conspiracy theory on a Geelong bias.

He’s the gift that keeps on giving is BACCS.

I think Charlie Cameron was very unlucky not to get the nod.

Had 47 goals to Stengles 46.
Teams #1 goal kicker. Teams #3 goal kicker.
Had 19 Goal Assits (7th in AFL) to Stengles 11 (83rd in AFL)
Had 46 tackles inside 50 to Stengles 16.

All of this without the benefit of having 2 of the best key forwards helping him out.

Only one All Australian jumper for Charlie Cameron despite being the leading small forward in the AFL over the past 4 seasons.

 

[FR0GGY]

You think he is really an All Australian if he doesn't play for Geelong?

I think he would have been underwhelming in our side.

I guess well never know

 

[FR0GGY]

He won't be in the same class as Rankine by the time their careers end.

Let’s hope!

 

[AFC979810]

I guess well never know

I know. And the answer is absolutely not.

 

[FR0GGY]

I know. And the answer is absolutely not.

May as well sell Josh then

 

[1970crow]

May as well sell Josh then

I like how there’s always a pivot that’s available. People can just go from ‘he’s no good, no loss, will he playing ammo’s soon’ to ‘he was never going to be that good with us’. They’re never wrong.

 

[Burtonsgottago]

Sacking him will basically cost us pick 5 and 750k for 5 years.

I was happy to let him go.. wouldn’t have been selected ahead of our gun small forwards anyway

 

[119others]

Well done to Hamish and the talent identification team - damn shame we didn’t get the benefits on this occasion but ultimately individuals need to be accountable for their own behaviour.

As a club we are CLEARLY the best at identifying and recruiting/trading for elite small forwards. In Hamishs reign Betts, Cameron, Stenge and now Rankine. Blows everyone else out the park

 

[secondary]

It's an odd one, I wasn't too concerned with seeing him go, but hindsight etc. Seems a huge balls up now.
Let's just hope Rankine goes well.

 

[Bearded Clam]

Well done to Hamish and the talent identification team - damn shame we didn’t get the benefits on this occasion but ultimately some individuals need to be accountable for their own behaviour.

As a club we are CLEARLY the best at identifying and recruiting/trading for elite small forwards. In Hamishs reign Betts, Cameron, Stenge and now Rankine. Blows everyone else out the park

Fixed that for you..

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

I like how there’s always a pivot that’s available. People can just go from ‘he’s no good, no loss, will he playing ammo’s soon’ to ‘he was never going to be that good with us’. They’re never wrong.

Even All Australian quality players will struggle here

So we just need to assemble a team with a number of players who are above AA quality, then we'll be back where we belong

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

I like how there’s always a pivot that’s available. People can just go from ‘he’s no good, no loss, will he playing ammo’s soon’ to ‘he was never going to be that good with us’. They’re never wrong.

Oh and also Fogarty sucks because he's no good, no other reason

 

[BACCS]

I think Charlie Cameron was very unlucky not to get the nod.

Had 47 goals to Stengles 46.
Teams #1 goal kicker. Teams #3 goal kicker.
Had 19 Goal Assits (7th in AFL) to Stengles 11 (83rd in AFL)
Had 46 tackles inside 50 to Stengles 16.

All of this without the benefit of having 2 of the best key forwards helping him out.

Only one All Australian jumper for Charlie Cameron despite being the leading small forward in the AFL over the past 4 seasons.

It does feel like he has got the nod because it’s a feel good story for the AFL. Charlie should not have missed the team. Tom Stewart over Sicily and Blicavs over Lynch the other baffling Geelong selections.

 

[AFC979810]

I like how there’s always a pivot that’s available. People can just go from ‘he’s no good, no loss, will he playing ammo’s soon’ to ‘he was never going to be that good with us’. They’re never wrong.

I like how you always incorrectly explain what other posters are saying.

No pivot from me. He has had a brilliant season and turned his career around. Hats off to him.

But this isn't some Hugh Greenwood gaff, either. All 18 clubs had a chance to get access to him in the preseason draft, they all passed for the same reasons we released him in March of 2021.

It's no coincidence that the below was written in October 2021.

Stengle will also live with Betts and wife Anna when he moves to Victoria. “I feel like I’m his older brother,” Betts said in Geelong on Thursday. “I felt really bad because he lived there with me and my wife (Anna) and we were pretty hard on him and kept him on the straight and narrow. “When we left, all this stuff started happening, not saying it’s because we left but it was tough seeing that from Melbourne.
“My best interests are that Tyson gets back and playing AFL footy. If he comes to Geelong, that would be great.”

I think when the decision was made by the Crows - we didn't have the systems and culture to get the best out of Stengle. Geelong and their stability, continued success were the perfect landing spot - not to mention he could live with Eddie and Anna.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

I like how you always incorrectly explain what other posters are saying.

No pivot from me. He has had a brilliant season and turned his career around. Hats off to him.

But this isn't some Hugh Greenwood gaff, either. All 18 clubs had a chance to get access to him in the preseason draft, they all passed for the same reasons we released him in March of 2021.

It's no coincidence that the below was written in October 2021.

Stengle will also live with Betts and wife Anna when he moves to Victoria. “I feel like I’m his older brother,” Betts said in Geelong on Thursday. “I felt really bad because he lived there with me and my wife (Anna) and we were pretty hard on him and kept him on the straight and narrow. “When we left, all this stuff started happening, not saying it’s because we left but it was tough seeing that from Melbourne.
“My best interests are that Tyson gets back and playing AFL footy. If he comes to Geelong, that would be great.”

I think when the decision was made by the Crows - we didn't have the systems and culture to get the best out of Stengle. Geelong and their stability, continued success were the perfect landing spot - not to mention he could live with Eddie and Anna.

Let's hope no one else we draft needs a supportive environment

 

[BACCS]

Let's hope no one else we draft needs a supportive environment

Hopefully to not that degree, Stengle's case seems fairly unique in that it appears there is only one person that can get the best out of him. Given Rankine has mentioned family reasons for his move home, it wouldn't surprise me to see him have a similar rise to Stengle and take his game to the next level with better support off field.

 

[AFC979810]

Oh and also Fogarty sucks because he's no good, no other reason

So glad our team turned around and became a juggernaut after our pathetic first 10 weeks so that Fogarty could begin to thrive. The transition from our 21 point loss to St.Kilda to our 42 point flogging at the hands of Geelong was staggering.

 

[AFC979810]

Let's hope no one else we draft needs a supportive environment

Well shit. Did you take a vacation the last 5 years?!?!?!? Ya think we had a culture in early March of 2021 that was able to nurture and get the best out of Stengle?

We haven't been a good and supportive environment at all. Thats why we brought in Nicks. Hopefully its changed now as evidenced by both Dawson/Rankine nominating us and us not losing anyone (so far) in 2021/2022.

 

[BACCS]

Well s**t. Did you take a vacation the last 5 years?!?!?!? Ya think we had a culture in early March of 2021 that was able to nurture and get the best out of Stengle?

We haven't been a good and supportive environment at all. Thats why we brought in Nicks. Hopefully its changed now as evidenced by both Dawson/Rankine nominating us and us not losing anyone (so far) in 2021/2022.

Soligo and Rachele signing on for 4 years before they played a game is also a positive sign in that regard

 

[Mr_Moogle]

I like how there’s always a pivot that’s available. People can just go from ‘he’s no good, no loss, will he playing ammo’s soon’ to ‘he was never going to be that good with us’. They’re never wrong.

I thought it was the correct decision at the time, clearly it wasn't. Not sure why people prefer mental gymnastics to just admitting an error.