peternorth
Moderator
- May 6, 2005
- 131,155
- 78,988
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Moderator
- #501
First wicket. B warne. C jones
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I have heard this a lot here about his commentary. Why was it bad or disliked?I was born in the late 80s, so I grew up playing and watching cricket when Warne was at his peak.
Back in U14s and U16s it seemed like almost every team had at least one leg spinner.
And usually their run ins and bowling actions would look similar to Warne's.
He inspired a generation of leg spinners, myself included.
I won my U16 bowling average, bowling leggies.
When I was around 14, Shane Warne's autobiography was published, I got a copy for christmas.
Even though it was 20 years ago now, I still remember certain passages from the book.
Warne had a natural tactical flair about him, like he was meant to play cricket.
News of his death doesn't seem to have 'hit' me as much as many others in this thread.
It may be because I couldn't stand his commentary. And he only seemed to be getting worse.
I guess I idolised him as a kid but kinda outgrew that phase as an adult.
Reading through this thread has been eye-opening, I guess I forgot just how popular Warne is / was.
The 'Warnie' Stand. That's pretty cool tbh. And fitting.
I think maybe one of the issues was if a captain didnt have a slip he would mention it, then continue to mention it for an hour. He also would just get completely side tracked an go on a tangent for an hour. He wasnt like Dermie with the arrogance, more so like he would forget he was on tv and was just chatting with his mates at the pub.I have heard this a lot here about his commentary. Why was it bad or disliked?
Overanalysis? Boring? Know-it-ally? Boys Clubby?
I've never heard his commentary but guessing it would be a bit like what Dermot Brereton is with footy. Which is all of the above.
Stories like this seem to be a dime a dozen about the great fella, i dont remember how it goes but something along the lines of for a celebrity a minute of their time can leave a life time of impact on a kid. Sounds like even at his peak he was more than happy if not even happier to chat with a fan.As an under 13 cricketer I remember going into Myer's (dont ask me why he was there) to get Shane's autograph on a GM bat that I still have today.
Shane didnt just sign the bat and push me to the side to sign the next, he talked to me for 2 or 3 mins asking me cricket questions, this was at the peak of his powers, returning from his first ashes tour. The autograph was great but I will always cherish him taking the time to interact with me as a kid even more.
Terrible few years for my cricketing heroes, losing Deano and now Warnie both way too soon.
Bowled Shane. RIP mate. Thanks for the memories.
Fixed it for you.The stand being renamed soon was a no brainer even if he lived til 99. Love it.
How about they go one further and have the funeral at the MCG. General public to sit in the stands and his close family and friends to sit out on his favourite hallowed turf. Fill the stands with the fans that loved him so dearly. That way he can do 1 final goodbye lap on route to his final resting place wherever that maybe. While the public give him one final "warnie" chantI know logistically it's not that easy, but would be nice if the MCG opened up today and played some Warne highlights on the big screen and people could come in and sit and reflect on his life.
Everytime I have been to India, I had a similar experience, except everybody asked me about Ricky Ponting. It was fun to be able to tell them that I was from the same town and knew his father and brother. Extraordinary ordinary people, who have become deities.My sister and her partner visited Delhi sometime around 2000 and wherever she went the locals, the locals wanted to talk about Shane Warne. Sadly she had zero knowledge or understanding of cricket but listened anyway.
One of her taxi drivers insisted on taking her to his home where he had put together a small 'shrine' to Shane's greatness with models of a pitch and players with newspaper cuttings of Warn glued on the cupboard it stood on. He assumed she knew Shane personally and asked her to take photos of his model and show them to Shane when she got back home to Australia.
The reverence with which Warnie was held by millions of ordinary cricket lovers people across the sub continent cannot be understated. I imagine they will be in deep shock at his loss
Lucky you. In my head all I can hear is the woodwindThat Paul Kelly song has been in my head today
I have heard this a lot here about his commentary. Why was it bad or disliked?
Overanalysis? Boring? Know-it-ally? Boys Clubby?
I've never heard his commentary but guessing it would be a bit like what Dermot Brereton is with footy. Which is all of the above.
I just loved his mindset, he was disgusted when a captain would bring on a spinner and put 5 back on the fence.I was in the minority I actually thought his commentary was excellent, could be somewhat brutal with his opinions, one example was when he went on about Starcs first ball wicket to Burns being a leg side half volley for best part of the first days play but he had good humour and I enjoyed listening to him.
Well said summary.A flawed larrikan as a human being and a genius as a bowler cricketer. He didn't need to whistle a ball past the ears to intimidate a batsman. His presence and his legend did that. Will never be another to rival him in the game.
Poor mark Nicholas he is very heart broken over his great mates death wow it feels not real he has gone
Ciggies are a shocking thing but some people have addicted personalities and no matter how hard you try to help,it's better letting go.Very sad to lose a close friend. Its all been a bit of a shock really.
That said, you can't like your whole life like a teenager. Drink, smoke, eat crap food, weight yoyoing.
He was a heart attack waiting to happen, & it did.
Phil Hughes was front page NYT two days in a row.How many cricketers have, or will, get a feature obituary in the New York Times?
Not too many I'm guessing.
View attachment 1338868
Shane Warne, One of Cricket’s Masters of Spin, Dies at 52 (Published 2022)
Warne’s management company said the Australian star died Friday of a suspected heart attack.www.nytimes.com
I'm pro vaccinations but there is a side effect with every medicine.Not going to shy away from saying I feel like the jabs are playing a role in these unexpected losses
RIP Warnie 🕊
Not going to shy away from saying I feel like the jabs are playing a role in these unexpected losses
RIP Warnie 🕊
Family history of heart disease. And heart disease himself.Very sad to lose a close friend. Its all been a bit of a shock really.
That said, you can't like your whole life like a teenager. Drink, smoke, eat crap food, weight yoyoing.
He was a heart attack waiting to happen, & it did.