Ward misses out on Rising Star????

[Libba39]

Aaron Joseph from the blues got it (19 disposals)

what a ****ing joke!

 

[Sween54]

Yes its a mystery, but Cal will play another good one this week and put his hand up for nomination again, its only a matter of time.

And Liam Picken must not be eligible because as a run with player he's been the best in the comp so far, much better that joesph

 

[2691617]

Picken is probably too old for the award.
Ward is just unlucky

 

[angry steve]

I might be wrong, but I would say Picken is too old to be eligible......

RE Ward, he should have been nominated by now (and it is a joke that he hasn't been) ,but he will at some stage and he has a good chance of finishing high up in the votes at the end of the season.

He is held in very high regard by a lot of the 'media types' who vote on the winner

 

[johnmandiddy]

Picken is probably too old for the award.
Ward is just unlucky

true on both counts

 

[Pklz]

Aaron Joseph from the blues got it (19 disposals)

what a F***ing joke!

Did you watch the game?

 

[Pigdog]

Did you watch the game?

Why would that make a difference? It's a BF tradition to fly off the handle with little or no facts to back you up.

BTW Ward was stiff, but a nomination shouldn't be too far away if he keeps up his present form.

 

[maddog37]

Ward was stiff but Joseph has been outstanding this year. Was one of the best in a team playing the top side in a blockbuster.

Ward was very good but played in a flogging against a team of non tryers.

Not sure picken has been better than Joseph either. Not a knock on Picken as he has been outstanding but every time I have seen Joseph he has beat his man. Not bad for a kid playing on stars.

 

[Libba39]

I admit I didn't but how does 19 disposals compare to 33 and a goal????

 

[Pigdog]

I admit I didn't but how does 19 disposals compare to 33 and a goal????

He played a defensive role on Milne who only got 7 touches while picking up 19 himself.

 

[.M a t t.]

He played a defensive role on Milne who only got 7 touches while picking up 19 himself.

Because Milne is really going to rack up 25+ posi's at 85% efficiency
Cal had been good for 3-4 weeks now and deserves it

 

[Pklz]

Why would that make a difference? It's a BF tradition to fly off the handle with little or no facts to back you up.

BTW Ward was stiff, but a nomination shouldn't be too far away if he keeps up his present form.

He played a defensive role on Milne who only got 7 touches while picking up 19 himself.

Great posts

Because Milne is really going to rack up 25+ posi's at 85% efficiency
Cal had been good for 3-4 weeks now and deserves it

Milne rapes us every time, he's averaged close to 4 goals against us over the past 6 or so games.

I wouldn't have complained if Ward had of gotten it this week because he deserves a nomination. The nomination is a big meh anyway, its just good to see Joseph get some recognition because he's been good all year.

 

[cosmicr]

whilst I do believe that ward deserved it more, i'm fine with it, the less attention to the dogs the better. It looks like the libba story is about to be overshadowed by the Michael O'Loughlin retirement too, which is good.

 

[Bodicifer]

Joseph deserved a nomination...Ward deserved it more...if Ward gets 5 touches this week he still should be nominated !

Who does the voting/nominating anyway? Don't tell me Ian Collins and Grant Thomas

 

[X_box_X]

Ridiculous. Grant Thomas and Ian Collins must be on the nomination panel.

 

[X_box_X]

Joseph deserved a nomination...Ward deserved it more...if Ward gets 5 touches this week he still should be nominated !

Who does the voting/nominating anyway? Don't tell me Ian Collins and Grant Thomas

WTF??? That is synergy. Seeing you had posted that at the same time as me totally freaked me out.

 

[Gridlock'd]

Ah well, he will get it soon enough. Jopesh has been pretty consistent all year.

 

[Chops_a_must]

Thought Joseph was 3rd behind Ward 1st and de Boer 2nd this week to be honest.

Really stiff.

 

[Spiritof82]

Ah well, he will get it soon enough. Jopesh has been pretty consistent all year.

Just shows how average players stand out in second rate teams.

 

[NathanMurray]

is ward allegble?
how many matches he play last year?

 

[Gridlock'd]

He is indeed allegble.

 

[Jean Claude Vas Deferens]

Cool your jets everyone. Joseph has been playing some consistent footy and has been awarded with this round's nomination. If Cal keeps up his good form like I'm sure he will, he'll get his in the next week or two.

And while Ward is allegble due to his tender years, Picken is too old and is sadly inallegble.

 

[Borgsta]

The spelling is killing me.

 

[.M a t t.]

Cool your jets everyone. Joseph has been playing some consistent footy and has been awarded with this round's nomination. If Cal keeps up his good form like I'm sure he will, he'll get his in the next week or two.

And while Ward is allegble due to his tender years, Picken is too old and is sadly inallegble.

It just proves that the award is a joke and awarded for consistency and not the best young kid per round.

 

[Jean Claude Vas Deferens]

The spelling is killing me.

Don't tell me that you doubt whether Ward is allegble Borgsta!