Welcome Welcome Josh Draper!! - 2022 Cat B Rookie List

[vidwhal]

Curious on the what peeps think about Drapes playing as a key tall, now we can see how he moves on field in the last two games and can see how he approaches a contest and anticipates.

Not advocating for the move now but in a handful of years, will we see him locked in defence, or moving fwd, even as a pinch hitter like Cox has?

We know fwd is his pref apparently, and depth availability will determine where he sits, but there's something very enticing about a silky 3rd tall like him floating around Treacy and Amiss.

 

[s_wd6]

Curious on the what peeps think about Drapes playing as a key tall, now we can see how he moves on field in the last two games and can see how he approaches a contest and anticipates.

Not advocating for the move now but in a handful of years, will we see him locked in defence, or moving fwd, even as a pinch hitter like Cox has?

We know fwd is his pref apparently, and depth availability will determine where he sits, but there's something very enticing about a silky 3rd tall like him floating around Treacy and Amiss.

Lack of KPD depth and we’re targeting LMac. No chance in the foreseeable future

 

[pK75]

Curious on the what peeps think about Drapes playing as a key tall, now we can see how he moves on field in the last two games and can see how he approaches a contest and anticipates.

Not advocating for the move now but in a handful of years, will we see him locked in defence, or moving fwd, even as a pinch hitter like Cox has?

We know fwd is his pref apparently, and depth availability will determine where he sits, but there's something very enticing about a silky 3rd tall like him floating around Treacy and Amiss.

Let him lock down 3rd tall defender first, if he can do that well it could release Chapman up the ground which would be more advantageous IMO.

 

[Madas]

Curious on the what peeps think about Drapes playing as a key tall, now we can see how he moves on field in the last two games and can see how he approaches a contest and anticipates.

Not advocating for the move now but in a handful of years, will we see him locked in defence, or moving fwd, even as a pinch hitter like Cox has?

We know fwd is his pref apparently, and depth availability will determine where he sits, but there's something very enticing about a silky 3rd tall like him floating around Treacy and Amiss.

What are the WAFL watchers thoughts on this ?
Was he good up forward ?
He definitely looks the part

YSAYE?

 

[rgauci]

What are the WAFL watchers thoughts on this ?
Was he good up forward ?
He definitely looks the part

YSAYE?

 

[Joao]

Curious on the what peeps think about Drapes playing as a key tall, now we can see how he moves on field in the last two games and can see how he approaches a contest and anticipates.

Not advocating for the move now but in a handful of years, will we see him locked in defence, or moving fwd, even as a pinch hitter like Cox has?

We know fwd is his pref apparently, and depth availability will determine where he sits, but there's something very enticing about a silky 3rd tall like him floating around Treacy and Amiss.

Given he moves like someone 190cm, he's probably the long term replacement for Ryan. The roll-off guy with the added benefit of being true KPP height.

 

[WilloTree]

Given he moves like someone 190cm, he's probably the long term replacement for Ryan. The roll-off guy with the added benefit of being true KPP height.

He's a CHB. Love him. Great guy as well.

 

[WilloTree]

Let him lock down 3rd tall defender first, if he can do that well it could release Chapman up the ground which would be more advantageous IMO.

He's already gone past Chapman. Love the Chappy, but he needs a run at it. Poor fella.

 

[mattis117]

He's already gone past Chapman. Love the Chappy, but he needs a run at it. Poor fella.

Lol, no.

 

[Docker82]

He's already gone past Chapman. Love the Chappy, but he needs a run at it. Poor fella.

Chapman was never a key defender so this comparison is irrelevant IMO.

Still like Chapman is in the top 5 most talented players on our list. You don’t play players like that as a KPD, especially when they’re 5cm undersized against most KPFs.

Chapman is very important for us to get right if we want to win a premiership. With all the leg ups other teams get we cannot afford anymore Anthony Morabito stories this time around.

 

[Docker82]

He's already gone past Chapman. Love the Chappy, but he needs a run at it. Poor fella.

IMO Chapman has never been a KPD or even a third tall so this comparison is irrelevant.

I still think he’s a top five player on our list in terms of talent. I know that’s a big call given how much footy he’s missed. You don’t play players as talented as him as a KPD especially when they’re 5cm undersized vs the majority of AFL KPFs.

With all the leg ups so many teams get we simply cannot afford for Chapman to turn into this generation’s Morabito. I want to win a flag and Chapman reaching his full potential will be a massive part of that.

 

[Docker82]

Lack of KPD depth and we’re targeting LMac. No chance in the foreseeable future

We’ve got six KPDs on our list (Cox, Pearce, McDonald, Draper, Davies, Murphy) and will only ever play two of them if Ryan is available.

Almost no one has someone with 80+ AFL games as their third best KPD. If Draper and Davies were any closer in their development the club could’ve tossed a coin to see who played. They’re both ready.

It’d be one of the deepest sets of KPDs in the AFL.

 

[mightymouse75]

And he is a good looking rooster to top it off

 

[Troy Cooked It]

Cox on return takes Hughes because Draper just looks all class. He adds another really decisive and clean layer to the backline. It's scary how identical his style is to Johnson. Glad (not for the injuries) that he has a good amount of runway in the team with Cox and McDonald out. Should give him plenty of development even if it ends with going back to WAFL.

Going to be an important piece in our backline for the future, you can bank on that.

 

[WilloTree]

Lol, no.

Lol, yes.

You don't think he needs a good run injury free?

Strange take.

 

[WilloTree]

Lack of KPD depth and we’re targeting LMac. No chance in the foreseeable future

Lack of KPD depth?

 

[WilloTree]

Chapman was never a key defender so this comparison is irrelevant IMO.

Still like Chapman is in the top 5 most talented players on our list. You don’t play players like that as a KPD, especially when they’re 5cm undersized against most KPFs.

Chapman is very important for us to get right if we want to win a premiership. With all the leg ups other teams get we cannot afford anymore Anthony Morabito stories this time around.

He's not important.

And, what's this magic number about 5cms? He's that same height as Charlie Curnow and 2cms taller than Pav.

Get a grip.

 

[s_wd6]

Lack of KPD depth?
View attachment 1945018

Ready* KPD depth. Hence why we recruited McDonald. If Pearce gets injured then suddenly we had Draper and Davies as KPDs. Murphy is a long way away.

 

[WilloTree]

Ready* KPD depth. Hence why we recruited McDonald. If Pearce gets injured then suddenly we had Draper and Davies as KPDs. Murphy is a long way away.

Oh, I thought you were being ironic. You know, because of our 6 KPD's.

Carry on.

 

[s_wd6]

Oh, I thought you were being ironic. You know, because of our 6 KPD's.

Carry on.

Very hard to classify as proper depth when 3 of them listed are in their first or second year and KPP take several years to develop. And the other three are all extremely injury prone.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Very hard to classify as proper depth when 3 of them listed are in their first or second year and KPP take several years to develop. And the other three are all extremely injury prone.

I think you were right 3 weeks ago but Draper hitting the ground like he has, Davies legitimately looking to have a step forward as well and suddenly things have changed. Some clubs would kill to have the depth we have now.

 

[WilloTree]

Very hard to classify as proper depth when 3 of them listed are in their first or second year and KPP take several years to develop. And the other three are all extremely injury prone.

Cox is injured. Played 41 games out of 48 though. Pearce 47 out of 48. Hardly injury prone.

Pearce

Cox

 

[MadMundy]

Give him some time in the main team and he will grow into a seriously quality defender, has Michael Johnson

Michael Johnson

Age

40

Ht

195cm

Wt

92kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

17.0

4star

K

11.0

4star

HB

6.1

4star

M

5.9

5star

T

1.7

4star

MG

260.5

4star

No current season stats available

D

7.6

2star

K

4.8

2star

HB

2.8

3star

M

2.6

3star

T

1.6

4star

qualities to him.

 

[s_wd6]

I think you were right 3 weeks ago but Draper hitting the ground like he has, Davies legitimately looking to have a step forward as well and suddenly things have changed. Some clubs would kill to have the depth we have now.

Which is exactly why we need Draper to stay as KPD and not swing forward for the forseeable future

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Which is exactly why we need Draper to stay as KPD and not swing forward for the forseeable future

Oh yeah, he’s not going anywhere near the forwardline