Win Prizes Werewolf comes to General Discussion - Day Eight - SK wins

[MP_]

Not that my word means much but I can assure you I was placed in a PM. There wasn't time to do all that.

But in theory in the first iteration of this game you could have selected an apprentice who already had a role which could make a very powerful partnership

 

[Pie 4 Life]

But in theory in the first iteration of this game you could have selected an apprentice who already had a role which could make a very powerful partnership

I selected Cubs2Lions who was ironically the Cub. But in this one all the roles were randomised. It was another way in which my faction got the short end of the stick lol. Another reason I'm keen to take down evil as they're far better placed.

 

[myblueroan]

Anyways I'll go with Jhye Clark 13 thanks and give us best chance of taking down a night immune. Anyone who is village aligned (there obviously aren't many) know that statistically a head is a better option particularly with the Beta gone (so can't be replaced by a night immune). Obviously I'm not going to lead my own head to get lynched so you know I won't also suddenly become night immune.

This is the play IMO unless we're targeting Pam or MP.

Gralin Wosh

Interesting.
Except you may well be leading us to get rid of another of our own villagers.
Plus you said you knew for sure DERO was evil.
So??

 

[myblueroan]

But in theory in the first iteration of this game you could have selected an apprentice who already had a role which could make a very powerful partnership

The rules say both those roles arw neutral.
I'm not buying into this theory.
The fact that Jhye agrees with you makes me nervous.
But I don't want to risk us lynching a villager.
Feel
So
Alone
Right now.

 

[Nothing]

Jhye Clark 13
MP_
Chipmunk
Quivorir
DERO
TheInjuryFactory
Pie 4 Life
Cubs2Lions
CM86
Nothing
BFew
DinoSoar
myblueroan
Pamcake1
Mesc

Mafia: Godfather, Underboss, Goon x 2 (4)
Wolves: Alpha, Cub, Wolf x2 (3)
SK & Apprentice (2)
Vig & Doc (2)
Seer & Fake Seer (2)
= 13

2 villagers.

Wolves: Alpha, Cub, Wolf x2 (3) that's 4 isn't it?

So 14 roles and 15 in the game.

 

[Chipmunk]

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Wolves: Alpha, Cub, Wolf x2 (3) that's 4 isn't it?

So 14 roles and 15 in the game.

Oh boy you're right. So there's literally ONE villager in this game left.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Interesting.
Except you may well be leading us to get rid of another of our own villagers.
Plus you said you knew for sure DERO was evil.
So??

Based on his actions. I'm going off your seers which are much more concrete. Only one villager left in the game, which mathematically means JC has a 67% chance of being a head (two heads, one villager). Same with Pam.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

There's no time for sleeping, we've got a breakthrough in the case!

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Mathematically it makes sense.

14/15 players are NOT villagers. JC and Pam have seered as VILLAGERS. One of them HAS to be a head.

MP_ and Chipmunk as the more experienced players, you know I'm right. Maths is mathing.

 

[Chipmunk]

Mathematically it makes sense.

14/15 players are NOT villagers. JC and Pam have seered as VILLAGERS. One of them HAS to be a head.

MP_ and Chipmunk as the more experienced players, you know I'm right. Maths is mathing.

 

[Nothing]

I'm confused even more.

 

[Nothing]

So the villagers are stuffed and it's just which evil wins?

 

[Pie 4 Life]

I'm confused even more.

Heads seer as villagers to disguise their roles.

There are 15 players let in the game and due to the available roles, there is one villager left (14 roles).

Pam and Jhye Clark 13 have seered as villagers. Therefore one of them must be either the Alpha or Godfather.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

So the villagers are stuffed and it's just which evil wins?

You've still got the doc, vig, seer and fake seer, they're just not villagers as such. So five good, four each in evil factions and two in neutral.

Hence why if neutral aligned with good, it's seven vs eight and evens it a bit more.

 

[Nothing]

Heads seer as villagers to disguise their roles.

There are 15 players let in the game and due to the available roles, there is one villager left (14 roles).

Pam and Jhye Clark 13 have seered as villagers. Therefore one of them must be either the Alpha or Godfather.

But how do we know they have seered as villagers?

You've still got the doc, vig, seer and fake seer, they're just not villagers as such. So five good, four each in evil factions and two in neutral.

Hence why if neutral aligned with good, it's seven vs eight and evens it a bit more.

Ok, that makes a little more sense.

 

[Gralin]

BFew CM86 Cubs2Lions DinoSoar Quivorir

this is your reminder that there is just under 3 hours left to vote

 

[MP_]

The rules say both those roles arw neutral.
I'm not buying into this theory.
The fact that Jhye agrees with you makes me nervous.
But I don't want to risk us lynching a villager.
Feel
So
Alone
Right now.

It’s not a theory, the sk chooses who the apprentice is, the apprentice role is assigned by a player not a mod. As pie pointed out when he was sk he chose cubs as his apprentice (who was already the cub in the wolf faction) this meant that straight away pie knew every member of the wolf faction if cubs gave him that info. Anyways it appears in the redo of the game the apprentice was randomly assigned so we don’t have to worry about an extra role unless of course gralin allocated all the normal roles then randomly selected the apprentice. This is too confusing hahaha

 

[Pie 4 Life]

But how do we know they have seered as villagers?


Ok, that makes a little more sense.

The seer (who has not been challenged for their role) said that's what they seered as. Plus JC said he was a villager knowing he would seer as one, so therefore based on that, it's a true seer rather than a false seer.

 

[Pamcake1]

Anyways I'll go with Jhye Clark 13 thanks and give us best chance of taking down a night immune. Anyone who is village aligned (there obviously aren't many) know that statistically a head is a better option particularly with the Beta gone (so can't be replaced by a night immune). Obviously I'm not going to lead my own head to get lynched so you know I won't also suddenly become night immune.

This is the play IMO unless we're targeting Pam or MP.

Gralin Wosh

Ok so if My

Mathematically it makes sense.

14/15 players are NOT villagers. JC and Pam have seered as VILLAGERS. One of them HAS to be a head.

MP_ and Chipmunk as the more experienced players, you know I'm right. Maths is mathing.

It's Pamcake for #$%@sake........I hate Pam. I've been outed by the soothsaying bluehorse. I have no power, looking like I'm a goner in the coming night. No ones paying me any attention when I've fessed up to being the village idiot. What's the mystery?

 

[MP_]

I'm confused even more.

I’ve played this for over ten years and I still get confused every game

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Ok so if My

It's Pamcake for #$%@sake........I hate Pam. I've been outed by the soothsaying bluehorse. I have no power, looking like I'm a goner in the coming night. No ones paying me any attention when I've fessed up to being the village idiot. What's the mystery?

If that's true that you're a villager, then you'll have no trouble voting Jhye Clark 13 as it means he is definitely either Alpha or Godfather because either he is, or you are essentially.

 

[Gralin]

I’ve played this for over ten years and I still get confused every game

and that's without me ****ing it up and then playing fast and loose with reality

 

[MP_]

Jhyeclark for me Gralin . I have however completely confused myself with the apprentice role though and look forward to dying to have my questions answered.

 

[Nothing]

The seer (who has not been challenged for their role) said that's what they seered as. Plus JC said he was a villager knowing he would seer as one, so therefore based on that, it's a true seer rather than a false seer.

Ok, then why haven't they been challenged? I have no information to work out their role (or I don't understand the available information to work it out).

I get the maths (now). At least that bit makes sense.