Win Prizes Werewolf comes to General Discussion - Day Eight - SK wins

[Chipmunk]

Also @ Doc I would protect myblueroan tonight as their information from seers will be the most valuable to the village given the sheer volume of roles left.

Why? By your logic, if they seer a role they’re not the lynch

 

[Nothing]

I feel like on Survivor when everyone votes for the same person even though it's not ideal for their game.

With that I'll stay on CM86

 

[Pamcake1]

You wouldn't be a goner for being a plIm ol villager right now you wouldn't think pamcake. I outed myself as well for the good of trying to save us. I asked for other seer so we could sort who is seeing correctly. We figured that out. I've protected our Doctor.

Oh I think neither of us will see past sunrise myblueroan and if we do it will just to be toyed with.......here have some cake for our wake.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

With more than 10 to go, absolutely you take out the guaranteed evil/neutral rather than the punt. Otherwise in future games evil will be outing themselves all over the place and going ‘but don’t lynch me, take a punt on a Head’! There’s plenty of time to sort out the unknowns.

And you know it. Understand that you want to argue otherwise

A punt? He's a 67% chance of being a head. That's more than a punt. You're making it sound like he's a 10% chance. But I understand you want to argue otherwise as mathematically you're in a faction (over 50% chance).

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Why? By your logic, if they seer a role they’re not the lynch

Come on Chippy, you can't play dumb with me. It very clearly helps the vig at night.

 

[myblueroan]

Well either Pamcake or JC13 is a head, that's just a fact based on numbers. JC13 is just the one more than crafty enough of getting it done.

I make it 2 villagers left.
Beta and 1 wolf gone

In Mafia
Roleblock gone
Adds up to 13 roles?
2 left?

 

[Gralin]

Gralin
I looked up rules which said SK and apprentice are neutral.
So if it's true that SK chooses a player and that player already has a role, but then has to be apprentice...do they stop in the other role? Who are they beholden to?
What if their team wants to take out the SK?

All good questions that only playing can answer

I thought that Apprentice would be sorted before other roles are given out?

Now where would be the fun in that?

 

[Pie 4 Life]

I make it 2 villagers left.
Beta and 1 wolf gone

In Mafia
Roleblock gone
Adds up to 13 roles?
2 left?

Who said earlier I'd miscounted when I said there was two left and instead there was one? Either way, one is still bound to be a head given other village claims.

 

[myblueroan]

View attachment 1864148
Oh I think neither of us will see past sunrise myblueroan and if we do it will just to be toyed with.......here have some cake for our wake.

Too bad if Jhye is a villager...?

 

[myblueroan]

Who said earlier I'd miscounted when I said there was two left and instead there was one? Either way, one is still bound to be a head given other village claims.

Umm..
If 2 left then they may well be Jhye and Pamcake1?

 

[Nothing]

Who said earlier I'd miscounted when I said there was two left and instead there was one? Either way, one is still bound to be a head given other village claims.

You had alpha, cub, wolf x2 =4.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Umm..
If 2 left then they may well be Jhye and Pamcake1?

Would mean MP_ is then a head and I'm more inclined to believe MP.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

You had alpha, cub, wolf x2 =4

But the original math I had of 13 roles / 15 was correct?

 

[myblueroan]

I feel large clever maNipulations and shinnanigans going on.
Plus suspect evil types are also voting for Jhye.

Jhye....what say you?

 

[myblueroan]

Would mean MP_ is then a head and I'm more inclined to believe MP.

Ahhhh!
So MP is probs SK!!!
And evil is all let's get Jhye..

And you don't care cos, why would you.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

I feel large clever maNipulations and shinnanigans going on.
Plus suspect evil types are also voting for Jhye.

Jhye....what say you?

I'm more confident in Jhye being the head given Chippy's reaction. There's no manipulations with seers left in play, so the seers have to be correct.

Obviously he's gonna claim villager

 

[Chipmunk]

A punt? He's a 67% chance of being a head. That's more than a punt. You're making it sound like he's a 10% chance. But I understand you want to argue otherwise as mathematically you're in a faction (over 50% chance).

Good to see you’re making your arguments up as you go.

Even with those odds you’re wrong about the lynch choice, and even you’d admit that your view is based on self-preservation and what is right for the SK (which is fine, and you’re also saying I have my view with an ulterior motive, though you know I like to go all strategy at this stage).

We have our dividing lines though and that’s clear to others. With other people (not naming names) this argument can go on for many pages.

 

[myblueroan]

You had alpha, cub, wolf x2 =4.

One wolf is dead!!!

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Ahhhh!
So MP is probs SK!!!
And evil is all let's get Jhye..

And you don't care cos, why would you.

Yes MP_ is SK. That checks out based on this game so far lol

 

[Chipmunk]

Come on Chippy, you can't play dumb with me. It very clearly helps the vig at night.

Im proving how nonsensical your argument is by extending your logic.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Good to see you’re making your arguments up as you go.

Even with those odds you’re wrong about the lynch choice, and even you’d admit that your view is based on self-preservation and what is right for the SK (which is fine, and you’re also saying I have my view with an ulterior motive, though you know I like to go all strategy at this stage).

We have our dividing lines though and that’s clear to others. With other people (not naming names) this argument can go on for many pages.

Please, are you seriously saying a non night immune person is better as a lynch target than a night immune? Come on now.

The difference between us is my allegiences are out in the open. I've said from the start of today, whoever the vig hit is the play as they're night immune. You literally agreed with me. Now that's it's JC on the table all of a sudden "oh that's not the move"... gee I wonder why

 

[Nothing]

But the original math I had of 13 roles / 15 was correct?

If there were only 3 werewolves then 13/15 is right.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Dammit, kills me to say but you’re right.

I was gonna instavote you but I guess I’ll come back later.

Enjoy!

I'm only right that the night immune was the play when it's not Chippy's night immune teammate.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

For those playing at home while Chippy tries to say I'm nonsensical.

Ask yourself, why would he agree this morning that whoever the vig hit is the play, but now that a certain player is in the gun, he doesn't think that is the play?

 

[Chipmunk]

Please, are you seriously saying a non night immune person is better as a lynch target than a night immune? Come on now.

The difference between us is my allegiences are out in the open. I've said from the start of today, whoever the vig hit is the play as they're night immune. You literally agreed with me. Now that's it's JC on the table all of a sudden "oh that's not the move"... gee I wonder why

That’s a 100% chance of hitting night immune evil in that situation. You’re saying a 67% chance of hitting night immune evil is better than a 100% chance of hitting non night immune evil with 15 players left, which is fundamentally wrong.

Also there’s an exploding amulet out there somewhere which will be a further unknown.