• Please read this post on the rules on BigFooty regarding posting copyright material, including fair dealing rules. Repeat infringements could see your account limited or closed.

Western Region FL - Divy 1 2019

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bully Man said:
Why don’t you actually find out what the breaches are ? The Bullen situation is one of several. If you don’t know your club is cheating then , you Sir are the goose . It may not be next week but your club will be officially exposed at some point and any successes you think you may have had will go down as a sham . Built on zero integrity.
Click to expand...
No worries ghazi
 
I expect they can't be thrown out of finals, especially with hearing beginning on Monday next week. Bit tough to ask St.Albans to back up from mad Monday!
 
Considering the 2019 home & away season will be completed when the case is heard any penalty involving loss of premiership points or disqualification from finals will have to be applied for 2020 season. It's absolutely appalling that this investigation wasn't done and dusted before round 1.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Kennedy, Magnabosco, Robbins, Goetz, Tighe, Post, Norton, Spiteri, all Altona Juniors that played at a higher Level. Look after your players when they are Juniors and you reap the rewards. And won’t cost you a fortune. It’s called loyalty. Not mercenary. Add the long list of the senior squad that played last week and says more about the quality and integrity of players and club. Werribee, Hoppers and Spotty the same. Point Cook in the near future also. To be honest I’d rather see a side beat DP in the coming weeks. I’m pretty sure the players in any team that managed to knock them out of the race would gain so much satisfaction as would 99% of non DP fans
 
Truth Be Said said:
Considering the 2019 home & away season will be completed when the case is heard any penalty involving loss of premiership points or disqualification from finals will have to be applied for 2020 season. It's absolutely appalling that this investigation wasn't done and dusted before round 1.
Click to expand...
Is that written anywhere or are you applying your version common sense?
 
Truth Be Said said:
Considering the 2019 home & away season will be completed when the case is heard any penalty involving loss of premiership points or disqualification from finals will have to be applied for 2020 season. It's absolutely appalling that this investigation wasn't done and dusted before round 1.
Click to expand...
Why is it a disgrace? I think I'm more comfortable that it's been done properly and thoroughly. There must have been a fair bit of fact and fiction to wade through.

If you think, they aren't loaded and prepared and conditioned for an outcome, your very much mistaken.

They wouldn't want to take on Galbally QC with a half arsed investigation.

It must be worth the risk the WRFL and football Victoria are willing to take, otherwise like many other "too hard" controversies, it would be swept under the carpet.
 
table tennis said:
Why is it a disgrace? I think I'm more comfortable that it's been done properly and thoroughly. There must have been a fair bit of fact and fiction to wade through.

If you think, they aren't loaded and prepared and conditioned for an outcome, your very much mistaken.

They wouldn't want to take on Galbally QC with a half arsed investigation.

It must be worth the risk the WRFL and football Victoria are willing to take, otherwise like many other "too hard" controversies, it would be swept under the carpet.
Click to expand...
Ok, will you be comfortable if the findings are all based around the coach playing reserves?

After 10 months of investigations do you honestly believe the WRFL & AFL VIC where going to come out and say they found nothing? The reason they haven't said anything is because the Herald Sun already spilt the main breach which is rule 2(a)(i) exceeding the allowable player payments. The League were made aware of this in October and it shouldn't take 10-11 months to come out with any other findings. This should've been done well before the season has ended and now the best finals series we might see in a very long time will be over shadowed by the investigation which is why it is a disgrace.
 
Truth Be Said said:
Ok, will you be comfortable if the findings are all based around the coach playing reserves?

After 10 months of investigations do you honestly believe the WRFL & AFL VIC where going to come out and say they found nothing? The reason they haven't said anything is because the Herald Sun already spilt the main breach which is rule 2(a)(i) exceeding the allowable player payments. The League were made aware of this in October and it shouldn't take 10-11 months to come out with any other findings. This should've been done well before the season has ended and now the best finals series we might see in a very long time will be over shadowed by the investigation which is why it is a disgrace.
Click to expand...
The HS spilled what it had been given to spill.
 
Truth Be Said said:
Ok, will you be comfortable if the findings are all based around the coach playing reserves?

After 10 months of investigations do you honestly believe the WRFL & AFL VIC where going to come out and say they found nothing? The reason they haven't said anything is because the Herald Sun already spilt the main breach which is rule 2(a)(i) exceeding the allowable player payments. The League were made aware of this in October and it shouldn't take 10-11 months to come out with any other findings. This should've been done well before the season has ended and now the best finals series we might see in a very long time will be over shadowed by the investigation which is why it is a disgrace.
Click to expand...
Sounds like it took so long was DP weren’t very helpful with the investigation. Some of the other charges relate to this don’t they. If a club isn’t will to help the investigators then it will always take longer. These charges are more serious then going over the cap because it sounds like they allegedly tried to hide information.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Truth Be Said said:
Who's to say it was the League who leaked it? The reports had already been handed to the clubs so who's to say someone from Deer Park didn't leak the findings?
Click to expand...
So DP leak it for what reason? An attempt to highlight the incompetence of AFL Vic and WRFL? If that was the case, why not give the HS all of the info regarding the administrative errors as well?
 
PhiloBeddoe said:
That is absolute bulls**t. I can’t believe the s**t that come out of people’s mouths in this comp.
We all know it had nothing to do with the traffic. It was all about playing at the club with the best canteen in the league! 🤪
Click to expand...
Got better paper bags to put there hot dogs in I believe that’s the only reason now more footy please feeling peckish
 
I'm more than comfortable that if all charges are around Bullens quest to be a reserves hero.

You should be too that if that's all they found that your club is either very good at covering up or actually playing within the boundaries of the competition. I'll let you decide witch one.
 
I don't think the club who wins the premiership is going to feel any better if DP makes the finals or not. A flag is a flag and I'd imagine it would feel amazing to win regardless of whether St Albans or Deer Park play finals this year.

If Deer Park manage to make it through however they will win it by the length of the Flemington straight.
 
AFDogs said:
I don't think the club who wins the premiership is going to feel any better if DP makes the finals or not. A flag is a flag and I'd imagine it would feel amazing to win regardless of whether St Albans or Deer Park play finals this year.

If Deer Park manage to make it through however they will win it by the length of the Flemington straight.
Click to expand...

You are kidding aren’t you Altona belted then first time and then also won in the second half of the year hoppers are 1 and 1 Spotty are 1 and 1 and the second time they kicked themselves out of it with 2 more scoring shots the goat herders even are 1 and 1 the only team not to beat them is Werribee

I can sew Altona winning the gf against Spotty and thats even if the cheaters are in the finals
 
Survey said:
One thing I will say out of all of this. The Spelling and Grammar from some of you posters is appalling!!!
Click to expand...
Said the bloke who used three exclamation marks.
 
Is it true James Wong cited for striking against St Albans? Along with Taylor Jones tearing a hamstring...

Makes it difficult for them from here if true
 
table tennis said:
I'm more than comfortable that if all charges are around Bullens quest to be a reserves hero.

You should be too that if that's all they found that your club is either very good at covering up or actually playing within the boundaries of the competition. I'll let you decide witch one.
Click to expand...
Let me make it clear, I have nothing to do with Deer Park. I've actually played for a couple of the clubs currently in the top 5 so I'm certainly not barracking for Deer Park. It might seem I'm defending them at times but I call things as I see them and try to point out facts that others may have overlooked.
 
table tennis said:
I'm more than comfortable that if all charges are around Bullens quest to be a reserves hero.

You should be too that if that's all they found that your club is either very good at covering up or actually playing within the boundaries of the competition. I'll let you decide witch one.
Click to expand...
Not sure why you refer to Bullen as being a reserves hero. I'm hearing more often these days that clubs are calling blokes who are long time retired to play reserves which I think is a serious risk. Would you rather a club reserves forfeits a match which leaves two teams missing out on playing a game or a senior coach who is still in reasonable shape for reserves football filling in? I'm also fairly sure the senior coach would rather be preparing for the senior game rather than be playing in the reserves.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

S
  • Sticky
WRFL Div 1 Discussion 2025
2
Replies
38
Views
2K
Dogs till i die
D

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top