What each Club Needs

[worsfold]

Basically what i believe Teams mainly need to draft to top up their lists

1. Melbourne - Key forward
2. West Coast - Midfielder
3. Fremantle - Midfield, Second ruck
4. Port Power - developing ruck, key forward
5. Essendon - Key Defenders
6. Carlton - another forward and key defenders
7. Bribane - Midfielders
8. Richmond - Ruckman, key forward
9. kangaroos -Mids and key forward
10. Collingwood - Mids, key forward
11.Sydney - Key position
12.Adelaide - Hlf backs, mids
13.St Kilda - Midfielders
14.Bulldogs - Key Forward
15.Geelong - Defenders
16.Hawks - Key defender

 

[The Octagon]

Basically what i believe Teams mainly need to draft to top up their lists

1. Melbourne - Key forward
2. West Coast - Midfielder
3. Fremantle - Midfield, Second ruck
4. Port Power - developing ruck, key forward
5. Essendon - Key Defenders
6. Carlton - another forward and key defenders
7. Bribane - Midfielders
8. Richmond - Ruckman, key forward
9. kangaroos -Mids and key forward
10. Collingwood - Mids, key forward
11.Sydney - Key position
12.Adelaide - Hlf backs, mids
13.St Kilda - Midfielders
14.Bulldogs - Key Forward
15.Geelong - Defenders
16.Hawks - Key defender

Collingwood do not need to draft any more forwards. Midfielders, Midfielders and then maybe a Key Back is what the pies need come draft day.
Rocca
Reid
Rusling
Dawes
Cloke
Anthony
Medhurst etc... Enough forwards as it is.

 

[popathon]

Basically what i believe Teams mainly need to draft to top up their lists

1. Melbourne - Key forward
2. West Coast - Midfielder
3. Fremantle - Midfield, Second ruck
4. Port Power - developing ruck, key forward
5. Essendon - Key Defenders
6. Carlton - another forward and key defenders
7. Bribane - Midfielders
8. Richmond - Ruckman, key forward
9. kangaroos -Mids and key forward
10. Collingwood - Mids, key forward
11.Sydney - Key position
12.Adelaide - Hlf backs, mids
13.St Kilda - Midfielders
14.Bulldogs - Key Forward
15.Geelong - Defenders
16.Hawks - Key defender

Key forward is the last thing we need. Mids, Mids and rucks

 

[Boogoos]

Geelong need forwards dingbat

 

[DockerNJL]

I think Freo need mainly mids with a developing Ruck + Key back.

 

[spartan-magpie]

ill be the 3rd to point it out.. collingwood has an abundunce of forwards - be they kp or creative, and our forward stocks are very good too - we do hoever require mids, mids, mids, mids and more mids.... maybe a kp back would be nice too...

 

[WeninRome]

Basically what i believe Teams mainly need to draft to top up their lists

1. Melbourne - New Team
2. West Coast - Cousins, Judd, Kerr
3. Fremantle - New Club song, colours and the last five years back over again
4. Port Power - developing ruck, key forward
5. Essendon - Key Defenders
6. Carlton - another forward and key defenders
7. Bribane - Midfielders
8. Richmond - 8th place
9. kangaroos -Mids and key forward
10. Collingwood - teeth
11.Sydney - Key position
12.Adelaide - Hlf backs, mids
13.St Kilda - Midfielders
14.Bulldogs - pension
15.Geelong - Defenders
16.Hawks - Key defender

edited for accuracy

 

[worsfold]

Collingwood do not need to draft any more forwards. Midfielders, Midfielders and then maybe a Key Back is what the pies need come draft day.
Rocca
Reid
Rusling
Dawes
Cloke
Anthony
Medhurst etc... Enough forwards as it is.

Rocca has not got much left and only Cloke and Dawes I would call key forwards but Midfields I have already said.

 

[bLuEbOy1984]

Basically what i believe Teams mainly need to draft to top up their lists

1. Melbourne - Key forward
2. West Coast - Midfielder
3. Fremantle - Midfield, Second ruck
4. Port Power - developing ruck, key forward
5. Essendon - Key Defenders
6. Carlton - another forward and key defenders
7. Bribane - Midfielders
8. Richmond - Ruckman, key forward
9. kangaroos -Mids and key forward
10. Collingwood - Mids, key forward
11.Sydney - Key position
12.Adelaide - Hlf backs, mids
13.St Kilda - Midfielders
14.Bulldogs - Key Forward
15.Geelong - Defenders
16.Hawks - Key defender

we actually have alot of defenders, im happy with what we have we have some big men stil developing, and i dont belive we need any more defenders... mind you if we do pick up hurly we can push waite back into the forward line...
waite
jamieson
thornton
bower
setanta
austin
joe anderson for small forwards

what we do need is another key forward and a small rioli type player that would compliment the work betts does...

 

[Grimreepah]

Midfielders and small forwards.

 

[The Dustbin]

Key defender and another ruckman for us.

A mature aged ruckman would be nice... somebody needs to put pressure on Laycock to make him earn his spot. We can't expect B'chambers to be the number 2 ruckman in only his second year. I hope B'Chambers can prove me wrong.

 

[HongKongRoo]

Mate I guess you don't get to see a lot of teams in the west. North needs a key backman more than they need key forwards.

We've got Hale, Azza, Jones (when fit), Petrie, who are all able to take a grab and kick goals.

Tarrant and Smith are starting their second year and will probably get a few games in 2009.

All of the above will be more afl ready in the next two years than anyone we draft.

You are right about the mids though.

 

[bellzy]

Yeah, nah, other than HBF's, I'd say key forwards is the least of North's issues.

Key backs and mids, of both varieties.

Good to see you've done your research though.

 

[spartan-magpie]

Basically what i believe Teams mainly need to draft to top up their lists

1. Melbourne - Key forward
2. West Coast - Midfielder
3. Fremantle - Midfield, Second ruck
4. Port Power - developing ruck, key forward
5. Essendon - Key Defenders
6. Carlton - forwards, backs, morals, ethics, AFL salary cap scrutiny, a finals berth, the development of their own players-as opposed to poaching everybody elses- a board which is not controlled behind the scenes by a criminal billionare....a soul.... supporters who jump back on the band wagon when things are looking up again..
7. Bribane - Midfielders
8. Richmond - Ruckman, key forward
9. kangaroos -Mids and key forward
10. Collingwood - Mids, key back
11.Sydney - Key position
12.Adelaide - Hlf backs, mids
13.St Kilda - Midfielders
14.Bulldogs - Key Forward
15.Geelong - Defenders
16.Hawks - Key defender

edited in the spirit of honesty...

 

[natty]

I thought the Crows had pick 10 ??????

The Crows need a a key forward.

Freo needs a key team ! lol

 

[Parasite]

Looks to me like Adelaide need some supporters with more than half a brain cell between them.

 

[moond0g]

geelong dont need any defenders,

scarlett
harley
egan back from injury
harry taylor
and mackie can all play tall
and heaps of guys that can play small
plus the bottom three are all pretty young

we need one key forward or maybe a quality ruck so that ottens can spend some more time down forward and not have to do all the rucking while blake is on the bench..... what we really need is two ottens'

 

[paran]

WCE don't need "midfielders", we need pace and good kicks who deliver the ball better. We also need less injuries and our young midfielders to phsically mature and gain game experience. But the worst thing last year was the lack of skill in kicking especially - looked like a bunch of kids a lot of the time (funny that).

C'mon NicNat!

 

[LemmingMaster]

geelong dont need any defenders,

scarlett
harley
egan back from injury
harry taylor
and mackie can all play tall
and heaps of guys that can play small
plus the bottom three are all pretty young

we need one key forward or maybe a quality ruck so that ottens can spend some more time down forward and not have to do all the rucking while blake is on the bench..... what we really need is two ottens'

Harley, Milburn and Scarlett are getting older. I would think twice about saying you don't need another key backman.

As for forwards, you have a couple of young forwards that you would hope develop nicely, Tommahawk, Gamble and that Djerrkura (sp?) guy....

Can you name two defenders that have the same potential with coming into your side next year or the year after?

In my eyes the cats need a key defender first and a forward second.

 

[telsor]

Basically what i believe Teams mainly need to draft to top up their lists
8. Richmond - Ruckman, key forward

Pretty much.

We have enough of both already, and while they're doing OK, none really look like setting the world on fire (yet), so better to stock up on more. Particularly looking for those with the X-factor required to be more than just (further) depth.

I also think all clubs can use more quality Mids...You can never have too many, so they're always an option.

 

[AxelFoley]

edited in the spirit of honesty...

Maybe the only time I totally agree with a Collingwood supporter but:

100% agree!

 

[roodav]

Yeah we don't need key forwards really, we spent part of this year trying out whether to convert Tarrant into a defender because we moved Hale up to FF and we have Josh Smith to go there as well.

We will probably take rookie a ruck and maybe take a forward as a rookie but we'll be after midfielders and a fullback if we've any sense.

 

[goodie23]

Saints need key backs as well as mids

 

[Masten2McKinley]

edited in the spirit of honesty...

hahaha that is 100% true

wce need MIDS and a Small Forward

 

[moond0g]

geelong dont need any defenders,

scarlett
harley
egan back from injury
harry taylor
and mackie can all play tall
and heaps of guys that can play small
plus the bottom three are all pretty young

we need one key forward or maybe a quality ruck so that ottens can spend some more time down forward and not have to do all the rucking while blake is on the bench..... what we really need is two ottens'

Harley, Milburn and Scarlett are getting older. I would think twice about saying you don't need another key backman.

As for forwards, you have a couple of young forwards that you would hope develop nicely, Tommahawk, Gamble and that Djerrkura (sp?) guy....

Can you name two defenders that have the same potential with coming into your side next year or the year after?

In my eyes the cats need a key defender first and a forward second.

well i think we'll get a few more years out of those three anyway but even if we dont we've still got three talls in egan taylor and mackie which is more than we have kpf, tomahawk will prob play next year but gamble (who i rate highly) isnt a key position player to small and not much bulk he is a medium/ small forward who roams around... Djerrkura similar, def not key position player, plays up forward an around the middle.

i'm just saying we get alot of goals but most of those come from the amount of ball our midfield gets, if you look at goals / inside 50 were not as good as some other teams so a key forward makes sense.

hopefully tomahawk takes the next step but lonergan isnt going to kick a bag and going by the same logic as you said mooney will be gone soon (only three months younger than scarlett) and then really we dont have any big forwards that will be able to dominate a game